《易說》Vol. 5
About this page. The original text of 《易說》 Vol. 5 (Qing Daoist texts 清代道教文獻, 6 volumes) is shown in Classical Chinese as transmitted in the Kanripo (Kyoto University) edition. An English interpretation of the 119 passages on this page accompanies it: select a passage or press “Interpretation” to show it. All texts in English
Reading modes explained
- Horizontal: ordinary left-to-right reading; the interpretation can be shown.
- Scroll: vertical text running right to left; the wheel scrolls sideways (no interpretation in this mode).
- Wheel: columns of vertical text turn around a drum; use the wheel, drag or arrow keys, or auto-play.
- Pages: about 200 characters per page; use the buttons, swipe or arrow keys.
Source textInterpretation
This passage comes from Explanations on the Changes, a commentary on the Hexian (Influence) hexagram of the Zhouyi (Book of Changes) by Lü Dongbin, the Daoist master revered as the Celestial Master of Pure Yang (Fuyou Shangdi Chunyang Lüzu Tianshi). The Hexian hexagram consists of Gen (Mountain) below and Dui (Lake) above, symbolizing mutual resonance and connection.
The hexagram statement reads: "Success. Perseverance brings good fortune. Taking a wife brings good fortune." The Tuanzhuan commentary explains that Xian means resonance—where the yielding (yin) is above and the firm (yang) below, the two Qi (vital energies) interact and unite. Just as a man humbly courts a woman, this brings success and good fortune. When heaven and earth resonate, all things are born; when sages resonate with human hearts, the world finds peace. Observing this phenomenon of resonance reveals the nature of all things under heaven.
The Daxiang commentary notes: The image of a lake atop a mountain teaches the noble person to embrace others with an open and receptive mind. The individual line statements are interpreted as follows:
- The first six (yin at the bottom): Resonance reaches the toes—showing the mind is directed outward.
- The second six: Resonance reaches the calves—though there is danger, remaining still brings good fortune; yielding avoids harm.
- The third nine (yang): Resonance reaches the thighs—forcing oneself to follow others leads to regret.
- The fourth nine: Holding to the correct path brings good fortune and dispels regret. Though the mind wavers, friends will support your thoughts.
- The fifth nine: Resonance reaches the back—no regret, but the aspiration is not yet grand.
- The top six: Resonance reaches the cheeks and tongue—indicating eloquence in speech.
Lü Dongbin further elaborates: Xian is the resonance of hearts and minds. Heaven and earth are distinguished by their positions but united by Qi; when mountain and lake connect, all things respond. Heaven and earth resonate through Qi; sages resonate through the heart-mind (Shen). The heart-mind can extend everywhere, connecting all things within and without—hence the term "successful resonance" (Xianheng). Deliberate resonance lacks harmony; only spontaneous, natural resonance remains pure and correct, like the good fortune in taking a wife.
This hexagram takes Gen (Mountain) as its substance and Dui (Lake) as its function, embodying the principle of yielding (yin) returning to the firm (yang). With the yielding above and the firm below, the two Qi interact and unite. Originally, Gen (firm) above and Dui (yielding) below could not resonate, but now Dui is above Gen—stillness harmonizes with joy, peacefully transforming the world, which in turn responds peacefully. Those who uphold the Dao (Way) in resonance and response will naturally achieve corresponding results when the time is right.
This passage elucidates the principle of "resonance" (ganying). Heaven and Earth resonate with all things through upright Qi (vital energy), and though all beings originate from this same Qi, they remain unaware of how they are nurtured and grown. The sage resonates with the world through a desireless mind, and though all under heaven stem from this same mind, they know not how harmony and tranquility are achieved. Observing this phenomenon of resonance reveals that the establishment of cosmic order and the nourishment of all things arise from the natural communion of sincere hearts—no trace of artificiality or pretense can intrude upon it.
Just as a mountain humbly receives nourishment from lakes and marshes (an image from the Xian hexagram of the Yijing), the noble person embodying this principle maintains an open mind to embrace others. Only when mountains are hollow can they store water; only when minds are empty can they accommodate others. If selfish desires and preconceptions infiltrate this resonance, the heart becomes narrow and obstructed, incapable of true inclusion. By cultivating stillness within, maintaining a state of serene immobility and boundless selflessness—like a clear mirror or placid water—one naturally preserves emptiness and tranquility when encountering external phenomena, thereby resonating with the world without attachment. Emptiness and stillness are fundamental, which is why among the six lines of the hexagram, those representing stillness are deemed auspicious.
To elaborate: The initial line shows the first stirrings of resonance, like a slight movement of the big toe—thoughts arise before events manifest. This represents minor fluctuations that do not disrupt fundamental stillness. The second line resembles restless calves; the yin nature tends toward agitation and struggles to comply, easily inviting misfortune. Yet if one remains content in their proper place without reckless action, good fortune may still be attained. The third line is like thighs losing their yang vigor—without inner mastery, one drifts with the currents, willingly submitting to others' control without adaptability, inevitably bringing regret. The fourth line occupies the central position among three yang lines (symbolizing the heart), governing resonance. Yang residing in a yin position risks straying from the proper path, so one must maintain steadfast correctness. The restless back-and-forth of an unsettled mind is not the true Way. The fifth line resembles a spine desiring movement yet able to remain still—though influenced by the second line's impulse to act, the admonitions of the fourth line and its own firm virtue at the center enable it to preserve stillness. It is like swallowing words at the lips' edge, exercising cautious resonance rather than careless speech.
(Note: "Xian" refers to the 31st hexagram of the Yijing, symbolizing resonance; the "six lines" denote the hexagram's six line statements; "zhen" means upholding correctness; "chongchong" describes a restless, unsettled state of mind.)
This passage primarily discusses two core concepts: "resonance" (感应) and "constancy" (恒常).
Regarding "resonance": The top sixth yin line (referring to the uppermost broken line in the Yijing) represents the extreme of resonance, yet it loses sincerity by relying solely on superficial gestures to please others. Attempting to move people through voice and facial expressions constitutes shallow resonance. True resonance with the Dao requires an empty mind and upright response—one must receptively embrace with humility and respond with rectitude, aligning with the natural harmony of original substance and returning to the Dao's spontaneous nurturing through non-intention. Those in lower positions shouldn't let emotions descend into servility, while those in higher positions shouldn't reveal traces through words. Resonance operates like body parts—where alignment is skewed, resonance skews; where alignment is upright, resonance remains upright.
Concerning "constancy": The Heng hexagram (composed of Xun below and Zhen above) symbolizes enduring prosperity. The Dao of heaven and earth operates through perpetual constancy. The sun and moon endure illumination by following celestial patterns; the four seasons accomplish all things through cyclical transformations; sages achieve universal transformation by steadfastly maintaining proper principles. Observing the principle of constancy reveals the essential nature of all phenomena.
The noble person should emulate thunder and wind in maintaining unwavering constancy, establishing immutable principles. Yet different line positions offer distinct warnings: the initial six warns against seeking excessive depth at the outset; the second nine exemplifies enduring adherence to the Middle Way; the third nine shows disgrace in failing to maintain virtuous constancy; the fourth nine demonstrates how prolonged residence in improper positions yields no harvest; the fifth six indicates auspiciousness for women's chastity but misfortune for men; the top six signifies failure through shaking constancy's foundation.
Finally, it reveals: The fundamental pattern of heaven and earth is stillness—movement exists to preserve constancy. Movement within stillness constitutes the core of creation, while stillness within movement serves as creation's function. In stillness, principles become established; in movement, vital energy flows unceasingly.
This passage expounds on the principles of the "Heng Hexagram" (恒卦) from the Book of Changes. The Heng Hexagram is formed by Xun (Wind) below and Zhen (Thunder) above, symbolizing a state where strength resides above and gentleness below, with yang firmness embedded within yin softness.
The enduring nature of the Heng Hexagram lies in its adherence to the correct path. The constancy of heaven and earth's movements stems precisely from their obedience to unchanging laws. The perpetual motion of the sun and moon represents Heng (恒, constancy), as does the cyclical alternation of the four seasons. When sages govern the world using this principle, their virtuous achievements endure—this too is Heng. The hexagram draws its imagery from thunder following wind, where the principle of firmness above and gentleness below remains fixed, and the ceaseless movement of Zhen emerging and Xun entering continues endlessly.
Those who disrupt natural patterns fail to understand principle, while those rigidly bound by convention fail to grasp adaptability. Only those who comprehend the Dao of change can truly master the principle of constancy. As the Book of Changes states: "When things reach their limit, they transform; through transformation comes penetration, and through penetration comes lasting endurance." The noble person who realizes this principle can assess circumstances and respond to myriad changes without losing their foundation.
The scripture illustrates this through examples: The "excessive pursuit of constancy" (浚恒) in the initial six yao line and the "shaking of constancy" (振恒) in the top six yao line both demonstrate a misunderstanding of the Dao of Heng. The initial six, a yin line in the lowest position, cannot resonate with the nine in the fourth place and is obstructed by the six in the second and nine in the third—yet it forcibly seeks depth, hence "excessive pursuit." The top six, a yin line at the apex where Heng is about to transform, also occupies the extreme of Zhen's agitation, wavering uncontrollably and unable to maintain stillness—thus "shaking constancy." The nine in the fourth place, a yang line in a yin position, inappropriately seeks to preserve normalcy, resulting in indecision and failed endeavors. These all exemplify acting contrary to the times and misunderstanding the Dao of constancy.
This scripture primarily discusses principles for personal conduct and governing the world. Using hunting as a metaphor, it illustrates how constant preoccupation with trivial matters brings no benefit to spiritual cultivation. When someone of inadequate capability occupies a high position (yin occupying a yang position), they tend to become indecisive, lacking resolution, which causes ministers to lose achievements and rulers to forfeit dignity—much like a wife who blindly obeys her husband without flexibility.
The text mentions that while some people's actions may deviate, their hearts can maintain equilibrium (residing in centrality), understanding how to balance convention with adaptability. If one's virtue is unsteady like the third line (yao), with a wavering heart, it invites disgrace. The phrase "regret vanishes" doesn't mean the absence of faults but rather the ability to correct them promptly.
The author categorizes the different line positions into several types: the fourth and fifth lines represent capable gentlemen, the ninth-third line represents petty individuals with flawed virtue, while the first and top lines, though talented, deviate from the proper path. Only the ninth-second line approaches the ideal state, though its position is somewhat weak and not perfect.
The text emphasizes that the principle of all things lies in the ability to both act and maintain, to establish footing while advancing. The most perilous is the top sixth line, as it completely fails to gain a firm foothold. Stillness governs agitation, and stability forms the foundation of action—without maintaining stillness and stability, one cannot truly stand firm.
Regarding the interpretation of the "Dun hexagram" (symbolizing retreat): this hexagram signifies that retreat can also bring prosperity. When those in power (the yang lines) are properly positioned and act in accordance with the times, though only minor gains may be achieved, the trend gradually strengthens. The noble person should distance themselves from petty individuals, maintaining dignity without hatred.
Revelations from each line:
First six: Danger lies in lagging behind during retreat; advancing is inadvisable.
Second six: Firmly resolve the heart like binding with ox-hide.
Ninth three: Being entangled and unable to retreat brings distress; suitable for managing household affairs rather than great undertakings.
Ninth four: The noble person who understands timely retreat attains good fortune.
(Note: The "yao" refers to the component lines of the Yi Jing hexagram, counted from bottom to top, totaling six lines—yang lines are called "nine," yin lines "six.")
This passage from the Yi Shuo explains the wisdom of the "Dun Gua" (Hexagram of Retreat), which symbolizes withdrawal and seclusion. When petty individuals gain power, noble persons understand the importance of timely withdrawal, whereas petty individuals cannot. The fifth line (九五爻) shows that withdrawing at the right moment preserves the correct path and brings auspiciousness, as it maintains an upright and resolute will. The topmost line (上九爻) states that complete withdrawal brings no harm, as the mind is already free from doubt.
The sage knows to observe subtle signs—when yin forces (symbolizing petty individuals) begin to rise, they choose to retreat to preserve their aspirations and uphold the correct path. This low-profile cultivation, without revealing one's traces, may seem obstructed but is ultimately smooth and successful. This hexagram takes Gen (Mountain ☶) as its substance and Qian (Heaven ☰) as its function, embodying the principle of yang restraining yin. Although yin gradually grows, it has not yet reached full strength, and the correct path has not entirely vanished. If one remains grounded and makes good use of timing, minor benefits can still be attained.
The noble person foresees the signs and withdraws early. Though this allows them to maintain purity, it cannot bring the entire world back to the correct path. The fifth line, with its firm yang position, actively adapts to the times—outwardly not seeking novelty, inwardly not forcing uniformity—carefully observing changes to preserve oneself. The hexagram takes the image of "a mountain beneath heaven," where the mountain (yin) rises from the earth to approach heaven (yang), yet ultimately cannot truly threaten heaven. The noble person, seeing the early signs, naturally inclines toward retreat. In cultivating this principle, one should distance themselves from petty individuals but need not do so with harsh words or stern expressions. Simply maintaining strict self-discipline will naturally keep petty individuals at bay.
The bottom line (初爻) symbolizes the petty forces still being weak, secretly scheming—like a tail trying to hide but inevitably being exposed. At this stage, their growth must be restrained. The second line, being central, understands when to withdraw; it is appropriate to restrain and conceal without revealing form. However, as yin gradually advances and presses upon yang, petty individuals gain momentum. While they can still be resisted when weak, once they grow strong, they become difficult to control.
This passage explores the wisdom of the "Retreat" (Dun) hexagram from the Book of Changes (Yijing), offering modern insights on managing relationships with petty individuals and the philosophy of strategic withdrawal.
When dealing with petty people, brute force suppression proves ineffective. Instead, one should stabilize the situation through balanced and yielding De (Virtue). This approach prevents adversaries from succeeding while preserving one's own principles. The third yang line, positioned above yin lines, faces susceptibility to confusion and hesitation—much like managing household servants. Bestow kindness but withhold substantial authority, thus rendering petty individuals useful without allowing harm.
Those bearing significant responsibilities may find immediate withdrawal impractical while in office. Yet they can subtly guide affairs by harmonizing all things—a retreat not in form but in spiritual transcendence. However, when confronting matters of fundamental right and wrong, compromise akin to handling servants becomes unacceptable. Some yearn for retreat yet cling to wealth and status—this half-hearted attitude demands vigilance. Only complete relinquishment of selfish desires brings true inner freedom.
The ideal retreat (represented by the fifth yang line) aligns with circumstances, wisely discerning timing to maintain integrity while adapting flexibly. The top yang line achieves the supreme state: serene spirit, transcendent detachment, and freedom from external entanglements. This "unrestrained retreat" (feidun) establishes one's life through Dao and righteousness—quietly supporting yang energy while covertly nurturing all beings.
Retreat appears as adversity but is actually "successful withdrawal" (dunheng)—preserving oneself wisely to await opportunity. Like Bo Yi and Shu Qi who embodied principles through sacrifice, or Confucius and Mencius who taught through words, such withdrawal temporarily shelters worldly aspirations in mountain forests, avoiding petty vulgarity to ultimately realize prosperity. Mere self-righteous austerity or forced asceticism that neglects others falls short of the noble retreat befitting a junzi (noble person).
The final hexagram image (Qian below, Zhen above) forms "Great Strength" (Dazhuang), symbolizing peak vigor. Firmness in action brings power, yet adherence to the upright Dao remains essential for benefit.
The "Great Strength" (Dazhuang) hexagram in the Book of Changes elucidates the proper application of masculine vigor (Yang qi). The movement of heaven and earth manifests through uprightness and steadfast strength. The hexagram image shows thunder resounding across the sky (Zhen/Thunder above, Qian/Heaven below), symbolizing that the noble person should act in accordance with the correct path.
The initial Nine line (the bottom Yang line) warns that excessive force in the toes brings danger when advancing rashly. This admonishes us that strength applied recklessly from a low position often leads to failure due to impulsiveness. The second Nine line, centered and correct, brings good fortune, demonstrating the importance of maintaining the Middle Way. The third Nine line cautions against petty people misusing brute force while noble persons hesitate—like a ram butting a fence only to get its horns stuck—showing how improper strength invites peril.
The fourth Nine line reveals that holding to the correct path dispels regret, like breaking through a fence without injuring one's horns, or like a sturdy axle that enables bold advance. The fifth Six line describes losing a ram at the field's edge without regret, for occupying an improper position (Yin line in a Yang place) means one shouldn't force outcomes. The top Six line depicts a ram trapped in the fence, unable to advance or retreat, illustrating how blind obstinacy brings no benefit—only enduring hardship can transform misfortune into fortune.
The Great Strength hexagram overall shows four Yang lines overpowering two Yin lines, symbolizing flourishing Yang energy. Yet the noble person understands true strength lies not in overpowering others but in aligning with heavenly principle. Just as thunder resounds through the sky (Zhen as Thunder, Qian as Heaven), the noble must act with dignified resolve to eliminate wrongdoing—yet always in accordance with ritual propriety. Excessive rigidity invites disaster, and reckless advance courts failure; thus the hexagram statement emphasizes "perseverance in correctness brings benefit."
The key insight: governing others begins with self-cultivation. During times of strength, one must exercise greater self-restraint, maintaining the vast, righteous qi that fills heaven and earth. Initial arrogance (initial Nine line) leads to ruin through recklessness, whereas upholding the Middle Way (second Nine line) brings auspicious outcomes. This teaches us that strength must be tempered with wisdom and moderation.
This passage explains the symbolic meanings of each line in the "Great Strength" hexagram (Dazhuang) from the Book of Changes, analyzing the behavioral principles represented by different line positions.
The initial line (bottom line) symbolizes someone who acts too aggressively when beginning an endeavor, thereby losing the balanced middle way. The second line represents using firmness to govern gentleness, capable of dissolving conflict and avoiding unnecessary disputes—this position maintains the correct path. The third line resides at the culmination of the Qian trigram (symbolizing heaven and strength), where excessive firmness leads to reckless action. Here, petty men use shameless boldness to spy on noble individuals, and if the noble fail to recognize such schemes and take precautions, they too are guilty of overbearing force. Thus, though their intentions may be upright, unawareness of danger ultimately thwarts their aspirations.
The fourth line stands at the beginning of the Zhen trigram (symbolizing thunder and action), neither excessively firm nor impulsive, leaving petty men no opportunity to create obstacles. The "strong chariot" metaphor here signifies that inner fullness prevents failure—by skillfully concealing strength and awaiting the right moment, one naturally moves freely without fear of collapse. While the third line faces obstruction, the fourth does not, illustrating how circumstances differ. Though not the most honored position, as the guiding force of the Great Strength hexagram, it commands multiple yang lines to resolve yin affairs, shouldering the world's burdens to achieve merit—precisely what sages value.
When obstacles are already removed and yin forces retreat, maintaining strength like a sturdy chariot axle guards against yin's resurgence. The fourth line's obstruction stems from yin, while the third's comes from yang. Using yang to oppose yin can break barriers, but yang confronting yang brings mutual harm. If noble individuals become divided while contending with petty men, their strength scatters and success eludes them. The third line's aim isn't wrong, but its method is flawed: suppressing petty men with force to dominate only breeds resistance, while trapping noble individuals beneath nets alienates potential allies. Like a ram butting a fence and getting stuck, progress stalls without support.
The fifth line occupies a high position through yielding softness, becoming too weak to assert itself while others exploit his passivity. Had he restrained forceful tendencies early when yang energies first rose, avoiding oppressive dominance, even firmness wouldn't have caused harm. Hence "losing the sheep on level ground" warns of preparing defenses before danger arrives. The top sixth line reaches strength's end and change's extreme—though naturally gentle, it resorts to force at the wrong time, misunderstanding circumstances. Thus it faces dilemmas. Yet recognizing the difficulty and proceeding with cautious deliberation...
This passage elucidates the wisdom of the "Jin Hexagram" from the Classic of Changes (Yijing), whose core teaching demonstrates how to advance through yielding to strength.
First, it explains principles for human conduct: Gentleness that can adapt to strength brings good fortune. For the strong yang aspect, one should decisively handle yin matters; for the yielding yin aspect, one must remain vigilant not to violate yang principles. The sages established these rules not out of aversion to yin or hatred toward petty people, but to prevent them from causing harm. Thus, the noble person (junzi) employs strength through the firmness of heavenly Virtue (De), manifesting the intrinsic nature of heaven and earth. Heaven and earth's nature toward all things is ceaseless generation, while the sage's nature toward all things is benevolence. Governing the world with this cosmic disposition means even when dealing with petty people, there's no intent to deliberately harm. To contend and foster enmity with them would violate heaven and earth's righteous and luminous nature.
The commentary then specifically interprets the Jin Hexagram (Kun below, Li above, symbolizing earth supporting brightness):
The Jin Hexagram signifies advancement, with brightness rising from the earth. Its imagery shows yielding submission attached to illumination, gently progressing upward. Like Marquis Kang (a virtuous minister assisting the ruler) receiving from the Son of Heaven numerous horses and multiple audiences in a single day, the noble person should emulate this hexagram by manifesting their luminous Virtue.
The meanings of individual lines:
First Six: Advancement meets obstruction, but maintaining correctness brings good fortune. Even if temporarily distrusted, remaining magnanimous avoids fault.
Second Six: Advancing amid sorrow; maintaining correctness brings great blessings originating from the Queen Mother (symbolizing the yielding, venerable feminine).
Third Six: Gaining the people's trust makes regret vanish.
Fourth Nine: Advancing like a flying squirrel (metaphor for insatiable greed) brings danger even when upright.
Fifth Six: Regret disappears. Without calculating gain or loss, advancing courageously brings good fortune.
Top Nine: Advancing to the apex (like an animal's horn) enables conquering cities. Though perilous, ultimately harmless—yet one must guard against excessive rigidity.
Summarizing the Jin Hexagram's essence: Jin means advancement through seizing opportunities by Virtue. Marquis Kang, as a virtuous minister assisting his ruler, earned the Son of Heaven's appreciation through gentle submission and balanced merit, while the ruler drew near him through yielding and centered Virtue—hence receiving abundant rewards. This hexagram takes Kun (earth) as foundation and Li (fire) as function, embodying yin's yielding to yang. In eras of universal peace where enlightened rulers and worthy ministers complement each other, all noble persons should actively advance to establish merit.
This passage elucidates wisdom in human conduct and ruler-subject relations, with "integrity and uprightness" at its core.
One should serve superiors with reverence and treat subordinates with clarity and impartiality. When one’s inner virtue is bright and unblemished, it is only natural to gain the recognition of an enlightened ruler. Just as the sun rises from the earth, fire burns brighter when nourished at its source. A true noble cultivates inner virtue (De) without deliberate display or reliance on external validation. Instead, they maintain discernment to distinguish right from wrong, use wisdom to guard against danger, act with prudence, and return to the innate radiance of the heart.
The text employs the six lines (yao, the fundamental symbols of divination in the Yijing) to illustrate different situations:
- The first line (bottom position) symbolizes talent obstructed by petty individuals—here, one must learn restraint.
- The second line represents steadfast adherence to the right path without drifting—only through such cautious conduct can auspiciousness be attained.
- The third line depicts like-minded individuals supporting one another with sincerity.
- The fourth line resembles those without virtue occupying high positions, like timid rats plagued by hesitation.
- The fifth line, though imperfect in governance, still commands respect through wise leadership.
- The top line, if restless, invites danger, but if directed toward subduing defiant states, it brings success.
A key emphasis is the need to abandon greed: subordinates rushing to please superiors is not the right path, nor is a ruler hastily currying favor with subordinates. Initial distrust (wang fu) may arise, but persistence to the third stage earns collective approval (zhong yun). The highest state is exemplified by the fifth line—detached from gain or loss—while the top line focuses solely on resolving concrete matters.
(Note: "Yao" refers to the hexagram lines in the Yijing; "shí shǔ" (鼫鼠) denotes field mice, symbolizing indecisiveness; "Jìn" (晋) is the 35th hexagram of the Yijing, representing progress and illumination.)
This passage discusses the "Mingyi" hexagram (Earth above Fire, symbolizing light entering the earth) from the Book of Changes (Yijing), primarily expounding on how virtuous individuals should conduct themselves in dark circumstances.
"Mingyi" signifies light being wounded, much like the sun sinking beneath the earth. The hexagram shows inner brightness (Li trigram) coupled with outer gentleness (Kun trigram). King Wen of Zhou employed this wisdom to endure his imprisonment, while Jizi (a virtuous minister of the Shang dynasty) likewise preserved his aspirations under a tyrant's rule.
Detailed line interpretations:
The first yang line describes a virtuous person like an injured bird flying low, traveling for three days without food—illustrating the need for endurance in adversity. The second yin line speaks of injuring the left leg but being rescued by a good horse, showing how following proper rules can turn danger into safety. The third yang line advises achieving great success in a southern hunt but warns against impatience. The fourth yin line discusses penetrating the enemy's camp to understand the truth. The fifth yin line uses Jizi as an example to emphasize upholding righteousness amid darkness. The top yin line cautions: though one may initially ascend to heaven and illuminate all directions, falling into the earth ultimately results from abandoning principles.
The core teaching is this: When virtuous individuals face a foolish ruler, they must maintain inner radiance (the De of civilization) while outwardly appearing gentle (adapting to external darkness). They should neither confront directly and invite disaster nor compromise their integrity by conforming to corruption. Instead, they ought to conceal their brilliance, endure temporary hardships, and subtly uphold the Dao—preserving themselves while advancing righteousness in secret. Just as the sun may temporarily sink below the earth, its light never truly extinguishes.
This scripture discusses how ministers should conduct themselves when serving a foolish ruler. Using King Wen of Zhou and Jizi (the uncle of King Zhou of Shang) as examples, it illustrates: though King Wen possessed noble virtue, he was still imprisoned by King Zhou; Jizi, facing tyranny, had to feign madness to preserve his life. These are manifestations of "holding fast to the Dao in adversity while concealing one's wisdom."
The text emphasizes that a minister's duty is to avoid harming the ruler at all costs, even if it means suffering injury oneself. Just as the earth (the way of Kun) eternally follows the way of Heaven, King Wen and Jizi exemplified ultimate compliance. Some compare their actions to the revolutions of Tang of Shang and Wu of Zhou, who overthrew tyrants, but this is mistaken—the revolutions of Tang and Wu were extreme measures taken as a last resort, not models to be routinely emulated.
The hexagram imagery shows brightness (ming) buried beneath the earth (yi), symbolizing how the wise must conceal their wisdom within while displaying gentleness without. The sixth line of the hexagram represents the foolish ruler—initially exalted and harming virtuous ministers, but ultimately reaping the consequences to the point of losing even commoner status. The first five lines depict five approaches for ministers: the first line signifies seizing opportunities to preserve oneself; the second resembles a minister with an injured left leg, wishing to serve but constrained at every turn; the third shows concern for the state and people despite holding no official position; the fourth advises tactful remonstration even in dark times; the fifth follows Jizi's example of guarding the Dao through unconventional means. These methods all aim to fulfill loyal duties without further impairing the ruler's clarity.
This passage discusses how virtuous individuals should conduct themselves during times of political darkness. Leaving the court (departing from centers of power) serves to keep harmful influences at bay, much like the Legalist school (which emphasized rule by law) and remonstrating ministers who dared to speak truth to power. Though such actions may bring personal losses, they cause no harm to the ruler.
The fifth line symbolizes a gentle and upright person navigating dark circumstances. As a high-ranking minister facing internal turmoil, one should conceal wisdom without revealing it, maintaining proper resolve without confusion—this is the correct approach to handle the "Ming Yi" (Brightness Wounded) hexagram situation. Speaking and acting too directly would harm both superiors and subordinates, which is why Jizi (a wise minister of the Shang dynasty) chose to conceal his wisdom.
The third line mentions "hunting in the south," akin to King Wen of Zhou's campaigns against the Chong and Mi states, which aimed to eliminate forces harming the ruler. The phrase "possessing two-thirds of the world" refers to using this majority influence to bring the Shang dynasty to submission, not to submit oneself. This represents the ultimate expression of yielding flexibility.
"Grasping the major issue" is like Chen Ping and Zhou Bo eliminating the Lü clan, or Li Guangbi and Guo Ziyi suppressing the An Lushan Rebellion—one can see their intentions but not fully realize their ideals. "Not rushing to correct" (不可疾贞) reflects how matters of loyalty between ruler and subject, as well as military campaigns, must only be undertaken as a last resort. One cannot hastily abandon dark circumstances to display righteousness.
The sage uses wisdom to navigate darkness, deciding whether to stay or leave based on what aligns with righteousness. Departing when appropriate demonstrates purity; remaining when necessary demonstrates loyalty. Hesitating when one should leave or failing to rectify when one should stay are both incorrect. For instance, the first line suggests leaving when in a lowly position, while the second line suggests staying when properly placed—from the second to the fifth line, one ought to remain. How could sages, who care deeply for the people, bear to leave merely to flaunt their purity? They only consider departure after careful assessment of the situation, and even then, as a last resort.
In orderly times, the phoenix soars upward, but in chaotic times, "Ming Yi" descends—hence the phrase "drooping its wings." "Going three days without eating" describes extreme hardship. Voluntarily stepping down from high office to a humble position invites suspicion from ordinary people; withdrawing before chaos fully erupts provokes envy from the cunning. Moreover, in dark ages, people resent those of high integrity, making slander inevitable. But why should noble-minded individuals, who uphold purity and righteousness, concern themselves with others' words? They preserve a greater righteousness. Confucius left to protect the ruler of Lu, and Lord Shen (possibly Shen Peigong) departed to safeguard greater interests.
This passage from the Yi Shuo (Explanations of the Changes) discusses two main sections:
The first part explores the wisdom of navigating adversity through the "Mingyi" hexagram (明夷卦, "Darkening of the Light"). When the sovereign (天王) faces difficulties, even departure has its purpose, while those who remain also have their reasons. Assisting others must follow the Dao—delayed intervention may harm ministers and disrupt order. Sages in chaotic times each fulfill their roles differently: like birds that fly not for height, servants who serve not from lowliness, rescuers of horses who act not in haste, southern hunters who pursue not just conquest, or those entering danger who expose not directly. The key lies in holding firm to the correct path (贞 zhen), using proper principles to govern disorder. When aiding the wounded, one must exhaust all means, never bearing to speak of the ruler's faults. Alas! Using obscurity to reveal light—is this truly the sage's preference?
The second section provides detailed commentary on the "Jiaren" hexagram (家人卦, "Family Members"). This wind-over-fire symbol (离下巽上) illustrates household management, particularly emphasizing women's role in maintaining virtue. The judgment states: In family life, women govern internally while men manage external affairs—this division aligns with heaven-earth principles. Parents resemble stern rulers; when fathers, sons, brothers, and spouses each keep their proper places, the household becomes rectified, and with rectified households, the world finds peace. Wind arising from fire (巽 as wind, 离 as fire) signifies that noble persons should speak with evidence and act with constancy.
Line interpretations:
- First Nine: Preventing domestic troubles early brings no regret
- Second Six: Women devoted to household duties, maintaining virtue, receive good fortune
- Third Nine: Excessive strictness in household heads brings regret yet fortune; if women and children indulge in constant amusement, misfortune follows
- Fourth Six: Enriching the family brings great fortune
- Fifth Nine: When the ruler visits the home, worry not—fortune comes
- Top Nine: Maintaining sincerity and dignity brings ultimate fortune
Conclusion: The Yijing takes yin-yang transformation as its fundamental principle. The "Jiaren" hexagram reveals that governing states begins with ordering households. Household management requires proper internal-external divisions, while self-cultivation demands a clear conscience. Domestic disorder often stems from women, necessitating strict distinctions between chastity and license, clarifying obedience to rectify customs. This hexagram takes 巽 xun (compliance) as its substance and 离 li (illumination) as function, embodying yang's restraint of yin.
This scripture primarily discusses the relationship between household governance and state governance, emphasizing the importance of men and women each fulfilling their respective roles within the family.
The foundation of governing a state lies in managing households, and the root of household management rests in the moral cultivation of women. Women should uphold the virtue (De) of gentleness and compliance, maintaining proper conduct within the domestic sphere, while men should embody the virtue of strength and vigor, upholding their proper role in external affairs. When both genders maintain their appropriate positions—when firmness and yielding complement each other—conflict cannot arise, and thus the household becomes well-ordered. Therefore, the sages regarded setting exemplary models as their primary achievement and considered household regulation as the manifestation of virtuous conduct.
Although men and women may live together in a household for a long time, they may easily pursue superficial harmony at the expense of principles. There must be an authoritative head of household who maintains proper order internally, so that moral instruction can be implemented between father and son, elder and younger brothers, and husband and wife. This establishes proper hierarchy between senior and junior, noble and humble, allowing family relationships to naturally fulfill their respective duties. When household governance reaches this level, it can be called rectified. When households are rectified, the world can achieve harmony as if it were one family.
The scripture uses the metaphor "wind arises from fire" to illustrate the importance of domestic moral cultivation. Just as wind originates from fire—with fire being its source—the family is the source of moral transformation. Just as objects must conform to the nature of fire, family members must follow the teachings of the household head—the principle is the same. The noble person who understands the source of moral transformation will pay attention to their own words and actions. For speech and conduct are the pivot of a noble person: though originating from oneself, they influence others; though beginning nearby, they reach distant places—all stemming from rectified intentions and sincere thoughts.
Specifically:
When first establishing a household, one must establish correct ethical relationships and manage domestic affairs with wisdom, thereby avoiding regrets caused by impropriety.
Women should be chaste, composed, virtuous, and gentle, contentedly attending to household duties—this constitutes maintaining proper order internally.
If household management becomes excessively strict, it may harm familial affection and ultimately lead to loss of reverence among family members, damaging ethical relationships.
Gentleness that maintains principles, harmony between internal and external affairs, the ability to both generate resources and practice frugality—these ensure the prosperity of family fortunes.
One should regard benevolence (ren) and righteousness (yi) as the path to prosperity, not seeking gain through exploiting others.
This scripture primarily discusses wisdom in familial relations and interpersonal interactions, divided into two parts:
The first part addresses the Dao of household management. The key to family harmony lies in balancing firmness and gentleness - spouses should maintain both emotional intimacy and proper ritual decorum. When family members grow lax through prolonged familiarity, one should engage in self-reflection, using sincerity to preserve bonds, rectifying oneself before influencing others. In governing a household, it's better to err on the side of reverence and rigor than to descend into casual disrespect. This embodies the fundamental principle of Yin-Yang harmony, which should never be treated lightly.
The second part expounds the wisdom of the "Kuai Hexagram" (symbolizing divergence and contradiction). Just as fire burns upward while water flows downward, two women living together may have differing aspirations. Yet heaven and earth demonstrate how seemingly opposite forces actually complement each other - the crucial approach is "seeking common ground while preserving differences": handle minor matters by following natural tendencies; when encountering difficulties, patiently await transformation (like a lost horse returning on its own); interact with others through mutual trust; ultimately, all suspicions will dissipate like rain washing things clean.
The deeper meaning of the Kuai Hexagram reveals that superficial separation and opposition actually contain higher-level harmony and unity. In human relationships, true wisdom lies in finding common understanding while preserving differences - this constitutes the authentic Dao of harmonious interaction.
This scripture discusses how when discord arises within families or nations and people's hearts are not united, it becomes difficult to immediately achieve great things through unity. One can only implement remedial measures to maintain the situation while awaiting a turning point. Viewing problems from a grand perspective makes them harder to resolve, whereas starting with small steps proves relatively easier—hence handling minor matters is considered more auspicious.
The text employs the characteristics of fire (Li trigram) and water (Dui trigram) as metaphors: fire burns upward, while water moistens downward; strong things naturally expand, while gentle things naturally withdraw—these are inherent differences in the nature of all things. Just as two women living in the same house may have different aspirations, coexistence does not guarantee harmony. Yet why is handling small matters considered auspicious? Because maintaining a joyful heart aligned with the light (referring to the right path), advancing gently upward while upholding the middle way and responding to strength, allows for mutual sincerity within and without, fostering harmony between above and below without resistance.
If there is only brightness without joy, the atmosphere becomes inharmonious; if one only knows advancement without gentleness, virtue lacks humility; if one is strong without responding to others, the will lacks modesty—such extremes inevitably lead to conflict. How then can one receive the aid of the worthy? Thus, the greatest fear in human affairs is disunity of hearts, yet the patterns of heaven and earth inherently contain differences. The sages, concerned that people's virtue might not be expansive enough or their analogies not broad enough, therefore expounded their functions by integrating the three powers: heaven, earth, and humanity.
Heaven and earth have distinctions of above and below (these are differences), yet their function of nurturing all things is the same; families have distinctions of inner and outer (these are differences), yet the shared purpose of husband and wife is interconnected; all things have distinctions of noble and humble (these are differences), yet their mutual needs are similar in nature. Understanding these subtle principles reveals that seemingly separate states actually contain unity—one must not only perceive superficial differences.
The hexagram image of fire above and marsh below (referring to the Kui hexagram) symbolizes the combination of things with differing natures. Fire ascending and marsh descending is like the qi of heaven and earth failing to intermingle—this represents the most pronounced state of opposition. The noble person embodies this principle in conduct: when among the multitude, they maintain their uniqueness; outwardly, they do not deliberately oppose others, nor inwardly do they blindly conform. In fusion, they preserve difference; in difference, they seek fusion—this is the profound application of the "Kui" (difference) principle.
The hexagram speaks of the way of difference, so the individual line statements cannot be treated uniformly—sameness contains difference, and difference contains sameness. Moreover, the pattern of physical change is such that what is initially the same may later differ, and what begins in opposition may ultimately unite—difference is not eternal. When difference reaches its extreme, it reverses; thus, the topmost line of the hexagram shows the omen of "encountering rain"—the descent of rain (symbolizing harmony) signifies the resolution of conflict.
When yin and yang are harmoniously balanced, they can resolve the state of separation (kui) and reunite. However, during the process of separation and transformation, suspicion arises between the upper and lower forces. At this point, strong and resolute energy must be employed to restrain the doubts of the weak—only by dispelling suspicion can harmony be achieved. Hence, it is said, "The suspicions of the multitude vanish" (qun yi wang ye). The principle governing all things is this: trust leads to unity, and unity deepens trust; suspicion leads to division, and division intensifies suspicion. Suspicion is the way of petty individuals, not the proper path for governing the world.
For example, the first and fourth lines are both yang (firm) lines: the first line states, "meeting with an evil person," referring to an encounter without prejudice when good and evil are not yet clear; the fourth line speaks of "mutual sincerity" (jiao fu), where trust is given without hesitation because virtues align and hearts connect. The second line corresponds with the fifth, and the third with the top line, but since the third and fifth lines are both yin (yielding), they carry symbolic punishments like "biting through tender flesh" (shi fu) or "having the nose cut off" (yi yi). The first line mentions "losing a horse"—horses, among all creatures, belong to yang and possess the ability to find their way, symbolizing a person free of suspicion. However, being in the early stage of separation, they cannot yet dispel the doubts of the multitude. The fourth line's "solitude in separation" (kui gu) reflects being distrusted by others, but upon encountering a "great man" (yuan fu), trust is established with noble individuals.
The second line's "meeting the lord in a narrow lane" illustrates the adaptive approach of sages—outwardly appearing questionable but inwardly free of doubt. Because the firm line occupies the central position, it does not deviate from the correct path. The third line aligns with the top line but harbors suspicion toward the second and fourth lines. When suspicion runs deep, forced unity only invites entanglement, as if being pulled in opposite directions. The fourth line imposes a branding punishment (qing) from above, while the second line inflicts a nose-cutting penalty (yi) from below. Despite suffering these punishments, both remain steadfast in their resolve. When a yin line opposes the yang line it rides upon, it begins to lose its proper place. Yet if the yin line harmonizes with its corresponding yang line, a favorable outcome emerges—a process that begins with suspicion but ends in trust.
The fifth line (yin in a yang position) governs the state of separation by honoring the wisdom of the second line and restraining the gaps of the third. Though its yielding nature is insufficient to fully resolve separation—and thus should bring regret—its yang position allows it to balance yin with yang, firmness with flexibility. Acting decisively, it avoids mistakes. The top line (yang) represents the extreme of separation—overly sharp and harsh, rigid and stubborn, suspicious of its counterpart. Seeing illusions of pigs and ghosts, it descends into absurdity. The third line, unafraid of such suspicion and aversion, ultimately finds union, demonstrating the power of adhering to the proper way. The phrase "going forward, encountering rain" signifies the mutual harmonization of yin and yang, leaving no room for slackness or disparity. By maintaining sincerity throughout, all differences quietly dissolve, and progress brings increasing harmony—hence, "the suspicions of the multitude vanish."
Alas! In times of flourishing virtue, rulers and ministers share a spiritual connection, their aspirations aligned, and the Dao naturally follows without need for words. Yet now we have reached a state where persuasion and isolation are necessary.
This scripture primarily discusses the wisdom of navigating adversity. The text observes that when one suspects others before establishing trust, forced cooperation will only lead to moral decline. The true noble person should aim to unite people's hearts by rectifying their aspirations and starting with small actions ("aligning their will while attending to minor affairs") to achieve universal harmony. Historical achievers like Chen Ping, Zichan, and Di Renjie all accomplished great deeds by beginning humbly, while figures such as Yuan Shao of the Han dynasty and Li Zheng of the Tang dynasty failed by overreaching, ultimately causing team divisions—a consequence of not understanding this principle.
Interpretation of the Hexagram Jian (Gen below Kan above, symbolizing mountain with water—an image of peril): When encountering obstacles, advancing southwest (symbolizing favorable momentum) proves advantageous, while moving northeast (symbolizing adversity) brings misfortune. Meeting virtuous elders ("the great person") brings aid, and holding to correctness yields good fortune. The wise recognize danger and know when to halt ("seeing peril and knowing to stop"). The hexagram teaches that noble individuals should engage in self-reflection and cultivate virtue ("turning inward to cultivate De").
Revelations from the individual lines:
First Six: Advancing brings peril, withdrawing earns praise—illustrating the importance of awaiting the proper moment
Second Six: A minister repeatedly faces danger, but not for personal gain—ultimately remaining blameless
Third Nine: Advancing into peril leads to turning back—those within will welcome this decision
Fourth Six: Meeting obstacles while advancing necessitates uniting with others—the proper approach
Fifth Nine: Great adversity brings friends' assistance—maintaining moderation makes this possible
Top Six: Advancing into peril but withdrawing brings great fortune—because the heart values internal unity; meeting noble persons proves beneficial—one may follow the wise
In summary, Jian represents adversity. When facing difficulties, sometimes stopping ("valuing cessation") is necessary, while other times active engagement ("valuing advancement") is required. The key lies in knowing when to advance or retreat and relying on the guidance of virtuous elders to overcome challenges. Just as the hexagram's image of water atop a mountain shows, the true solution lies in self-examination and cultivating virtue.
This passage elucidates the wisdom of the "Jian Hexagram" (symbolizing hardship and obstacles) from the Book of Changes. The Jian Hexagram combines the Gen trigram (representing mountain) above and the Kan trigram (representing water) below, forming a configuration where Yin and Yang stand in opposition.
When sages face worldly crises, they cannot remain indifferent. Yet if circumstances prohibit action, one must understand when to halt; when opportunity arises, one must step forward. The scripture states "favorable in the southwest, unfavorable in the northeast" because the southwest corresponds to the Kun position (symbolizing docility) while the northeast aligns with Gen (symbolizing cessation). Here, the metaphor of the fourth line of Qian trigram moving to the fifth position of Kun to form Kan illustrates how finding the middle path enables escape from peril.
Persisting stubbornly in the northeastern position (symbolizing cessation) leads to danger, while encountering wise assistance allows joint overcoming of difficulties—preserving both self and state. True wisdom lies not merely in foreseeing danger and stopping, but in discovering opportunities for breakthrough within stillness. Like water temporarily halted on a mountain that ultimately flows downward.
After comprehending this principle, the noble person cultivates inner virtue to navigate worldly hardships. When recognizing that most obstacles stem from insufficient self-cultivation, one reflects on personal conduct. The text particularly notes how the uppermost Yin line (symbolizing yielding) paradoxically attains good fortune by understanding retreat to gain powerful support. Though the lowest Yang line (symbolizing strength) preserves itself through inaction and earns praise, the true noble never forgets worldly affairs even in stillness—hence the text advises "appropriate to wait."
Finally, when the nation faces adversity, ministers ("royal officials" denoting high-ranking courtiers) must shoulder greater responsibility. The entire passage emphasizes maintaining both situational awareness and compassionate engagement during trials, transforming danger through balanced inner and outer cultivation.
This passage comes from the Discourse on the Changes (Yi Shuo), primarily expounding on the principles for navigating difficult circumstances.
When a person's abilities prove insufficient, as long as they exhaust all their strength, dedicate themselves completely, and even disregard personal safety in their utmost loyalty, who could possibly blame them? In times of national crisis, one cannot rely on others but must depend solely on their own resilience to press forward, despite encountering obstacles. If they can join forces with like-minded companions (the two yin lines) to assist the ruler, they might compensate for their own shortcomings. This is what is called "inner joy" — though the heart rejoices, external circumstances remain arduous; though no fault can be found in their efforts, the actual results may fall short of expectations.
The fourth line, by its position, ought to support the strong, but being yin and weak itself, it cannot proceed to aid directly. Instead, it must coordinate with the third line's yang strength to jointly achieve merit. The fifth line occupies an honorable position yet faces peril, with the nation's survival resting on its shoulders — an exceedingly difficult situation. Fortunately, its firm and upright nature enables it to recommend the worthy, and its virtue is sufficient to command respect, drawing heroes to its aid.
The top line stands at the extreme of hardship, surrounded by treacherous and impassable circumstances, yet it must not halt progress in resignation. One should follow a virtuous and capable enlightened ruler to jointly establish achievements, not passively withdraw from the world.
To resolve the world's predicaments, unity between high and low is essential. Both the third and fifth lines are yang and strong. If the fifth does not advance, it cannot attract the third's assistance; if the third does not act, it cannot aid the fifth. Their cooperation ultimately manifests in the top line (the Kun trigram). The phrase "favorable to the southwest" encourages the ruler in the fifth position, while "unfavorable to the northeast" cautions the third to proceed prudently.
All line statements mention "advancing with difficulty" (wang jian), for this is precisely a time requiring obstacles to be overcome — reminding people to act carefully rather than stagnate. How evident is the sage's urgent desire to save the world from hardship!
The subsequent hexagram image (Kan below, Zhen above) represents Jie (Release), symbolizing liberation from difficulty. It is favorable to move southwestward, as this direction garners popular support. Timely action brings auspicious results. When heaven and earth thaw, thunder and rain erupt; the nourishing storms cause plants to sprout — this is the season of all things reviving. The noble person emulates this image by forgiving others' faults.
This commentary on the "Xie" (Release) hexagram of the Yijing explains its symbolism and line interpretations. The "Xie" hexagram signifies liberation from adversity, representing relief following the hardships depicted in the preceding "Jian" (Obstruction) hexagram.
The initial six (Yin) line suggests that balancing firmness and flexibility prevents errors. The second nine (Yang) line describes hunting three foxes and obtaining bronze arrowheads—maintaining uprightness brings good fortune by embodying the Golden Mean. The third six line warns that carrying goods while riding invites robbers; though righteous, this invites trouble through one's own actions. The fourth nine line indicates that removing shackles from one's feet attracts supportive friends. The fifth six line shows how noble persons who resolve conflicts auspiciously cause petty people to retreat. The top six line depicts a lord shooting down a fierce bird atop a high wall, symbolizing supreme effectiveness in eliminating rebellion.
With Kan (Water) as its substance and Zhen (Thunder) as function, "Xie" embodies Yang rescuing Yin. When facing peril, one must shoulder the responsibility of resolution through vigorous action to transform danger into safety while avoiding petty interference. Yet such action must accord with timing—just as moving southwest garners collective support. True benefit isn't forced: avoiding obligations during crises violates natural flow, as does forcibly claiming merit during peace.
Maintaining the Middle Way prevents both unnecessary strife and harmful indulgence. A tranquil approach stabilizes hearts in all endeavors. When rulers emulate heaven and earth's cyclical Dao in implementing solutions, Yin and Yang energies harmonize, awakening all beings' vitality. Before heaven-earth's release, nothing prematurely leaks its essence (Jing); when release begins, nothing lags behind.
This passage elucidates the philosophy of the "Hexagram of Liberation" (解卦) from the Book of Changes (易经), using the natural phenomenon of thunderstorms dispersing oppressive weather as a metaphor for resolving social conflicts.
Just as thunder and rain break through gloomy skies, a noble person (君子) should approach problem-solving with magnanimity as their virtue (德), emulating the nurturing embrace of heaven and earth. Specifically: laws should be applied with measured flexibility—pardoning unintentional faults, forgiving redeemable wrongs, and balancing firmness with gentleness.
The first line (初爻, the bottom symbol of the hexagram) symbolizes the initial stage of liberation. Here, one should temper strength with flexibility—neither acting so harshly as to provoke upheaval nor so lenient as to enable wrongdoing. Maintaining upright character, rectifying what is crooked, and acting with precision are key—like a hunter capturing three foxes (representing the removal of petty schemers) and obtaining a yellow arrow (symbolizing the recruitment of virtuous allies).
The third line warns: those who lack competence yet hold high positions—forming cliques for selfish gain within and provoking conflict without—embody the traits of petty individuals. If they reluctantly imitate noble conduct, they may still find fortune, but harboring base intentions will inevitably bring calamity.
The fourth line explains: a strong and principled minister in an advisory role cannot resolve difficulties alone; they require like-minded allies. If ensnared by flatterers, they must free themselves—like loosening a bound thumb (representing shaking off obstructive influences)—to unite with true companions.
The fifth line emphasizes: a ruler upholding the middle path (中道), aided by wise ministers and supported by the second and top lines in eliminating harm, demonstrates the wisdom of leveraging talent without stubbornness. In a court where virtue and vice mingle, sincerely allying with noble individuals naturally marginalizes the petty—just as falcons (鹰隼) perched on high walls eventually threaten the sovereign. Entrenched malevolence must be purged decisively for the people to benefit.
In conclusion: to dissolve the world’s crises, one must harmonize strength and gentleness. The resolute must guard against rigidity (symbolized by the "yellow arrow" as restraint), while the yielding must avoid indecision. Only through this dynamic balance can one shoulder the great responsibility of governing the world.
This scripture primarily elucidates the principles of the "Hexagram of Diminishment" (Sun) from the Book of Changes. The Diminishment hexagram (comprising Dui below and Gen above) speaks of the Dao of reduction, but such diminishment must be undertaken with sincerity to attain great fortune.
The text first interprets the hexagram image: a marsh beneath a mountain symbolizes diminishment. When noble persons observe this hexagram, they should restrain anger and curb desires. The explanation then proceeds line by line:
The first line states that after completing affairs, one should promptly proceed forward—this incurs no fault, but requires appropriate reduction. Such action aligns with one's true intent.
The second line emphasizes that perseverance in correctness brings benefit, while reckless advancement invites danger. Here, neither diminishment nor increase is necessary; maintaining the Middle Way is paramount.
The third line employs the metaphor of three people traveling together—where one is inevitably diminished—while a solitary traveler may instead find companionship. This illustrates how excessive numbers breed doubt.
The fourth line describes how diminishing illness leads to swift recovery, a cause for joy.
The fifth line speaks of someone presenting a priceless tortoise-shell (a highly valued item in antiquity) that cannot be refused—an auspicious omen indicating heavenly favor.
The final line declares that neither diminishment nor increase is needed; remaining faultless and steadfast in correctness brings good fortune. Action may be taken to gain "ministers without homes" (symbolizing obtaining virtuous aides), signifying great fulfillment.
The scripture concludes by summarizing: Diminishment is not something sages impose arbitrarily but reflects the natural rhythms of heaven and earth—waxing and waning, ebb and flow. Sages simply accord with these patterns. Both diminishment and augmentation must be timed appropriately, adjusted according to circumstances, and harmonized with the momentum of change.
This passage expounds the principle of the "Hexagram of Diminishment" (Sun) from the Book of Changes. The core teaching is that one should cultivate self-restraint to benefit others, reducing excessive desires to achieve harmonious balance, embodying the Daoist way of disciplining oneself while treating others generously.
The concept of "diminishment" actually refers to eliminating what ought to be eliminated—there is no real loss in essence. Like the hexagram's structure (Note: Gen ☶ below representing mountain, Xun ☴ above representing wind), it demonstrates how yielding Yin follows firm Yang. By diminishing the firmness (Qian ☰) we form Dui ☱ (representing marsh), while augmenting the yielding (Kun ☷) forms Gen ☶ (mountain). When the mountain above receives increase, the marsh below willingly diminishes—this manifests sincerity.
Practicing the Dao of diminishment requires implementing frugality through concrete actions of economy, creating mutual trust between superior and inferior without forced pretense. When virtuous conduct provides evidence and no faults invite reproach, we achieve "great auspiciousness without blame." Firmness doesn't vanish through diminishment, nor does yielding overflow through increase. Without flattery below or arrogance above, one's path becomes unobstructed.
The scripture mentions "two simple food vessels suffice for sacrifice," illustrating how sincere devotion can be expressed through modest offerings. If even spirits accept simplicity, how much more should humans? Yet extreme austerity cannot be sustained indefinitely, nor can firm virtue be perpetually diminished. Therefore, we must adjust according to circumstances: diminish when appropriate—what seems loss becomes gain; restrain when needed—what appears meager proves abundant. The sage acts in accordance with timeliness, mirroring nature's infinite transformations without excess or deficiency.
The hexagram image shows marsh beneath mountain (Note: Sun hexagram structure), where water diminishes itself to elevate the mountain. The noble person internalizes this principle by restraining anger and curbing desires—this constitutes the cultivation of heart-mind. What humans most need to diminish are disturbances of anger and desire. By checking anger before it arises, one avoids turmoil from暴躁情绪 (violent emotions); by severing desires before they sprout, one escapes being led by妄想 (delusory thoughts)—thus self-cultivation cannot fail.
In the hexagram lines: The initial yang line in yang position diminishes itself to follow the fourth yin line; the second yang line in yin position reduces itself to resonate with the fifth. Hence the first line suits advancing, while the second requires cautious action. "Completing affairs swiftly brings no blame" means treating superiors' matters as one's own, seizing opportunities to serve loyally with prompt action. Yet at Dui ☱'s initial stage...
This passage elucidates the philosophy of the "Diminishment" hexagram (symbolizing reduction) from the Yijing (Book of Changes). The core teaching is that excessive diminishment of one's strong Qi (vital energy) leads to self-loss, necessitating balanced adjustment. Initially diminishing strength, then further diminishing oneself, plunges one into the path of decline—at such times, stillness is preferable to rash action.
Through hexagram analysis, the text reveals: The upward movement of Yang's strong Dao follows natural law. The third line symbolizes action—the upper line of the Qian hexagram (pure Yang) diminishes to supplement the Kun hexagram (pure Yin), just as three travelers must reduce by one. Diminishment isn't abandonment, nor is augmentation excess; Yin and Yang must harmonize to generate all things. Like the union of Gen (Mountain) and Dui (Lake) nurturing life, or the accord between high and low achieving transformation, this demonstrates the natural principle of Yin-Yang complementarity and mirrors the political wisdom of ruler-minister cooperation.
Detailed line interpretations: The weak fourth line requires support from the first line's clarity and strength; the receptive fifth line needs the second line's centered correctness. Ministers who accept reasonable diminishment serve loyally; rulers who consciously diminish themselves welcome counsel—thereby gaining celestial and human assistance. The topmost ninth line maintains unyielding Yang without self-diminishment while benefiting those below, yet must guard against complacency. By upholding the correct Dao, with strong De (Virtue) growing daily, one's grace spreads widely, winning universal allegiance.
In summary: The first line should diminish moderately; the second treats non-diminishment as true diminishment; the fifth turns diminishment into gain; the top line transforms non-diminishment into benefit. The fourth line loses through excessive gain, while the third gains through proper loss—revealing that true diminishment requires perfect measure. The fusion of strength and flexibility secures both ministerial support and friendship—this sincere path of diminishment constitutes an eternal principle. Those who prioritize private gain over public welfare, or rely on brute force while neglecting moral transformation, violate this truth.
The Yi Discourse explains the principle of the "Increase Hexagram" (Yi Gua). This hexagram combines Zhen (thunder) below and Xun (wind) above, symbolizing the concept of "beneficial increase."
The core teaching is that rulers should understand the principle of "diminishing above to benefit below"—reducing upper-level privileges to enhance the welfare of common people. Just as heaven sends nourishing rain and earth spontaneously generates all things, such natural beneficence makes people rejoice and ensures the nation's path remains bright. During such times, all endeavors prosper, and even formidable obstacles like crossing great rivers become manageable.
Specifically:
The mutual assistance of wind and thunder symbolizes increase. When noble persons observe this hexagram, they should emulate others' virtues while correcting their own faults. The six lines reveal:
The first line indicates auspiciousness in large-scale construction projects;
The second line describes receiving precious ceremonial gifts (ten pairs of tortoise shells) as highly auspicious for offering to the Heavenly Emperor;
The third line shows no fault in relieving people during famines;
The fourth line advises following public consensus when relocating capitals;
The fifth line confirms that sincere benevolence toward people brings good fortune;
The top line warns that neglecting public welfare may invite attacks.
The fundamental principle derives from cosmic patterns: Heaven (Qian) nourishes below with yang qi to form thunder (Zhen), while Earth (Kun) responds with yin qi to create wind (Xun). As heaven and earth thus benefit all creatures, sages emulate this pattern to bless humanity. Like trees growing or boats sailing naturally, rulers should embody this spirit through concrete actions—construction, rituals, disaster relief, and capital relocation—to benefit the people.
A crucial warning concludes: Failing to maintain this consistent benevolent attitude ("not establishing constant care in the heart") inevitably brings misfortune.
This passage expounds the principles of the "Hexagram Yi" (Increase) from the Yijing (Book of Changes), using natural phenomena as metaphors for human affairs. Thunder (representing Yang strength) advances ahead, while wind (representing Yin softness) follows and spreads—through this, all things receive nourishment. The harmony of Yin and Yang is as natural as heaven above and earth below. When Yin rises to support Yang, and Yang descends to nourish Yin, the profound mystery of heaven and earth's transformative power manifests.
The movement of heaven and earth follows a pattern where constancy inevitably gives rise to change, and within change, constancy is maintained. Increase and decrease, fullness and emptiness, continuously transform into one another. Understanding that "gain may turn into loss" allows one to establish virtue amidst change. When encountering good deeds, emulate them; when recognizing faults, correct them immediately—acting as subtly as a gentle breeze yet as decisively as a sudden thunderclap.
Yin softness suits minor affairs, while Yang strength suits major ones. Initially, Yin requires Yang's support to grow strong, and those who benefit the most must uphold firm virtue, responding with sincere gratitude. However, if one holds a low position with numerous responsibilities, quiet contemplation is essential to avoid the pitfalls of hasty action.
A minister assists the ruler with gentle yet upright virtue—this is the noble path of balancing strength and softness. Strength resolves difficulties, while softness ensures reverent rituals; thus, when the ruler employs such virtuous ministers to offer sacrifices to heaven, blessings will surely follow. Even inherently weak qualities, if steadfastly adhering to the Middle Way, can remain secure.
When Yin occupies a Yang position, disaster may arise, yet if one courageously shoulders the world's crises without claiming merit, fortune will instead be granted. The key lies in accumulating sincerity within and maintaining unwavering resolve. Just as in perilous situations, responding with utmost sincerity ultimately turns danger into safety.
This scripture primarily expounds on principles for personal conduct and state governance. Its core philosophy emphasizes the importance of the Middle Way and sincere selflessness.
First, it teaches that one should act with integrity (you fu) and follow the Middle Path (zhong xing), neither excessively humble nor arrogantly proud. For instance, when ministers advise their rulers (gao gong yong gui), they should attribute merit to their superiors—this embodies the proper way of serving as a subject.
The fourth line, positioned at the beginning of the Xun hexagram (symbolizing humility), though not in the most advantageous place, exemplifies overcoming hardness with softness—neither groveling nor domineering. Even those of lower status, if they act with the intention of benefiting the people and move in accordance with the times, can embody the Middle Way. With such an attitude, their counsel to rulers will never go unheeded.
The text also uses the metaphor of "relocating the capital" (qian guo) to illustrate the principle of Yin-Yang harmony: the originally Yin first line ascends to the position of the fourth line, while the originally Yang fourth line descends to the first line, symbolizing how state policies must align with the Dao of Heaven. The fifth line, representing the ruler, should uphold the Middle Way—not dispensing petty favors but treating the people with sincerity. Likewise, subjects should not flatter the ruler for personal gain but should reciprocate his benevolence with genuine loyalty. When ruler and subjects interact with such mutual sincerity, harmony arises naturally, like Heaven and Earth nurturing all things.
Conversely, if one behaves like the top line—taking without giving (tu qiu yi yu ren)—they invite retribution (fan you yi ji zhi). This stems from failing to understand the dialectical relationship between "diminishment" (sun) and "increase" (yi). All people possess an innate inclination toward goodness, but when clouded by selfish desires, they lose their original nature, and their upright virtue gradually erodes.
Finally, the text warns that relentless pursuit of gain without humility violates the Dao of Heaven—just as water overflows when full, endless taking eventually provokes divine wrath and popular resentment. Thus, each line’s judgment offers admonitions: the first line speaks of "supreme good fortune" (yuan ji), the second of "perseverance bringing good fortune" (zhen ji), the third and fourth of "following the Middle Way" (zhong xing), and the third and fifth of "holding to integrity" (you fu), all cautioning reverence toward "benefit." Only by maintaining constant vigilance can one truly attain lasting prosperity.
The subsequent Guai hexagram (Heaven below, Lake above) symbolizes decisive action, emphasizing the need to handle affairs with firm resolve (gang jue rou) while maintaining harmonious moderation (jue er he). To "proclaim righteousness in the royal court" (yang yu wang ting) arises when the yielding overrides the firm (rou cheng wu gang), necessitating urgent warnings issued with sincerity (fu hao).
This passage is from the Yi Shuo (Discourse on the Changes), explaining the meaning and line interpretations of the Guai hexagram (symbolizing resolution).
The Guai hexagram consists of five solid (yang) lines and one broken (yin) line, representing the yang force decisively resolving the influence of yin petty individuals. Though yang is strong and yin appears weak, the hexagram repeatedly warns against complacency due to one's advantage. With Qian (Heaven) as its substance and Dui (Marsh) as its function, this hexagram illustrates the principle of yang restraining yin.
The image shows marsh water rising to the heavens (Dui above Qian). When a noble person observes this image, they should understand the need to distribute blessings and rewards to subordinates. However, if they pride themselves on their virtue (De), they will invite resentment.
Interpretations of the lines:
The first line states that reckless advancement without victory will bring misfortune. The second line advises vigilance—even if conflict arises at midnight, there is no need for worry if one abides by the central path. The third line warns that excessive strength invites danger: when a noble person acts decisively alone and is drenched by rain, though angered, no real harm follows. The fourth line describes difficulty in movement, like an injured hip; leading a sheep forward dispels regret, but one fails to heed advice. The fifth line suggests resolving matters with the flexibility of an amaranth plant—maintaining the center ensures no misfortune. The top line warns that issuing commands without vigilance will ultimately bring calamity.
The hexagram as a whole emphasizes: If petty individuals remain near the ruler, their crimes must be openly exposed to prevent further scheming. Announce their wrongdoings in court, uniting the righteous. Remain watchful to guard against usurpation of power. Inform all sides to demonstrate impartiality. It does not advocate immediate military action, as while force may sometimes be necessary, it cannot be relied upon. Victory is uncertain if one depends solely on force without cultivating virtue (De) or careful planning. The true path to resolution lies in decisive progress—firm yet timely action, handled with moderation to avoid escalation. The noble person must act for the sake of all under heaven.
All things in heaven and earth are fundamentally one, just as sunlight shines impartially upon all creation. Even toward those of unvirtuous character, it never harbors enmity. It is merely that petty individuals consume the righteous Yang Qi (vital energy) like parasites, becoming a burden to the world, and thus must be removed.
Yet even in removal, there remains compassion—like forcefully excising a festering sore. Though the action is vigorous, it always maintains the balance of the Dao (the Way). Therefore, thorough planning is essential to magnify one's endeavors and ensure a proper beginning and end. This principle resembles the marsh's Qi (vital energy) rising to form clouds, then descending as nourishing rain—a process symbolized by the hexagram "Guai" (Resoluteness). The noble person emulates this natural law, bestowing blessings upon those below.
To claim merit for oneself invites resentment. Just as the marsh's Qi (symbolized by the Dui trigram) ascends as clouds and descends as rain, this is the most harmonious state. When purging the world's impurities—though it entails removing petty individuals—the whole world benefits. Only by eliminating those who harm all things can the noble person widely distribute virtuous governance, aligning with the harmonious order of creation. But if one monopolizes merit, refusing to credit others, they fall into narrow-minded jealousy and invite the suspicion of other Yang forces.
The first line (a solid Yang line at the bottom) resembles a strong toe: though it holds authority, it remains in a low position, just beginning to issue commands. When Yang energy is still weak, one must guard against rashness—if one acts recklessly and fails, it is a fault. The second line (a yielding Yin line in the center) is gentle and balanced, capable of assessing the situation and issuing warnings. It does not rely on force but excels in vigilance, ensuring inner preparedness and outer security. The third line is the enemy of complacency; the fourth line is the indulgence that nurtures harm. Though righteousness may be written plainly on one's face, it instead invites suspicion—this is the path to calamity.
The noble person must act resolutely, severing ties with petty individuals through independent action. Even when forced to interact with them, one should maintain outward composure without revealing differences, while inwardly keeping a distance and refusing to share in their corruption. This is the proper way to deal with petty individuals. The fourth line, by excessively pursuing harmony, loses its principles, wavering indecisively—thus its steps falter, and none follow. Even if it presses forward, none trust it, for its judgment is impaired.
The fifth line (a Yang line in the honored position) purges Yin influences with ease, like uprooting purslane. Yet if isolated in a high position, one must remain vigilant—when circumstances are urgent, adversaries may feign closeness, and when bonds are entangled, they become hard to sever. Even if the resolution seems slightly excessive, so long as it adheres to the Mean, it is no fault. In the world, there are those who err by being overly rigid...
This passage explains the principles of the "Guai" (Resoluteness) and "Gou" (Encounter) hexagrams from the Book of Changes (Yijing). The Guai hexagram (symbolizing decisive action) teaches using Yang's vigorous energy to resolve Yin's yielding matters, maintaining a state of pure Yang. The relationship between Yin and Yang resembles a tug-of-war—Yang energy grows with difficulty while Yin energy proliferates easily. Thus, sages urgently emphasize preserving Yang's strength.
The top sixth line (a Yin line at the peak) of the Guai hexagram is in grave danger, as Yin energy has reached its extreme and stands isolated. Though it seeks support from the third and fifth lines (Yang lines), their coordination fails, much like how desperate pleas cannot avert misfortune. This warns us that yielding petty individuals should not be lightly pardoned even when begging for mercy. Both the third and top lines face peril because their insufficient virtue leads to improper private alliances.
The Gou hexagram (symbolizing encounter, with Xun below and Qian above) depicts weak Yin energy meeting strong Yang energy. Its judgment states, "A strong woman should not be taken as wife," meaning one should not maintain prolonged association with dominant Yin figures (symbolizing petty individuals). Yet the meeting of Heaven's Yang and Earth's Yin follows natural law, enabling all things to flourish. The key lies in Yang maintaining centrality and correctness, allowing upright energy to prevail under heaven.
The author concludes: Sages understand the world cannot exist with only Yang and no Yin, just as petty individuals cannot be entirely eradicated. But sages ensure yielding petty people ultimately cannot overcome vigorous upright energy, preventing them from gaining power in governance. Like Emperor Shun's exile of the Four Malevolents or the Zhou dynasty's civilizing influence, the sage's method of supporting Yang while restraining Yin combines resoluteness with harmony, decisiveness with gentleness—revealing profoundly comprehensive intent.
The Gou (姤) hexagram in the Book of Changes (Yijing) embodies profound Daoist wisdom. Its imagery shows wind (Xun trigram) meeting heaven (Qian trigram), symbolizing how a ruler should emulate this phenomenon by proclaiming decrees to all directions.
The initial six yao line teaches: Restraint like a rope tied to a metal brake brings good fortune; reckless action invites misfortune, like a scrawny sow's restless agitation. This illustrates how yielding forces require proper guidance.
The second nine yao line states: Having fish in the kitchen (representing resources) brings no misfortune, but they shouldn't be used to entertain guests. This signifies resources should be allocated wisely, not squandered carelessly.
The third nine yao line depicts: Injured hips make movement difficult—a precarious situation without major disaster. This suggests limited mobility doesn't equate to complete loss of autonomy.
The fourth nine yao line warns: An empty kitchen (no fish) invites calamity, metaphorically showing the dangers of losing popular support.
The fifth nine yao line says: A melon wrapped in willow leaves (symbolizing包容 tolerance), with inner virtue, receives heavenly blessings. This demonstrates how upholding the Middle Way (中正之道) naturally aligns with celestial mandate.
The top nine yao line observes: Encountering horns (representing conflict) brings regret without disaster, showing inevitable friction when things reach their zenith.
Gou fundamentally illustrates the principle of "encounter." When yang energy culminates above (as in the Guai hexagram), yin energy quietly germinates below. While yin actively seeks union, yang remains unguarded—such meetings often occur unexpectedly. With Xun (wind) as substance and Qian (heaven) as function, this hexagram reveals how yin influences yang.
Yang's return signifies "reversion" (复, internal contraction), while yin's growth represents "encounter" (遇, external manifestation). The five yang lines above must remain vigilant against the single yin line below. Yin excels at attachment and seduction—when one yin encounters five yangs, it leverages their momentum to expand. Complacent yang allows yin to flourish, potentially harming noble individuals. Hence the warning "don't marry such a woman," fearing domination. Sages therefore approach "encounters" with utmost caution.
Yet encounters shouldn't be wholly condemned. While yin-yang interactions have moral dimensions (avoiding improper unions), their necessary mutual attraction remains essential. Just as heaven and earth must meet to nurture all things, when steadfast strength encounters balanced yielding—like a nobleman finding a virtuous maiden—the Great Dao (大道) can manifest throughout the world.
This scripture discusses how human relationships and social functioning must follow natural laws, otherwise they will veer toward extremes and chaos. The key lies in grasping the subtle timing of "encounter" (yu)—it must neither be absent nor casually approached. When encounters are properly conducted, the way of Yang (阳刚之道) can prevail; when improperly handled, the way of Yang will decline.
The text uses the relationship between heaven and wind as a metaphor: though heaven is supreme, it requires the wind to touch all things; though the ruler (后) holds noble status, governance must be enacted to communicate with the people. Just as the wind reaches all things, decrees spread throughout the land—this is the state in which the Dao (道) flows freely. Yet danger lurks within: when wind rises from below, it signifies ascending Yang (阳气上升), but when it descends from above, it signals declining Yang (阳气下降), foreshadowing the growing dominance of Yin (阴气).
The author observes that ancient times emphasized virtue (德), the middle ages valued education, while now governance relies on decrees—a sign that the world is no longer at peace. The "Gou Hexagram" (姤卦, one of the 64 hexagrams in the Yijing, symbolizing encounter) illustrates this: the meeting of Yin (阴柔) and Yang (阳刚) is inherently not the proper way. The first line (the bottom Yin line in the hexagram), as the leading force of Yin, must both be restrained and act with rectitude. If unrestrained and agitated, it becomes as perilous as a frenzied sow (羸豕) in heat. The "brake" (柅) represents how the noble person must use firm and composed resolve to curb such recklessness.
The second line (a Yang line) first encounters the first (Yin) line, much like wrapping fish in a net—Yin must be controlled but not excessively exalted. The third line faces danger, yet by staying true to its position, though minor troubles arise, no great harm follows. When the fourth line meets the first, excessive softness risks losing authority. These metaphors emphasize that in human interactions and governance, one must balance firmness and flexibility—neither indulging excess nor suppressing too harshly.
This passage primarily elucidates the principles of "encounter" and "gathering" from the Yijing (Book of Changes).
First, regarding the Dao of "encounter": When the proper timing is lost, maintaining stillness becomes appropriate, as reckless action invites misfortune. The fifth line, positioned in the yang-bright place, can control the subtle yin energy below—like covering tender seedlings with a tall farming tool. Though easily accomplished, one must proceed with caution. Conceal your abilities, subtly guiding the situation while allowing things to unfold naturally. When human effort is exhausted, celestial fortune shifts, and adversity ultimately transforms into smooth progress.
The topmost yang line stands isolated in its lofty position—like touching objects with horns, which is not the correct approach. The entire hexagram teaches yin-yang encounter: the second line maintains proper measure without confusion; the third and top lines, lacking virtue and position, ironically avoid errors; the fourth line forces encounters, hence its misfortune; the fifth line understands self-concealment, mastering the proper method of encounter. Yet this still falls short of the sage's realm of transforming all beings.
The Yijing reminds us: encounters are celestial-earthly opportunities for union, but one must distinguish between noble and petty individuals. Without cautious prevention and self-cultivation through centered virtue, one easily falls into improper relationships.
Next is the "Cui Hexagram" (meaning "gathering"): When the ruler performs ancestral temple sacrifices, it benefits meeting virtuous individuals. Using grand sacrificial animals brings good fortune, and action is favorable. Cui Hexagram teaches gathering's principle—only by aligning with the Dao of heaven can gathering be correct. Observing gathering phenomena reveals the essence of all things under heaven. The noble person should maintain weapons, preparing for the unexpected.
First yin line: If sincerity cannot be sustained to the end, gatherings become chaotic. Timely correction avoids worry; proceeding brings no misfortune. Second yin line: Being guided forward brings good fortune—even simple sacrifices can express sincerity.
[Notes:]
1. "Gou" refers to the Gou Hexagram in the Yijing, discussing encounter.
2. "Cui" is the 45th hexagram, concerning gathering.
3. "Yue" denotes ancient simple sacrificial rites.
4. Line positions refer to the six lines in a hexagram, counted from bottom to top.
This passage from Yi Shuo (Discourse on the Changes) explains the core philosophy of the Cui hexagram (symbolizing gathering and convergence). The hexagram image shows lake water accumulating upon the earth, mirroring the harmonious relationship between ruler and subjects. The key lies in maintaining connections through sincere emotion rather than superficial formalities.
The hexagram statement mentions "the king approaches the temple," illustrating how solemn rituals can unite people's hearts. Yet mere outward compliance is insufficient—one must uphold impartiality. The "grand sacrifice" symbolizes selfless devotion, the true foundation for unifying the community.
Each of the six lines offers distinct insights:
The first line warns, "sincerity not enduring," reminding us that gatherings without genuine commitment lead to chaos;
The third line's "gathering with sighs" depicts forced assemblies, demonstrating the futility of coercion;
The fifth line's "gathering with rank" shows that even high status brings regret if one's intentions lack purity;
The top line's "lamenting with tears" reveals how excessive gathering breeds unease instead.
The central teaching is this: True convergence depends not on external forms but on heartfelt resonance. Just as the earth naturally bears the lake's waters, a ruler should gather the people through authentic connection. This bond originates from heavenly mandate, linking all creation. Thus, sages learn to "store weapons and prepare for uncertainties"—for sincere unity is the ultimate safeguard.
This passage explains the principles of the "Cui Hexagram" (Gathering) from the Book of Changes. "Cui" signifies gathering, but excessive accumulation risks dispersion—thus preparedness is key. Like building dikes against floods, one must prevent contention when resources gather, and the method lies in making proper preparations.
The hexagram's structure shows two solid yang lines (representing strength) centered between yielding yin lines (representing flexibility), symbolizing a favorable moment when rulers and subjects unite and all things resonate. Yet sages remain vigilant: when yin gathers, guard against corrupting influences; when yang dominates, resist arrogance. Grand gatherings easily deplete energy—only sincerity and gentle perseverance ensure lasting fortune.
Analyzing the six lines:
The first (bottom) yin line, being weak and indecisive, is prone to temptation and broken trust—like someone crying for help yet wavering, becoming a laughingstock. But persisting in righteousness while disregarding mockery brings no blame.
The second line, sandwiched between two yin lines, seems suspicious of factionalism. Yet it actually guides yin upward—a virtuous act of gathering talents without violating justice. Maintaining loyalty even moves the spirits (Shen).
The third line lacks capability, attracting no followers. Seeking powerful allies but finding no entry, it sighs in distress. Without firm integrity, even attempts to follow superiors prove fruitless.
The fourth line connects the sovereign (fifth line) below and the masses above, seemingly well-positioned. But power centers breed danger—only by serving the ruler with integrity and governing people through Daoist principles brings fortune.
The fifth (sovereign) line draws all to gather beneath it. Yet while people assemble for status, true cohesion requires virtue (De). Without sufficient virtue, unity dissolves. Cultivating De to unite hearts ensures policies spread and teachings prevail.
The top line marks gathering's dissolution—weak and leaderless, it fails to unite, left isolated like one weeping in lament. This reveals the ruler's precarious position.
In summary, most lines misunderstand gathering's essence: the first line cries for truth but wavers; the third complains and is abandoned; the top laments isolation. The key lies in sustaining lasting unity through sincerity and gentle adaptability.
This scripture primarily elucidates the philosophical principles of the "Cui" (Gathering) and "Sheng" (Ascending) hexagrams from the Yijing (Book of Changes).
Regarding the "Cui" hexagram, it states that all things naturally tend to gather, with yin energy always converging in accordance with yang energy. Even when gathering doesn't occur temporarily, this still aligns with natural tendencies and thus incurs no fault. The text notes that the second line (Line 2), though in an irregular position, remains blameless by maintaining a centered and upright attitude. It emphasizes the importance of preserving independent integrity within a group—blindly following trends brings danger, while sudden shifts in stance create chaos. Only through sincere interaction and mutual understanding can deviations be avoided.
Line 4 warns that during gatherings, pursuing selfish gain invites fault, while upward dedication brings auspiciousness—illustrating the proper conduct of ministers. Lines 2 and 5 respectively discuss "drawing in auspiciousness" (yin ji) and "great enduring perseverance" (da yong zhen), showing how rulers and ministers must cooperate to maintain societal harmony. Even in times of peace, sages prepare for potential divisions.
The "Sheng" hexagram depicts the timely ascent of yielding energy. With Xun (representing humility) below and Kun (representing docility) above, it signifies inner humility and outer gentleness, leading to great fortune. The hexagram statement mentions "success in southern campaigns" because the south symbolizes brightness, representing the fulfillment of aspirations.
The Great Image compares this to trees growing from the earth—gentlemen should follow virtue (De), beginning with small steps to gradually ascend. Line 1 ("allowed ascent brings great fortune") aligns with heavenly will. Line 2 emphasizes sincerity; even simple offerings (yue sacrifice) bring blessings. Line 3's "ascending into an empty city" signifies advancing without hesitation.
Overall, the text highlights the importance of aligning with nature, interacting with sincerity, progressing step-by-step, and the governance principles of ruler-minister cooperation and preventive vigilance.
This passage elucidates the principles of the "Ascending Hexagram" (Sheng Gua) from the Book of Changes (Yijing), focusing on how a noble person (junzi) should seize opportune moments and progress step by step toward advancement.
"Ascending" symbolizes an upward momentum. When still in a humble position, the noble person should continuously accumulate virtue (De) and wait for the right moment before striving forward—success will then come naturally. This hexagram combines Kun (representing docility) as its foundation with Xun (representing humility) as its manifestation, illustrating how the yielding (yin) should harmonize with the firm (yang).
The key to ascending lies in possessing both gentle virtues and the ability to seize proper, righteous opportunities. Forcing advancement when the time is not ripe constitutes overreach, while hesitating when the moment arrives reflects timidity. Only by grasping the perfect timing can one encounter an enlightened ruler who recognizes one's worth—just as a southern campaign (symbolized in the hexagram) would meet with wise assistance.
The text mentions "meeting the great man without anxiety," meaning that when the firm (yang) energy remains in a low position and has yet to be acknowledged, there is no need for worry. Once encountering the enlightened ruler represented by the fifth line (the "nine-five" position, traditionally symbolizing the sovereign), one will receive support. The "southern campaign" here signifies yielding (Kun) moving toward strength (Qian), acting in accordance with the timing of heaven.
The hexagram uses the image of "a tree growing from the earth" as a metaphor: just as a tree rises gradually from the soil, the noble person's progress should also be steady and incremental. One should take this as inspiration to purify the heart-mind (Shen) and attend to even the smallest matters with care. Beginning with subtle details, one gradually attains refinement; starting from solitude, one ultimately achieves harmony and fulfillment. Only through such accumulation can true elevation be reached—this is the path of ascending with both docility and prudence.
The first line (Chu Yao) embodies the virtue of humility, not rushing to take the lead in advancement, while the second line emphasizes sincerity in ritual offerings, avoiding empty formalism. These all demonstrate that ascending requires grounded effort—it cannot be forced or hurried.
This passage elucidates the principles of the "Ascending" (升) and "Constrained" (困) hexagrams from the Book of Changes, focusing on how noble individuals attain advancement through virtuous conduct (De 德) while maintaining integrity during adversity.
Regarding the "Ascending" hexagram: When one serves superiors with sincerity (the fifth line), neither currying favor with the powerful nor oppressing the weak, minor officials can fulfill their aspirations while major ministers discharge their duties faithfully. The third line, embodying yang vigor (阳刚) in peaceful times, progresses smoothly like entering an undefended city if remaining humble. The fourth line, with yin flexibility (阴柔) near the sovereign, gains auspiciousness without blame by leading others in loyal service—akin to a ruler's devout sacrificial rites to spirits.
The text mentions two sacrificial forms: the modest "yue" (禴) and the grand "xiang" (享), both emphasizing sincere communion with heaven. Advancement at the fifth line should be gradual, like ascending steps methodically. The top line, obsessively pursuing gain without restraint, resembles attempting progress at dusk—doomed by circumstance, only persistent goodness ensures lasting fortune.
A noble's ascent relies on virtue yet requires timely support. Before promotion, one must cultivate foundations diligently; after advancement, humility remains essential. The first three lines need no special exhortation, as their innate humility and balanced virtue suffice.
Concerning the "Constrained" hexagram (water below, lake above): Constraint signifies perseverance through hardship. For the virtuous, it portends good fortune when words fail to convince. The hexagram shows yang obscured by yin, yet joy persists amid danger. Nobles prevail by adhering to the central path (中正之道). When speech lacks credibility, action becomes paramount.
The core teaching: Whether ascending or constrained, virtue remains fundamental. Neither haste nor compromised principles are tolerable—one accumulates strength awaiting opportunity, proving worth through practice.
The Yishuo commentary explains the symbolism and line meanings of the "Hexagram Kun" (困, Distress). While Kun represents adversity, true hardship lies not in external poverty but in one's inability to rouse one's inner spirit. The movement of Heaven-Earth Qi (气) progresses toward Yang when flowing from west to north, but retreats toward Yin when shifting from north to west—such is the principle of adversity and transformation.
In this hexagram, the Dui trigram (☱, representing Lake) forms the body while the Kan trigram (☵, representing Water) manifests its function, symbolizing how Yin obscures Yang. The Yang aspect of Kan becomes veiled by Dui's Yin, mirroring how noble individuals may be eclipsed by petty people. Yet truly cultivated persons maintain inner peace and uphold righteousness even in adversity.
Detailed line interpretations:
The initial Yin line depicts someone trapped beneath tree roots, lost in a dark valley for three years without seeing sunlight—symbolizing utter obscurity. The second Yang line, though entangled in ceremonial feasts, remains auspicious when donning vermilion robes (denoting status) to conduct sacrifices, indicating joy emerging from distress. The third Yin line shows one wedged between rocks, leaning on thistles, returning home to find no spouse—a clear omen of misfortune. The fourth Yang line advances cautiously but encounters obstruction by a golden chariot; though temporarily hindered, favorable outcomes await. The fifth Yang line suffers as if punished by crimson official garments, yet gradual liberation comes, making it suitable for sacrificial prayers. The top Yin line, entangled in vines and trembling, finds resolution through decisive action.
Fundamentally, Kan signifies peril while Dui signifies joy, teaching us to maintain optimism amid danger. The Dao (道) of noble individuals lies in upholding unwavering integrity through the Golden Mean—assisting others while cultivating oneself. True wisdom means preserving joy within adversity, just as one maintains aspirations despite poverty.
This passage elucidates the Daoist approach to navigating adversity, emphasizing that maintaining firm integrity (gangzhong, "resolute centrality") is paramount when facing difficulties.
The text first observes that hardship most easily destabilizes those with weak character (rouren, "pliant and yielding"), who tend to become indecisive and entangled by external circumstances. Conversely, those with impatient temperaments (jinji, "impetuous and extreme") often succumb to arrogance, ultimately dissipating their vital energy. True mastery in overcoming challenges requires harmonizing firmness with equilibrium—this dual cultivation preserves one's principles while maintaining inner nourishment, naturally leading one through adversity over time.
A pointed warning emerges: attempting to escape hardship through clever rhetoric (shangkou, "elevating speech") or forced solutions only invites suspicion and worsens one's predicament. Historical examples like factional conflicts (danggu zhihuo, "the calamity of partisan prohibitions") demonstrate how self-promotion and cliquish behavior ultimately deepen one's entanglements.
Analyzing the Hexagram of Hardship (Kun, formed by Water below and Lake above), the text reveals that silence and non-forcing (wuwei) prove wisest during adversity. The hexagram's structure—three yielding lines obscuring three firm lines—shows that both strong and weak individuals face trials: the weak invite trouble by provoking the strong and should retreat to preserve themselves, while the strong must guard against agitation, finding fortune through steadfastness.
Specific line interpretations:
- The first yin line, trapped in a low position, faces dilemmas but avoids misfortune through withdrawal;
- The second yang line embodies gangzhong virtue—its humble patience resembles ritual sincerity that naturally attracts blessings, whereas forceful grasping would sacrifice integrity;
- The third line lacks sufficient virtue to properly resolve hardship.
The core teaching crystallizes thus: When confronting adversity, the noble person adheres to gangzhong as the standard—neither compromising principles nor losing composure. By awaiting timing rather than forcing outcomes, one follows the true Dao (Way) through difficulty.
This passage comes from Yi Shuo (Explanations of the Changes), interpreting the meanings of each line in the Kun (困, "Oppression") hexagram from the Yijing (Book of Changes). It describes various predicaments people face and how to respond to them.
When a yin-soft individual attempts to shoulder yang-strong responsibilities, it resembles a petty person forcing themselves to act tough. The second line seeks to propel the fourth line upward, yet the fourth line retreats to the second for stability. The third line, caught in between, finds itself in dire straits—advancing toward the fourth is like carrying a stone on one's head, while retreating to the second feels like sitting on thorns. Despite the hardship, its determination to challenge the strong remains unshaken; even if injured, it presses forward, still hoping for aid from the sixth line.
"Entering the palace but not seeing one's wife" signifies losing support after entering adversity. The fourth line lacks sufficient talent and virtue, relying only on external help. Though it wishes to depend on the first line, the first is obstructed by the second, delaying assistance. Without companions, even the sharpest tools prove useless—hence "oppressed by the golden chariot" foretells hardship.
The fifth line, yang-strong in a yang position, corresponds with the equally strong second and fourth lines, resembling a warlike ruler. Yet this ruler is blinded by the yin line above, as if deceived by treacherous ministers, inevitably provoking anger and harsh measures that lead to harm. Thus, it warns of suffering "the punishment of nose-cutting and foot-amputation." Though wounded and ineffective, its inherently wise and upright nature keeps it from rebellion, and in time, its faction will dissolve.
At the extreme of oppression, one's strength wanes—unable to act to escape, yet unable to rest peacefully, like being entangled by vines. But extremity begets change: recognizing that force is futile, one should adapt strategies, which is the auspicious path.
References to "the siege of Pingcheng" and "oppression by scarlet kneecovers" illustrate how similar phrasing in different lines carries distinct nuances. For instance, "advancing brings misfortune" in the ninth-second line warns against moving forward, while "advancing brings good fortune" in the top sixth line advises retreat as the better course. This reflects the principle of valuing yang and deeming yin inferior: honoring yang means advancing cautiously, while deeming yin inferior means withdrawing contentedly.
"Oppressed by wine and food" denotes being trapped in indulgence due to unfulfilled aspirations, whereas "oppressed by the golden chariot" stems from being constrained by circumstances.
This scripture primarily expounds upon the "Hexagram of Oppression" (Kun) and the "Hexagram of the Well" (Jing) from the Book of Changes (Yijing), discussing how people behave differently in adversity and how to maintain the constancy of the Dao (the Way) like a well.
Interpretation of the "Hexagram of Oppression": When action is obstructed, authority is stripped away, or governance fails, people fall into hardship. Those of low status are trapped because their kindness cannot benefit others, while those of high status are trapped because their decrees cannot reach far. When yin (the yielding) individuals face oppression, they often see no way out, lose their support, and regret every move—this is because they fail to abide by their true nature. In contrast, yang (the firm) individuals, when encountering hardship, can turn the situation around, ultimately achieving favorable outcomes and finding liberation. Thus, oppression is the plight of petty people, while noble individuals are never truly trapped.
Interpretation of the "Hexagram of the Well": The well symbolizes constancy (a village may change, but the well remains the same) and the principle of neither increase nor decrease ("no loss, no gain"). The well nourishes all things without ever running dry, much like how a noble person diligently serves the people and encourages mutual improvement. The scripture describes the different states of the well through its six lines:
- First Six (Yin): The well is muddy at the bottom and undrinkable; an old well goes unused—this is a well abandoned by time.
- Nine Two (Yang): The well’s water can only sustain small fish, and the clay jug for drawing water is broken—signifying a lack of support.
- Nine Three (Yang): The well’s water is clean, yet no one draws from it, causing sorrow. If a wise ruler appears, it can benefit the masses.
- Six Four (Yin): Repairing the well’s walls prevents fault.
- Nine Five (Yang): The cool, clear water is fit to drink, symbolizing the upright Dao.
- Top Six (Yin): The well’s work is complete and needs no cover—utmost sincerity and goodness bring great fortune.
The "Hexagram of the Well" follows the "Hexagram of Oppression" because the well represents steadfast adherence to the right path and the unchanging virtue of constancy. None of its six lines indicate misfortune, showing that the well is passively used rather than actively seeking use. The hexagram statement warns that a broken jug is an ill omen, but the danger lies with the user, not the well itself. "No loss, no gain" means that without loss, there is no misfortune, and without gain, there is no need to speak of good fortune. This hexagram takes Xun (Wind) as its body and Kan (Water) as its function, embodying the principle that the yielding requires the firm. It is named "Well" because the roots of trees (the foundation of wood) need water to thrive—just as people need the nourishment of virtue (De).
This scripture discusses the interaction between water and wood in nature, and how to apply this natural principle in governing society.
Water (symbolized by the Kan trigram) nourishes trees (symbolized by the Xun trigram), and with ample water, trees will not wither. Ancient sage-kings governed with benevolent hearts and virtuous methods. However, excessive water can easily become uncontrollable, just as a person with insufficient moral fortitude may struggle to maintain integrity; if one's thoughts become rigid, chaos may arise. Only through firm and balanced virtue (De) can one remain pure like well water—warm in winter and cool in summer, unaffected by seasonal changes.
The phrase "overturning the water jar" symbolizes the failure to properly maintain a well, which stems from a lack of steadfast virtue (De), leading to the inability to preserve essential things. The scripture uses the hexagram image of "wood above water" to illustrate that, in nature, the Five Phases (Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal, Water) operate with water as the guiding force and wood as its function, working in harmony. In winter, the Qi of wood is stored within water, making the well water warm; in spring, the wood Qi ascends, and the well water cools. A well properly regulates these transformations.
The interplay of Yin and Yang gives rise to the Four Symbols (Great Yang, Lesser Yin, Lesser Yang, Great Yin), which further form the Xun (wind/wood) and Kan (water) trigrams. Water is particularly represented by the well because it preserves water's pure essence. The noble person (junzi) emulates this principle by teaching the people farming and husbandry, aiding them in productive development—this is the meaning of "nourishing without exhaustion." Thus, the people do not suffer hardship, and the Dao of governance does not fall into difficulty.
Well water rises from below, and its merit manifests above. The top line of the hexagram speaks of "supreme good fortune," indicating blessings for all things—not just the well itself. Similarly, when a noble person emerges to aid the people, the principle remains the same. The noble person takes the world as their responsibility: reclusion is not mere withdrawal, and public service is not for personal gain—it is all in accordance with the needs of the time. Yet, the fulfillment of the great Dao (Dao) must come through practice, hence the well's significance lies in its "flowing water." Without the virtue (De) of nurturing others, one cannot accomplish great things.
This passage expounds on two key themes: the metaphor of the "well" illustrating the cultivation of noble character and the way of benefiting the world, and the philosophy of transformation embodied in the "Ge" (Revolution) hexagram.
Regarding the well metaphor: Like an old well that becomes silted when unused, a virtuous person ("possessing the virtue of nourishing others") resembles this well—even with the capacity to nurture, their benefits cannot reach all if no one draws from them. Some individuals may have talents to aid the world ("three virtues sufficient to benefit the people"), yet lacking proper timing, they remain unrecognized by enlightened rulers, left only to sigh privately. The truly cultivated ("fourth line: pure within and adorned without") are like well-maintained wells, refined both internally and externally, combining virtue with ability. The highest cultivation ("fifth line: firm centrality in honored position") resembles clear, sweet spring water that nourishes others while maintaining its purity. The ideal state ("top line of the well") allows universal access, generously bestowing blessings without seeking return.
Concerning the "Ge" hexagram's transformative path: Revolution requires choosing the proper moment ("only after the si day comes trust"), just as fire and water counteract, or two women cohabiting inevitably bring change. Transformation must accord with the proper Dao ("civilized harmony brings great success through correctness"), like the righteous revolutions of Tang of Shang and Wu of Zhou that followed celestial will and popular sentiment. The noble observes the hexagram's image of "fire in the lake" to comprehend the need for establishing calendars and clarifying seasons. In revolution's initial stage ("first nine"), one should stabilize foundations like binding with oxhide, avoiding rash action; when the time ripens ("second six"), decisive movement becomes imperative.
The passage emphasizes that noble cultivation focuses on nurturing inner virtue, maintaining integrity whether one's talents find expression or not. The way of transformation lies in seizing the timely moment and aligning with celestial patterns, requiring both revolutionary resolve and strategic methodology.
This passage expounds on the philosophy of transformation as embodied in the "Ge" (Reform) hexagram from the Book of Changes. The Ge hexagram symbolizes the natural laws governing change in heaven, earth, and all things—much like the anomalous phenomenon of fire within a lake (with the Dui trigram representing the lake below and the Li trigram representing fire above), which signifies a state of yin-yang imbalance.
The scripture states that the "ji day" (when matters reach their extreme point) is the most opportune moment for reform, ensuring auspicious outcomes free from calamity. The Nine in the Third Line warns that forced reforms invite danger, requiring repeated deliberation ("three rounds of reform discussions") to earn trust. The Nine in the Fourth Line affirms that sincerity of heart ensures good fortune when altering old mandates. The Nine in the Fifth Line depicts great figures transforming as naturally as tigers shedding fur—their changes inspire conviction without divination. The Top Six Line describes noble individuals refining their essence like leopards molting, while ordinary people adjust superficial attitudes; here, rash advances are ill-advised, and only upholding integrity brings fortune.
The commentary explains: Reform is undertaken only when unavoidable. Just as two maidens dwelling together (Dui as the younger sister, Li as the middle sister) inevitably breed conflict, when tensions escalate to water-and-fire incompatibility, transformation becomes inevitable. Yet sages never initiate reform lightly—only when heaven and earth manifest anomalies (like yin-yang disharmony) do they align with celestial timing to guide change. Authentic reform must move hearts through sincerity, like compasses correcting squares or carving returning to simplicity, never through coercion.
Finally, the meaning of "ji day" is clarified: The twelve two-hour periods of the day cycle naturally, with yin and yang waxing and waning by their own rhythms. When yang energy culminates ("the moment of fullness"), it marks the turning point where yin begins its transformation ("ji day"). Seizing this pivotal moment ensures reforms resolve matters thoroughly, leaving no lingering repercussions.
This scripture elucidates the principle of transformation. When human emotions deviate from innate nature, as long as essence and temperament remain harmonious, the change is not false or delusional. From this we understand that the power of spiritual operation cannot be opposed even by Heaven—how much less by humans? If transformation gains the trust of all people, it becomes vast and penetrating; if it endures for ten thousand generations, it brings benefit and longevity—how could there be any regret?
Yet to achieve mutual trust between inner and outer realms, one must rely on the power of wenming (civilizing culture, referring to ritual and music) and joy (harmonious accord). Civilization enables people to comprehend principles and perceive the patterns of all things; joy allows human nature and emotions to resonate without opposing the timeliness of events. Where timeliness leads is where righteousness resides, and where righteousness resides is where the heart of Heaven and Earth finds its lodging. All transformations under Heaven ultimately stem from transformations in the human heart—thus the revolutions of Tang of Shang and Wu of Zhou were responses to Heaven and accord with humanity. Had Heaven not consented and people not followed, how could they have succeeded in overthrowing Jie of Xia and Zhou of Shang?
The scripture uses the hexagram image of "fire in the marsh" to illustrate: just as water can extinguish fire, transformation is compelled by timeliness, like the sun's course that cannot be halted. Sages understand this principle, using the Dao of Heaven as their measure in times of crisis, making "discerning timeliness, complying with opportunities, seizing moments, and steadfastly maintaining timing" the essential art of governance. Transformation is not something sages enact arbitrarily—it is action taken in accordance with the transformations of Heaven and Earth.
Regarding concrete methods of transformation: In the initial stage, when institutions are not yet completely decayed, those in lower positions may contemplate change, while those in higher positions must shoulder the responsibility for transformation. The first line (initial stage of change) shows the opportunity for transformation has appeared, but action is still inadvisable—one should maintain a centered and compliant attitude, reinforcing the current situation like strengthening with ox-hide, avoiding rash action. The second line (developmental stage) occupies the central position—here one should match gentle virtue with civilizing culture, ensuring auspicious action without fault. But note: ministers should not take the lead in advocating change; they must await the proper "day of Ji" (opportune moment for transformation), planning thoroughly and complying with timeliness—only then can transformation succeed. A ruler's transformation must gain trust before the moment ripens, while a minister's transformation should be implemented only after the moment arrives, advancing with calm and steady demeanor to avoid chaos.
This passage from the Yi Shuo (Discourse on Change) elucidates the principles of transformation. When facing circumstances requiring reform, if one pushes for change with excessive rigidity and impatience ("the nature is overly rigid and agitated in enacting change"), it will alienate people instead—even with correct intentions, the outcome will be perilous ("though upright, it remains severe"). The key lies in repeated deliberation ("thinking thrice") and avoiding rash alterations, as only then can reform genuinely gain public trust ("change must be embraced by the hearts of the people").
The text uses different hexagram lines as metaphors for various roles in reform: the auspiciousness of the second line stems from its gentle and appropriate approach ("softness properly ascends"), while the peril of the third line arises from rigid and reckless advancement ("rigidity fears progress"). The fourth line, positioned at the moment of transformation, requires unwavering integrity coupled with adaptability ("benefiting from firm righteousness and the skill of balancing tension and relaxation") to thoroughly eradicate entrenched abuses. The fifth line symbolizes a great leader guiding reform ("the virtue of the great person is the master of change"), capable of weighing past and present ("adjusting the gains and losses of antiquity and deliberating over the ways of a hundred kings") and implementing transformation with majestic authority ("the awe of a tiger's transformation").
When reform is complete ("the path of change is fully realized"), the ruler establishes grand policies ("the sovereign who initiates revolution and creates institutions"), while ministers refine specific laws and edicts ("ministers who perfect wise strategies and polish details"), much like the renewed splendor of a tiger or leopard's pelt ("a leopard's transformation"). At this stage, the emphasis shifts to governing through non-action (Wuwei) ("the value lies in non-action, avoiding excessive force"). Maintaining stability brings good fortune, while agitation invites misfortune.
Finally, the text clarifies that sages do not delight in change ("the sage does not take pleasure in transformation"). Even revolutions like those of Tang of Shang or Wu of Zhou were acts of necessity ("the tiger's transformation was also unavoidable"). The author laments how later generations often pursue reform with the rash impulsiveness of the third line ("the restless ambition of the ninth three") or the reckless movement of the sixth line after change is already complete ("the misfortune of the top six's advance"). These failures stem from not grasping the proper method of transformation.
This passage explores the profound meaning of the Ding (Cauldron) hexagram from the Book of Changes. The cauldron, an ancient cooking vessel, symbolizes both state power and moral cultivation. Those with talent who indulge selfish desires or hold high positions yet misuse authority fall far short of sage rulers like Yao and Shun. Even compared to virtuous kings like Tang of Shang or Wu of Zhou, they possess only superficial grandeur without true De (Virtue/Power) — a lamentable state.
The Ding hexagram combines Xun (Wind ☴) below and Li (Fire ☲) above, depicting wood burning beneath flames like a cauldron cooking food. Sages used cauldrons to prepare sacrificial offerings for Heaven and to nourish the worthy with bountiful meals. This imagery reveals how humility (Xun) sharpens perception, while gentle progress (Li) attains the Middle Way by harmonizing with strength, thus ensuring great prosperity.
The individual line statements further illuminate: The initial Yin line (6th line) shows an overturned cauldron suited for discarding dregs — akin to taking a concubine to bear children, signifying renewal by abandoning the old. The second Yang line (9th line) warns of food in the cauldron spoiled by an ailing companion, urging caution. The fourth Yin line (6th line) depicts broken legs spilling a noble’s feast, foretelling grave missteps. The fifth Yin line (6th line) describes golden handles and rings, symbolizing adherence to the Dao. The top Yang line (9th line) features jade rings as supremely auspicious, embodying perfect balance of firmness and yielding.
As a ritual vessel, the cauldron’s value manifests De. Sages designed hexagrams not merely to represent objects but to encompass all meanings. Though the cauldron’s parts (ears, rings, belly, legs) correspond to the hexagram’s structure, one must avoid rigid literalism — reflecting the Book of Changes principle that interpretations "cannot be reduced to fixed formulas." Like the Well hexagram, the Cauldron symbolizes vital aspects of livelihood. Those wielding the cauldron’s power must prioritize De, governing the world as one balances flavors in cooking — only impartiality ensures lasting prosperity.
The Ding hexagram takes Xun (humility) as its substance and Li (illumination) as its function, demonstrating how yielding Yin perfects firm Yang. Sages modeled artifacts on hexagrams: wood under fire inspired the cauldron’s design. Heaven reveals the signs; humanity completes the form — thus the cauldron’s utility is realized. Yet its greater purpose lies in consolidating celestial mandate and uniting hearts. Hence, cauldron-cooked offerings express utmost sincerity to Heaven, while feasts for sages display reverence. Herein lies the cauldron’s true grandeur.
This scripture expounds the philosophy of ruler-minister relations and self-cultivation through the symbolic meaning of the Ding hexagram (one of the 64 hexagrams in the Yijing).
The wise express reverence through ceremonial cooking (ancient sacrificial rites), maintaining inner humility (symbolized by the Xun trigram) while outwardly demonstrating clarity (symbolized by the Li trigram). They can deeply contemplate moral principles while wisely discerning the right timing. The function of the Ding (cauldron) lies in perfectly embodying these virtues. The fifth line represents the ruler occupying the honored position with gentle virtue, while the second line represents the minister shouldering great responsibility with strength and wisdom—hence the auspicious "great prosperity" (yuanheng) of the hexagram. Just as fire cooks food, the image of the Ding reflects this harmonious cooperation.
The noble person emulates the humility of the earth and the lofty wisdom of heaven, employing intelligence through a gentle disposition, thereby stabilizing their position and fulfilling their mission. Humans are born endowed with the harmonious Qi of heaven and earth, and the key lies in applying the Middle Way. When rulers and ministers each abide in their proper roles, they do not violate the Mandate of Heaven. A correct position ensures a stable mission, just as a properly formed cauldron can fulfill its nourishing function—these two principles are interconnected.
The Ding hexagram values upward progression, much like the Well hexagram (Jing) awaiting use—there is a proper sequence that must not be disrupted. The first and fourth lines resonate but lack sufficient ability, like a minister failing in duty and overturning the cauldron’s legs. If one awakens to correction, discarding weakness to follow the Yang path, danger can be averted, bringing unexpected joy like a concubine bearing a son. A concubine serving her husband is akin to a minister serving his ruler—remaining content in a humble position and laboring diligently is fitting, hence blameless.
The second line (Nine in the Second Place) possesses abundant virtue but, being close to the first line, is inevitably disturbed by petty men. If one holds firmly to the Middle Way, guarding strictly without provoking conflict, the task of assistance can be fulfilled. The third line has both virtue and talent, worthy of great reward, but if unwilling to serve, it is like a cauldron full of delicacies left uneaten. Yet by adhering to the right path, one will eventually meet an enlightened ruler, as joyous as rain after a long drought.
The fourth line bears heavy responsibility but lacks true ability—improper appointments lead to ruinous governance, like the ominous omen of broken cauldron legs and spilled food. In such cases, even sacrifices to Heaven and nourishing the worthy become impossible, falling far short of expectations. The fifth line employs the worthy with humility, deeply understanding the Dao and skillfully utilizing talent, thus eternally preserving the cauldron’s purpose.
This scripture primarily discusses two sections: the philosophy of the "Cauldron Hexagram" (Ding Gua) and the interpretation of the "Thunder Hexagram" (Zhen Gua).
Regarding the Cauldron Hexagram:
A cauldron (an ancient cooking vessel) must be sturdy to withstand the heat of fire, yet excessive rigidity can damage its wooden frame. The ideal state is one of luminous clarity combined with gentle warmth, where firmness and flexibility harmonize to form the perfect "jade handle" (the jade ornament on the cauldron's ears). This mirrors the Dao of governance, where different positions require distinct approaches: the first line (Chu Yao) signifies the need to purge corruption; the second line represents restraining the powerful; the third warns against overly hasty reforms; the fourth, though capable of mediating between upper and lower, lacks sufficient strength; the fifth exemplifies using softness to temper rigidity—the most fitting approach; and the top line achieves the greatest auspiciousness through balanced firmness and flexibility. The cauldron and the well (another hexagram) symbolize fire and water respectively: water's virtue lies in flow, fire's in restraint—when these two are properly coordinated, great fortune follows.
Regarding the Thunder Hexagram:
The Thunder Hexagram (symbolizing thunder) signifies smooth progress. The initial roar of thunder induces fear, but soon gives way to calm laughter; though thunder resounds for a hundred miles, one remains composed during rituals. This illustrates how fear can bring blessings, while laughter arises from following the natural order; the thunder's far-reaching reverberations symbolize the sovereign's ability to protect the realm. The noble person (Junzi) should maintain vigilance and cultivate self-reflection. Each line reveals distinct lessons: the first Yang line (Chu Jiu) turns fear into auspiciousness; the second Yin line (Liu Er) suffers loss but ultimately recovers; the third Yin line, due to its improper position, trembles with anxiety; the fourth Yang line is trapped in difficulty with little room to act; the fifth Yin line, though in peril, remains unharmed by adhering to the Middle Way; the top Yin line's excessive fear leads to perilous actions—a warning against misdirected apprehension.
(Note: The term "Yao" refers to the six component lines of a hexagram, numbered from bottom to top as Chu, Er, San, Si, Wu, and Shang Yao.)
This passage comes from the Yi Shuo (Discourse on the Changes), primarily explaining the symbolic meaning of the "Zhen" (Thunder) hexagram in the Yijing (Classic of Changes). "Zhen" represents thunder, symbolizing shock and awakening. The scripture states: When a person maintains reverence in their heart and remains vigilant at all times, they can avoid calamity. Just as thunder shakes all things, the noble person must also stay alert and reflect on themselves when change arrives.
The Zhen hexagram is composed of two Thunder trigrams overlapping (both upper and lower trigrams are Zhen), symbolizing yang energy rising vigorously from within yin energy. The movement of heaven and earth follows the principle that yang will never remain suppressed forever—just as petty men may temporarily oppress noble individuals, or human desires may momentarily obscure heavenly principle, these conditions cannot endure. The key lies in maintaining a cautious heart before the thunder even arrives, enabling one to respond to changes with composure.
Among the six lines of the Zhen hexagram, the initial nine (yang) line and the fourth nine (yang) line are most crucial. The initial nine line symbolizes yang's firm autonomy, allowing one to remain composed and at ease. The fourth nine line, however, is trapped between yin lines above and below, as if mired in mud and unable to extricate itself. The second six (yin) line, positioned above the initial nine, faces danger; the fifth six (yin) line, positioned above the fourth nine, encounters peril in both advance and retreat, though it is relatively milder. The second six line's loss of position symbolizes the loss of treasures, while the fifth six line, occupying a yang position, must not be lost—hence it is called "great non-loss."
The noble person should emulate the spirit of the Zhen hexagram: cultivating reverence before change arrives and reflecting on their faults. In ordinary times, they must maintain reverence for the Dao (the Way), and in moments of crisis, they must be even more strict with themselves. Just as thunder shakes repeatedly without cease, the noble person must remain vigilant at all times. Only then can they shoulder great responsibilities, with virtue worthy of the expectations of ancestral temples and the state, and a reputation as awe-inspiring as the sound of thunder.
This passage elucidates the principles of the "Zhen" (Thunder) and "Gen" (Mountain) hexagrams from the Yijing (Book of Changes) in contemporary terms:
The Zhen hexagram teaches how to confront danger. When facing extreme peril (the "danger of nine hills"), maintaining a yielding yet upright attitude allows one to preserve integrity and ultimately return to the proper position. The phrase "recovery in seven days" indicates that cautious action over time transforms crisis into safety. The fifth line's mention of "having affairs" reminds us to remain vigilant and plan strategically.
The third line, being distant from the initial line, shows the thunder's vibration gradually subsiding—yet one must still tread carefully, avoiding confrontation with rigidity to avert misfortune. The topmost line, farthest removed, becomes utterly silent if unmoved. However, the yielding nature inherently carries apprehension; hesitation arises when looking ahead and behind. Hence "advance brings misfortune"—one shouldn't push outward but rather turn back to aid the third line. Forcing rigid methods invites danger, whereas maintaining stillness, though potentially sacrificing certain connections, won't violate the Dao of serving yang.
Yang's strength can be avoided but not defied. Supporting yang and restraining yin reflects the sage's original mind and heaven-earth's intent. Some ask why the initial line—as the master of Zhen—laughs freely instead of showing caution first. Precisely this demonstrates reverence for yang's principle: yang occupies auspicious positions while yin belongs to inauspicious ones, as is proper. Repeated phrases like "recovery in seven days," "nothing lost," and "no blame" all admonish us to maintain wariness during change, never indulging in careless pleasure.
Ministers serving rulers or petty people serving noble ones avoid peril through constant vigilance. Danger can bring stability, yet stability may breed danger. Those who recognize danger only when it arrives are inferior; those who foresee it beforehand are superior. Each line discusses understanding danger within danger—hence achieving "no blame" though not great fortune. As for those who "startle a hundred leagues without dropping the sacrificial spoon"—they perceive danger within stability, treating stability as potential danger, thus never truly falling into peril. Such individuals can govern nations.
The Gen hexagram embodies the principle of "stopping." Gen means cessation—stopping when one should stop, moving when one should move. Aligning movement and stillness with timeliness illuminates the path. "Stopping the back" means halting at the proper place. When upper and lower lines oppose rather than harmonize, one "does not obtain the body" (loses self-awareness) and "walks in the courtyard without seeing people"—thus committing no fault.
The Gen hexagram (symbolizing stillness and cessation) in the Book of Changes (Yijing) consists of a single yang line resting above two yin lines. Yin represents stopping, while yang represents tranquil stability, hence its name "Gen" (Restraint). The hexagram statement speaks of "restraining the back" because the human back internally houses the organs while externally connecting the limbs, remaining desireless and free of mental preoccupations whether in motion or stillness - perfectly embodying the true meaning of cessation.
The first six (yin) line suggests that stopping at the toes prevents mistakes and benefits prolonged adherence to the correct path. The second six line describes restraining the calves without rescuing followers, causing inner discontent. The third nine (yang) line warns that forcibly stopping at the waist leads to a torn spine and heart-searing pain. The fourth six line indicates stopping the entire body brings no misfortune. The fifth six line shows restraining the cheeks brings orderly speech and dispels regret. The top nine line concludes that profound stillness ultimately brings good fortune.
This hexagram reveals: Though all things under heaven undergo endless transformations, they follow inherent patterns. By discerning the subtle timing between movement and stillness - acting when appropriate and stopping when necessary - one attains the state where "movement is cessation and cessation is movement." Those who truly understand the Dao of cessation forget self and others alike; their inner tranquility naturally manifests wisdom, while their external expression remains perfectly harmonious.
Though the upper and lower trigrams correspond in this hexagram, it's an obligatory correspondence (called "hostile correspondence"), like two mountains standing independently - maintaining stillness yet observing from afar. The noble person thus realizes that contemplation shouldn't exceed proper bounds, just as mountains remain in their positions: in stillness lies far-sighted vision.
This passage explores the philosophical insights from the "Gen" hexagram (symbolizing mountain and stillness) and "Jian" hexagram in the Book of Changes (Yijing), focusing primarily on the wisdom of "stopping" (zhi).
By observing the interlocking patterns of mountain ranges, one can grasp the principle of "stopping" when viewing them separately. Human thoughts are often chaotic, but if one applies the concept of "stopping" to regulate them, the mind can return to its proper state. When thoughts no longer disturb the heart-mind (xin), and external things no longer agitate the spirit (shen), one can maintain their fundamental nature. If vision and hearing align with the natural order, even amidst worldly complexities, one will not lose their innate authenticity.
Analyzing the meanings of the six lines (yao) in the hexagram:
- The first line represents an inherently tranquil nature, where inner desires have not yet arisen, but one must be cautious of external temptations.
- The second line demonstrates the ability to remain peacefully self-contained.
- The third line warns that stubbornly forcing stillness may instead lead to entrapment.
- The fourth line suggests that stopping in accordance with the right timing prevents reckless mistakes.
- The fifth line, occupying the noble position (symbolizing a ruler), embodies perfect balance in movement and stillness, speech and action.
- The top line represents the ability to consistently maintain the cultivation of "stopping" to the very end.
The "Jian" hexagram (composed of Gen below and Xun above) illustrates the process of gradual progress, much like a bride following proper rituals in marriage. The hexagram text states: "Gradual advancement brings good fortune; progress must find its proper position to succeed." Advancing with rectitude can bring order to the state, as the position is firm yet balanced. By acting with stillness and gentleness, sustainable development is possible. Just as trees grow slowly on a mountain, a noble person (junzi) should accumulate virtue (de) and refine customs.
The first line uses the imagery of "a wild goose gradually alighting on the shore" to emphasize cautious action. The entire passage underscores the profound teaching of the sages: knowing when to stop is of great significance. The essence of "stopping" lies in halting precisely where one ought to halt.
This passage interprets the "Gradual Advance" hexagram (Jian Gua) from the Book of Changes using the metaphor of wild geese progressing through stages to illustrate human development. The hexagram's image of wind over mountain (Xun/Wind above, Gen/Mountain below) symbolizes the natural law of gradual progression.
The first line describes a young goose just reaching the water's edge. Though its position remains unsteady, maintaining vigilance and heeding advice while avoiding rashness prevents mistakes—much like how young people navigating challenges succeed by exercising discretion.
The second line shows the goose securely perched on a boulder while feeding, enjoying rewards earned through diligent effort rather than unearned gains, thus auspicious. This signifies how steady accumulation yields enduring benefits.
The third line warns of danger when geese venture onto arid land: akin to a husband lost in battle or a wife suffering difficult childbirth, yet advantageous when resisting invaders. It cautions that reckless advancement severs communal ties and violates natural order, whereas united defense turns peril into security.
The fourth line depicts geese alighting on trees, finding stable branches through adaptability. This mirrors how those in high positions maintain stability through humility and flexibility.
The fifth line describes geese ascending hills, where a wife's three-year infertility ultimately yields fulfillment. It demonstrates how perseverance in righteous paths, like vegetation requiring time to flourish, eventually bears fruit despite temporary setbacks.
The top line portrays geese soaring into clouds, their feathers becoming ceremonial adornments—symbolizing how sublime virtue at life's pinnacle becomes exemplary. It emphasizes maintaining integrity when reaching ultimate heights.
The hexagram's core teaching reveals all transformations follow gradual processes. The noble person should emulate mountain trees—growing upward while rooted firmly. In turbulent times, one must discern opportunities, regulate conduct through ritual, and accumulate virtue to refine customs progressively. Neither stagnation nor impetuousness serves: like geese selecting resting places judiciously, only measured advancement leads to fulfillment.
This passage explains the hexagram imagery and line statements of the "Returning Maiden" (Guimei) hexagram from the Book of Changes. The hexagram consists of Dui (representing the Lake) below Zhen (representing Thunder), symbolizing a young maiden's marriage, yet the hexagram text warns that "advancing brings misfortune with no benefit."
The imagery reveals that when Heaven and Earth's Yin and Yang fail to interact, all things cease to flourish—just as marriage represents a pivotal life event. Although marriage follows natural order (moving through joy), improper timing (misaligned position) or softness overpowering strength (the yielding riding the firm) invites misfortune. The noble person should contemplate long-term consequences and foresee potential pitfalls.
Each line statement uses different marital scenarios as metaphors for proper conduct: The initial nine line describes a younger sister accompanying the bride—like walking with a limp yet still progressing—symbolizing how maintaining one's proper role brings auspiciousness. The second nine line speaks of blurred vision suiting one who dwells in seclusion, advising adherence to normalcy without reckless action. The third six line warns of a main bride reverting to a companion's role, cautioning against overstepping one's position. The fourth nine line's delayed wedding date illustrates awaiting the proper moment. The fifth six line recounts Emperor Yi's daughter marrying with simple attire yet achieving nobility through virtue. The top six line uses the metaphor of a bloodless sacrificial basket to expose empty appearances that ultimately bear no fruit.
The passage concludes by revealing how "Returning Maiden" inherits the profound meaning from the preceding "Gradual Advance" (Jian) hexagram: Just as a maiden preserves her purity like jade, a noble person upholding the Dao must first calm the mind and rectify intention before moving with the flow. The hexagram repeatedly emphasizes gradual progress—like a bride awaiting the auspicious hour, human affairs require measured timing rather than rash advancement. Those in exalted positions should particularly take this as their standard, maintaining transcendent perspective toward advancement and retreat.
This passage from Yishuo explains the principles of Yin-Yang and male-female relationships through the "Guimei" hexagram (a marriage-related hexagram in the Zhouyi). It warns that deviating from the proper path to conform to worldly customs not only hinders progress but also brings harm to oneself and the state, signifying misfortune. The hexagram structure features the Dui trigram (representing the youngest daughter) as the main body and the Zhen trigram (representing the eldest son) as its function, embodying the principle of Yin submitting to Yang.
The mutual resonance of Yin and Yang is the fundamental law of heaven and earth. When Yang Qi (vital energy) flows smoothly within and Yin Qi moves inversely outward, it reveals the profound mechanism of cosmic creation. Yin follows Yang, while Yang acts upon Yin—this dynamic generates the vitality of the universe. Without the interaction of heaven and earth, all things would cease to grow; without the union of man and woman, humanity would perish. The Zhen trigram symbolizes the eldest son inheriting his father's legacy externally, while the Dui trigram represents the youngest daughter adhering to her mother's teachings internally. A woman upholding her marital duties may seem like an endpoint, yet it marks the beginning of human relationships.
However, when a man takes the initiative and a woman responds with excessive delight, such joy becomes improper if unchecked. A woman who loses her proper role cannot sustain the household, hence the need to guard against actions skewed by personal emotions. Just as marsh waters (Dui) descend with the thunder (Zhen), symbolizing a woman following a man's lead, this is the meaning of "Guimei" (Returning Maiden). From this, the noble person understands that marital bonds must balance deep affection—like the harmony of Yin and Yang—with adherence to cosmic righteousness. Only by establishing a proper foundation can the relationship endure. Rash actions driven solely by fleeting joy will inevitably lead to upheaval, emphasizing the need for prudence from the outset.
The text uses the six Yao (lines) as metaphors: The first Yao resembles a virtuous minister without an enlightened ruler, just as a virtuous woman may become a concubine rather than a wife. The second Yao advises loyal ministers serving unworthy rulers to remonstrate tactfully, akin to recluses preserving integrity. The third Yao warns that the unvirtuous will be cast aside, like an inferior sister in a dowry. The fourth Yao affirms that the virtuous will eventually meet a wise sovereign, as a noblewoman marrying late still upholds propriety. The fifth and sixth Yao suggest rulers must welcome the worthy with humility, just as princesses marrying downward should embrace simplicity over vanity. Ultimately, it stresses that true De (Virtue) lies in valuing frugality and rejecting extravagance.
This scripture passage primarily discusses two main sections:
The first section analyzes interpersonal relationships through the lens of the "Returning Maiden" (Guimei) hexagram. It points out that when individuals lack genuine virtue (De) yet pursue vanity and superficiality, their actions become excessive. If a woman abandons proper feminine conduct or a man forsakes masculine principles, it's like carrying an empty basket (symbolizing mere appearances) or slaughtering a sheep without drawing blood (symbolizing futile efforts), ultimately leading to misfortune. The text emphasizes that pursuing official positions must follow the correct path (Dao), with each line from the initial nine to six-four demonstrating the importance of self-restraint. While the six-fifth line holds high status, it maintains humility, whereas the top six line's extreme arrogance results in isolation. The author laments those who covet wealth and status without walking the proper path, warning that wielding great power under such circumstances inevitably invites disaster.
The second section explains the meaning of the "Abundance" (Feng) hexagram. "Abundance" symbolizes magnificent brightness, through which rulers manifest their virtue (De). The hexagram shows thunder above fire (Li below Zhen), and noble persons should emulate this by exercising discerning judgment and impartial justice. However, it cautions about the principle of reversal at extremes: the sun declines after reaching its zenith, and the moon wanes after becoming full—this being the natural way of heaven and earth. The individual line statements respectively indicate: the initial nine line meeting a compatible ruler may gain support; the six-second line maintaining sincerity despite doubts brings good fortune; the nine-third line's excessive expansion leads to loss; the nine-fourth line, though in unclear circumstances, finds auspiciousness when encountering like-minded companions; and the six-fifth line's recruitment of worthy talents brings blessings.
(Note: "Returning Maiden" refers to the 54th hexagram of the Zhouyi, symbolizing marriage; "Abundance" is the 55th hexagram representing magnificence. "Di" refers to a younger sister accompanying the bride, "kui yang" denotes the ancient ritual of sacrificing sheep by drawing blood, while "pei zhu" and "yi zhu" both indicate like-minded companions.)
This passage elucidates the philosophy of the "Feng Hexagram" (Abundance) from the Book of Changes, exploring the natural laws governing the waxing and waning of all phenomena. The auspiciousness of the sixth five line stems from maintaining vigilance during prosperity, while the ominous sixth top line warns how excessive expansion leads to isolation.
The Feng Hexagram symbolizes the state of abundance brought by illumination and action, yet reveals that any fullness reaching its zenith often marks the beginning of decline. To sustain prosperity long-term, one must remain alert during favorable circumstances. This vigilance isn't passive worry, but rather resembles the noonday sun illuminating all things—actively discerning latent issues before they manifest.
The author employs natural metaphors: the sun declines after reaching its zenith, the moon wanes after becoming full. If even heaven and earth follow these cycles of growth and decay, how much more should human affairs? True wisdom recognizes that behind the abundant spectacle of thunder (Zhen Hexagram) and lightning (Li Hexagram) lies the need for judicial clarity and decisive action—like a magistrate administering justice—to maintain equilibrium.
The interplay between the initial nine and fourth nine lines demonstrates how those in lower positions should interact with superiors: while maintaining sincere cooperation ("meeting counterparts"), they must preserve independent judgment ("meeting equals"). Even without immediate achievements ("though temporarily blameless"), steadfast adherence to principle ("perseverance brings reward") ultimately gains recognition. This reveals the key to enduring prosperity—maintaining clarity during success and upholding integrity within collaboration.
This scripture primarily discusses how to maintain upright principles and wise attitudes during life's journey.
It first explains that if one can cultivate virtue (De) daily and align with the heavenly Dao, their actions will be free from misfortune, and persistence will lead to success. When those in lower positions encounter superiors who are ignorant or misguided, they should rectify themselves to influence others, eliminating harmful thoughts to prevent errors. Just as the right hand is most prone to improper movements, petty people often act with hidden malice and restlessness. By restraining such improper behaviors, one can avoid calamity.
During times of national prosperity, if the ruler enjoys unnecessary meddling and displays restless agitation, petty individuals will seize opportunities to manipulate power and create disturbances, rarely without disastrous consequences. Even if the ruler is inherently weak and ignorant, they can still govern effectively by supplementing their deficiencies with the wisdom of virtuous individuals and humbly embracing talents from all corners of the world. A ruler should not fear being unable to perceive the world clearly but rather fear being unable to attract worthy talents. Attracting such talents is the best method for achieving clear perception.
The scripture criticizes rulers who indulge in pleasure and are misled by close attendants, likening them to those who dwell in luxurious palaces yet remain blind to the outside world. Examples include Emperor Qin Shi Huang, Emperor Wu of Han, and Emperor Huizong of Song, who were deluded by temporary insights and failed to awaken. The mid-Han dynasty was able to reflect and revive itself, while the Song dynasty remained unenlightened and suffered disasters.
Finally, it emphasizes that wise rulers and ministers should understand that the more they restrain themselves, the brighter they become, whereas the more they display themselves, the more they descend into darkness. Arrogance, indulgence, and lack of self-reflection inevitably lead to downfall.
Regarding the "Travel Hexagram" (Lü Gua):
The Travel Hexagram symbolizes a person on a journey. Though only minor success is attainable, steadfast adherence to the right path brings auspiciousness. The significance of travel is profound. Just as fire rests upon a mountain, the noble person should employ punishments with wisdom and caution, ensuring legal matters are not delayed.
The first six (Yin line at the bottom) states: Being overly calculative during travel invites misfortune upon oneself, as narrow-mindedness attracts disaster.
The second six states: Finding lodging at an inn during travel, carrying wealth, and gaining a loyal servant—this is favorable.
This passage from the Yi Shuo explains the wisdom of the "Travel" hexagram (symbolizing journeys and sojourning in foreign lands). When dwelling abroad, the key lies in maintaining inner stability without being trapped by external circumstances.
The third yang line (Nine-Three) states that a burning inn and losing attendants signify how excessive rigidity invites danger. The Xiang Zhuan commentary explains this as loss caused by improper relations between the traveler and subordinates. The fourth yang line (Nine-Four) mentions acquiring resources and tools ("Zi Fu" refers to wealth and axe-shaped currency), yet remaining inwardly discontent because one has not yet found their proper place.
The fifth yin line (Six-Five) uses the metaphor of shooting a pheasant—though one arrow is lost, reputation will ultimately be gained. The top yang line (Nine-Nine) depicts the ominous sign of a bird's nest burning, where the traveler first rejoices but later grieves, akin to losing cattle in unfamiliar territory. This illustrates how an overly elevated position can instead invite misfortune.
The essence of sojourning is temporary residence—whether in governance or commerce, one remains a traveler. In such times, one must preserve their fundamental nature and maintain pure intent: the heart should be as steady as a mountain (the Gen hexagram), while actions should be as discerning as fire (the Li hexagram). The noble person thus learns to adjudicate legal matters decisively, acting with the same resoluteness as a traveler who does not linger.
When handling affairs while traveling, observe: though the situation is transient, it must not be treated casually; though matters may seem trivial, they should not be underestimated. The first line (Six-One), lacking foresight, invites self-inflicted humiliation, while the second line (Six-Two), gentle and balanced, ensures proper settlement. The third line (Nine-Three), overly rigid, clashes with the environment and loses protection. The entire hexagram teaches that when dwelling abroad, one must understand the Dao of advance and retreat—possessing both insight and magnanimity.
This scripture primarily expounds on the philosophy of conducting oneself during journeys or challenging circumstances.
When traveling without support, even upright conduct may encounter danger. As the fourth line suggests, leaving a stable environment for foreign lands may bring material assistance (资斧, zifu), yet the dwelling remains unsuitable with no like-minded companions. Discord with those around you and unrecognized talents in this world—how could anything go smoothly?
The fifth line represents a wise ruler. A visiting minister's initial audience might face minor obstructions due to small faults, but ultimately, he will attain honor and appointment. The topmost ninth line warns that arrogance and self-satisfaction lead to ruin—like a bird's nest burned or cattle lost—leaving one stranded with no one to care.
Thus, though the encounters on a journey may seem coincidental, one must steadfastly uphold the right path in life. What appears trivial requires knowing when to stop to ensure smooth progress. Consider:
- The first line: Contentment with a humble position avoids self-inflicted misfortune.
- The second line: Satisfaction with one's dwelling, free from greed, brings unexpected gain.
- The third line: Failing to restrain oneself even after losing one's home leads to greater loss.
- The fourth line: Humility attracts support without ostentation.
- The fifth line: Adhering to the middle path yields brilliance without flaunting.
Is not life itself a hundred-year journey? Though individual experiences differ, the principle remains universal. Those who grasp this truth adapt to circumstances while preserving their true nature. With loyalty and sincerity, one can find peace even in wild lands. Hence, those who truly understand the I Ching master the art of living.
The passage then turns to the Xun hexagram (☴, symbolizing wind), representing humility and gentleness. Though its power is modest (小亨, xiaoheng), it favors progress and meeting noble figures. The hexagram's doubled wind (重巽, chongxun) mirrors how a ruler's decrees cascade through layers. The first line advises decisive, steadfast movement, like a soldier's discipline. Overall, it emphasizes the wisdom of balancing humility with integrity, blending firmness and flexibility in navigating life.
This passage from the "Explanations of the Changes" discusses the symbolism and line interpretations of the Xun hexagram (representing gentleness and humility). The Xun hexagram shows one yielding line (yin) beneath two firm lines (yang), symbolizing the state of yielding to strength. While great undertakings in the world require great talent to accomplish, the Xun hexagram reveals an attitude of modesty and low-profile. Though one may avoid mistakes in action, there's ultimately an insufficiency of ability, hence it's described as "small success" (xiao heng). However, if one can use the virtue of gentleness to follow great and strong leaders, it's still possible to achieve merit by borrowing others' strength.
Regarding individual lines:
The initial six (the bottom yin line) occupies a humble position. Hesitation in action makes accomplishment difficult, so one needs the decisive firmness of a warrior to gain advantage.
The nine in the second place (yang line) resembles a shaman humbly prostrating beneath a bed. Though appearing chaotic, its central position brings auspiciousness without misfortune.
The nine in the third place shows excessive humility leads to distress because one's aspirations become suppressed.
The six in the fourth place sees regrets vanish, like obtaining diverse game in hunting—a sign of achievement and merit.
The nine in the fifth place maintains correctness with auspiciousness; regrets disappear and affairs proceed smoothly. Actions taken three days before and after the "Geng day" (following ancient calendrical selection) will be fortunate due to its proper and balanced position.
The top nine line demonstrates extreme humility to the point of losing resources and tools. Even maintaining correctness brings misfortune because it reaches an extreme.
Overall, the Xun hexagram teaches the principle of balancing strength and gentleness. Strength without the temperance of gentleness becomes narrow and tyrannical, while gentleness unaccompanied by strength degenerates into flattery and timidity. When noble persons implement governance, they repeatedly clarify commands—not through empty proclamations or penal intimidation, but by transforming hearts through benevolent virtue (De). Just as wind (symbolized by Xun) penetrates everywhere without gaps, so should rulers govern like the wind, ensuring policies take root in people's hearts through persistent reiteration.
This passage primarily discusses the importance of humility and sincerity in human interactions while maintaining principles, warning against excessive flattery.
The text first explains the attitude of yielding humility: If one can maintain humility, compliance, reverence, and honesty, they can express genuine sincerity and alleviate a ruler's hidden concerns. The key lies in sincerity manifesting true loyalty. The phrase "using historians and shamans frequently brings good fortune without blame" suggests that frequent communication with the divine, like court historians and ritual priests, is auspicious. However, excessive submissiveness in social interactions borders on sycophancy and easily leads to deviant paths. When communicating with deities in this manner, it must be done with wholehearted sincerity and silent attainment to be truly auspicious.
Next, it analyzes different situations: The fourth line, though in a strong position, relies on proper principles and thus can subdue violence without regret. The fifth line, though surrounded by multiple strong positions, maintains proper alignment and can take initiative in issuing commands without regret. The repeated mention of "regret vanishes" indicates that Yang (阳刚) energy should neither be suppressed nor excessive—both must be balanced according to one's capacity and circumstances.
The third line, due to frustrated ambitions, exhibits forced compliance that lacks sincerity. When superiors are excessively yielding, it stems from indecisiveness and inability to know when to stop. Hence, the third line warns of difficulties, while the superior position warns of misfortune.
Those who covet wealth and power, solely protecting their interests through fawning and obsequiousness to maintain status, unknowingly sacrifice dignity and decisiveness—ultimately losing their authority. When everything is lost yet they remain unrepentant, it's truly lamentable. Even if they appear upright outwardly, having deviated from the true path, how can this be called genuine adherence to proper principles?
Finally, it explains the meaning of the Dui (兑) hexagram (comprising two Dui trigrams): Dui represents joy—firm within yet gentle without. Joy must align with proper principles to accord with heavenly will and human hearts. Using joy to guide people makes them forget their toil; facing hardship with joy makes them forget death. Noble persons should discuss and learn with friends. The initial Yang line shows harmonious joy as auspicious; the second Yang line's sincere joy dispels regret; the third Yin line's forced joy brings misfortune; the fourth Yang line maintains caution amid joy—though minor ailments may occur, there will be celebration; the fifth Yang line warns that trusting petty people invites danger.
In summary, this scripture teaches us to maintain sincere humility while upholding principles and decisiveness. One must not preserve oneself through excessive flattery, lest everything be ultimately lost. Joy must accord with proper principles to bring true auspiciousness.
This passage elucidates the profound meaning of the Dui (Joy) hexagram from the Book of Changes (Yijing), which symbolizes harmony and delight. Dui represents joy—when a ruler educates the people through Dao (the Way) and De (Virtue), the populace naturally responds with sincerity, fostering mutual affection and creating harmony between superiors and subordinates, leading to prosperity. However, true joy must stem from selflessness and righteousness, free from personal desires, to maintain the correct path.
The Dui hexagram embodies the balance of Yin and Yang, where yielding Yin harmoniously follows the joyful principle of firm Yang. True governance does not indulge people in selfish pleasures but is rooted in strength and integrity—gentle in appearance yet filled with the Taiji (Supreme Ultimate) Qi (vital energy) within, remaining impartial and sincere to uphold the Dao. By adhering to the Dao, Heaven and humanity coexist harmoniously, aligning with cosmic principles without defiance and resonating with human hearts without deviation. When guiding the people, they willingly labor; when leading them through hardship, they sacrifice for righteousness without hesitation. Without coercion, people naturally gather; without exhortation, they spontaneously strive. This is the highest manifestation of transformative influence, akin to the subtle yet profound power of "silent transformation and preserved spirit" (guò huà cún shén).
The hexagram's image depicts two lakes connected, symbolizing how Dao, De, and righteousness permeate hearts like water. A noble person emulates this gentle, nourishing virtue—otherwise, how can true inner joy arise? Thus, one should gather like-minded friends for shared study, as solitary learning without exchange leads to narrow perspectives. Through mutual refinement and daily interaction, the boundless delight of intellectual discourse naturally emerges. Yet the Dui hexagram emphasizes mutual enrichment without indulgence, as excessive joy leads to deviance.
Each line reveals distinct circumstances:
- The first line is most auspicious, isolated from Yin lines and thus untainted by petty influences.
- The second line, near a superior Yin line, faces danger and doubt; only utmost sincerity can avert regret.
- The third line lacks genuine virtue, relying on flattery to court favor, inviting disgrace and misfortune.
- The fourth line, adjacent to the third’s deceit, appears unsettled, but resolute integrity can transform it into the joy of ruler-minister harmony.
- The fifth line, occupying the sovereign position but close to Yin, risks corruption by petty forces; only centered righteousness can neutralize this threat.
- The top line, yielding Yin at joy’s extremity, overindulges in clever pleasing tactics, abandoning the path of luminous integrity.
People are lost in self-obsession without realizing it. Fortunately, the Five Precepts (Daoist ethical guidelines) can restrain them from being consumed by desires. Though flattering behaviors may appear obvious on the surface, they ultimately conceal darkness and never truly reveal illumination. Alas, the temptation to please others is most treacherous.
Therefore, when surrounded by wickedness and sycophancy, one should respond with balanced integrity—neither lured by crooked paths nor complicit in dubious affairs. Only thus can one maintain righteousness and attain joy aligned with the Dao. Some say the Dui trigram (one of the Eight Trigrams/Bagua) represents speech—joy arises inwardly and manifests through words, which inherently express delight. Yet observing the six line statements (yao) of the hexagrams, all advocate conciseness, discouraging excessive speech. This precisely aims to restrain overflowing joy. Moderating delight and discerning wickedness resembles building dikes beside marshes to prevent uncontrolled flooding—such is the sage's profound intent.
(Hexagram Huan: Dispersion, formed by Kan below and Xun above)
The Huan hexagram signifies prosperity. When the king approaches the ancestral temple, it favors crossing great rivers and persevering in righteousness. The Tuan Commentary explains: Huan's prosperity lies in the unceasing flow of yang energy, while yin occupies its proper position harmonizing with what's above. The king approaching the temple indicates his central role; crossing rivers succeeds by "riding wood" (Xun symbolizes wood).
The Xiang Commentary states: Wind moving over water forms Huan's image—thus ancient kings worshipped Heaven and established temples.
First line (yin): Using strong horses for rescue brings good fortune—by aligning with the times.
Second line (yang): In dispersion, hastening to rest brings vanished regret—fulfilling one's aspiration.
Third line (yin): Dispersing oneself brings no regret—for the mind looks outward.
Fourth line (yin): Dispersing the crowd brings great fortune; hills emerging amid dispersion surpass ordinary imagination—through radiant correctness.
Fifth line (yang): Issuing great decrees like sweat, dispersing the king's residence (restructuring authority) incurs no blame—by occupying the proper position.
Top line (yang): Dispersion involving bloodshed—distancing danger averts calamity.
The Huan hexagram reflects perilous times when people's hearts scatter. Here, the king must concentrate spirit, communicate virtue with deities through sacrifice, and employ talent to traverse dangers—reuniting the people and restoring peace to the world. Though dispersed, prosperity ultimately returns. This hexagram takes Kan as its substance (essence) and Xun as its function (manifestation), embodying yin-yang harmony. Why does dispersion regain prosperity? Because strong ministers possess unexhausted capacity to rescue dispersion, while gentle ministers hold unfailing virtue to reunite it: strength supplemented by gentleness avoids internal hardship; gentleness supplemented by strength prevents extreme actions.
This passage elucidates the principles for reuniting a fragmented society when the world is in disarray—when hearts are scattered and social order collapses. During such times of dissolution, the ancestral spiritual lineage is severed, and the people sink into profound suffering. Three essential approaches are required: first, one must connect with the divine through utmost sincerity (the integrity of Zhongfu); second, genuine compassion must unite the populace; and third, one must possess the capability to turn the tide.
Just as the hexagram image "wind over water" depicts a state of dispersal, the ancient kings understood that people often chase trivialities while forgetting the root. Thus, the key to governing fragmentation lies in establishing foundations—through rituals honoring the Heavenly Sovereign and ancestral temples, the people learn to revere what is fundamental. When this reverence reaches its zenith, respect for the ruler naturally follows. By promoting the virtues of humaneness and filial piety, hearts are gathered, preventing the world from further disintegration.
The root of fragmentation lies in negligence and laxity. Specific methods include: at the initial stage (the first line of the hexagram), acting swiftly like a horse spurred to gallop; at the second line, maintaining vigilance as if fleeing danger—neither slackening nor succumbing to partiality. When the consciousness of governing the state wanes, the depth of self-cultivation grows; the more thoroughly selfish desires are restrained, the more urgent the heart to aid the world becomes. The third line requires eliminating selfishness, while the fourth line dissolves cliques—seemingly dispersing, yet actually uniting on a grander scale. Hence the saying, "In dispersion, there is a mountain" (Huan You Qiu), a realm beyond ordinary comprehension. Extraordinary actions like refuting heresies and disbanding factions demand unfathomable wisdom and trustworthy capability—this is not achievable through mundane reasoning.
As for issuing decrees, they must embody the kingly Dao. The fragmentation of the world stems from hearts growing distant, and this distance arises when wealth accumulates at the top without benefiting the people. Thus, the ruler should remain open and receptive, ensuring tangible benefits reach the populace ("dispersion at the king's abode brings no blame"). Plans should be profound and inscrutable, while commands must be clear and unmistakable—only then can the people's hearts be awed. However, if dissolution is incomplete or decrees lack thoroughness, hidden dangers persist, and calamities will resurface. Only by eradicating these dangers entirely and maintaining vigilance can one dwell safely beyond harm, ultimately accomplishing the great task of reuniting a fragmented world.
Who but those whose virtue can move ancestral spirits and whose ability can ford perilous rivers is capable of this? This hexagram precisely illustrates how to harness adversity to achieve greatness.
This passage expounds the principle of the "Hexagram of Moderation" (Jie Gua) from the Book of Changes. "Moderation" signifies measured restraint, like water (represented by the Kan trigram) above a marsh (represented by the Dui trigram), where water levels must be regulated to prevent flooding.
The hexagram's imagery shows Dui (joy) below and Kan (danger) above, warning people to understand restraint. The hexagram statement declares: "Moderation brings success, but excessive restraint is unwise." Just as heaven and earth operate through the natural rhythm of four seasons, a country must establish regulations to avoid wasting resources or harming its people.
The line statements illustrate the principle of moderation through six stages:
The initial nine line states "no blame in not leaving the courtyard," showing prudent timing; the second nine warns "misfortune in not leaving the gate," indicating missed opportunities; the third six line cautions "those who don't moderate will lament"; the fourth six promises "success through contented moderation"; the fifth nine declares "sweet moderation brings supreme fortune"; while the top six line warns "bitter moderation brings misfortune."
The sages teach us to uphold the Middle Way in conduct. In material enjoyment, it's better to be frugal than extravagant, yet one shouldn't be so miserly as to violate human nature. Just as marshes require water regulation, life demands balance between indulgence and stinginess. When enjoying wealth and power (Dui's joy), we must remain vigilant against danger (Kan), using strength to restrain desires and flexibility to moderate expenditures. Only by achieving this "sweet moderation"—neither excessive indulgence nor extreme restraint—can we attain natural harmony and auspicious outcomes.
This passage elucidates the principle of "moderation" (节制). Moderation should align with human nature and common sense, yet maintain appropriate limits. When restraint becomes excessive to the point of causing suffering, it deviates from the Middle Way (中庸之道). Those who truly understand moderation must first implement it with a peaceful mindset, thereby establishing proper norms for the people's livelihood and harmonizing social conditions.
The text employs the metaphor of "swamp waters ever rising" (泽上益水) to illustrate the dangers of excessive restraint. True moderation lies in upholding the Middle Path: maintaining fundamental boundaries without going to extremes, regulating behavior while remaining aligned with proper rites (礼). The noble person (君子) should lead by example, adhering to established systems while enabling the people to abide by their proper roles.
Specifically: At the initial stage (初爻), maintaining one's fundamental position brings good fortune; at the second stage (二爻), excessive timidity invites misfortune; at the third stage (阴居阳位), failing to keep to one's proper place leads to self-inflicted consequences; at the fourth stage (臣子之位), stability and compliance are paramount; at the fifth stage (君主之位), gentle moderation is most valued. The ideal state manifests when upright virtue (中正之德) moderates the world, allowing all people to benefit from balanced restraint.
At the highest stage (上爻), when moderation violates human nature—even with pure intentions—misfortune follows. The sages particularly warn against temperamental extremes that lead to deviation. Through the transformations of the six stages (六爻), the text demonstrates that moderation's essence lies in equilibrium—both excess and deficiency create problems.
This passage from Yi Shuo primarily explains the principle of the Zhongfu hexagram (symbolizing inner sincerity). When sincerity reaches its utmost depth, even the most obtuse creatures can be transformed—hence the hexagram statement that even pigs and fish (representing ignorant beings) receive auspiciousness. Such profound sincerity can overcome hardships and dangers, like crossing a great river in a hollowed-out wooden boat.
The hexagram's structure consists of Dui (Lake) below and Xun (Wind) above, symbolizing how a noble person's integrity, like wind sweeping over water, permeates everywhere. Emulating this hexagram, the noble person carefully adjudicates legal cases and delays executions. The line statements illustrate the path of sincerity through six stages:
The initial Yang line (Nine at the First) states that maintaining focus brings auspiciousness, while distraction leads to unrest. The second Yang line (Nine at the Second) uses the metaphor of a crane's call and its response to depict like-minded individuals resonating with one another. The third Yin line (Six at the Third) suggests that encountering opposition may lead to either advance or retreat, indicating instability due to improper positioning. The fourth Yin line (Six at the Fourth) says that losing a horse when nearing the full moon is inconsequential, emphasizing the need to proactively sever improper ties. The fifth Yang line (Nine at the Fifth) declares that sincere mutual treatment brings no blame, as the position is correct. The top Yang line (Nine at the Top) warns that empty fame reaching the heavens will ultimately invite misfortune.
The core teaching is this: Genuine sincerity arises from within, embracing all things like the void yet clinging to nothing. When rulers treat subordinates with humility and sincerity, and ministers serve with gentle devotion, their mutual sincerity can transform all lands. Such profound sincerity knows no distinction between the hidden and the manifest—it moves all things, hence the auspiciousness of "sincerity reaching pigs and fish." Yet one must remain vigilant: petty sincerity or selfish intentions will never attain this state.
This passage elucidates the profound principles of the Zhongfu hexagram (from the Yijing, symbolizing sincerity and trust). Just as a hollow boat floats upon water, only when the human mind maintains emptiness and tranquility can one navigate life with ease. A noble person who comprehends this truth will adjudicate legal cases with utmost care, striving to minimize capital punishment—for penal measures are methods of last resort. If the slightest doubt remains during judgment, the condemned will harbor resentment, thereby violating the Dao of sincerity.
The text emphasizes that legal cases must be meticulously examined to seek grounds for leniency; even for those sentenced to death, every effort should be made to find avenues for reprieve, maintaining compassionate intent throughout. Like the mutual resonance between the first and fourth lines—symbolizing unwavering sincerity—or the second and fifth lines that, despite intervening obstacles, still connect through their adherence to the Middle Way: this mirrors how a crane's call draws response from its young, a pure interaction of De (Virtue) rather than self-interest.
Conversely, the third line lacks constancy. Neither understanding principles nor properly aligned with the stubborn fourth line, it results in erratic speech and action. The fourth line inherently possesses virtue, but calculating gains and losses would forfeit its advantage; only by severing personal ties and wholeheartedly assisting the fifth line can it avoid fault. The fifth line represents the sovereign—their sincerity must first move nearby ministers before transforming the populace, creating a cohesive governance structure.
The topmost ninth line resides at the zenith of the Xun hexagram (symbolizing humility), mutable as the wind. This teaches us: when things reach their extreme, transformation occurs; only through transformation can harmony be achieved. Such is the eternal law between heaven and earth.
This passage from Yi Shuo primarily explains the meaning of the "Minor Surpassing" (Xiaoguo) hexagram in the Book of Changes (Yijing). The Xiaoguo hexagram (composed of Gen below and Zhen above, symbolizing thunder over a mountain) discusses how to conduct oneself in situations where Yin dominates and Yang is weak.
The hexagram imagery suggests that this is a time suitable for small actions rather than major undertakings, much like the lingering call of a flying bird—it is inauspicious to soar upward but favorable to descend. This is because the Yin (soft) energy is excessive (with four Yin lines on the outside and two Yang lines on the inside). Although Yin holds the advantage, the two Yang lines form a protective barrier at the top and bottom. Attempting to force progress at this time would be as unrealistic as a small bird trying to reach the heavens with its faint cry.
The hexagram text emphasizes that "sincerity" (孚, fu)—genuine mutual resonance—is more important than mere adherence to promises. Only when those above and below respond sincerely, free from inner doubts, can true trust be established. Stubbornly clinging to one's views without flexibility risks losing this essential quality of sincere connection.
The specific line interpretations offer further guidance:
- The first Yin line (初六) warns that forcing a bird to fly high invites danger.
- The second Yin line (六二) suggests that missing an encounter with the grandfather but meeting the grandmother, or failing to see the ruler but encountering a minister, is without fault.
- The third Yang line (九三) cautions that without proper precautions, harm may follow.
- The fourth Yang line (九四) advises seizing opportunities with restraint, avoiding excess.
- The fifth Yin line (六五) depicts thick clouds gathering without rain.
- The top Yin line (上六) warns of surpassing proper limits, likening it to a bird flying into a net—a dire omen.
Overall, the hexagram teaches us: when strength is insufficient, one must act with heightened reverence, mourn with deeper sorrow, and practice greater frugality. Success lies in discerning the circumstances—when Yin is overly dominant, moderation is crucial. Overreaching invites misfortune.
This passage elucidates the wisdom of the Minor Excess hexagram (xiaoguo) from the Classic of Changes (Yijing). When societal problems arise, petty individuals become blinded by selfishness and lose sight of the greater picture, while noble persons find their transformative potential temporarily constrained. In such circumstances, forcing major reforms would only exacerbate conflicts—the correct approach lies in implementing gentle adjustments.
The hexagram's structure shows Mountain (Gen) below and Thunder (Zhen) above, symbolizing Yang Qi being slightly subdued by Yin Qi. In this situation, one should remember: make minor corrections rather than sweeping changes; prefer discreet handling over overt displays. Like letting birdsong fade naturally without pursuit, allowing matters to resolve themselves often dissolves tensions. This embodies the wisdom for navigating "minor excess" scenarios.
Practically speaking: noble persons should demonstrate more humility than usual, express deeper grief during mourning rites, and maintain greater frugality in daily life. These seemingly "excessive" behaviors actually serve to rectify unhealthy tendencies. Yet moderation remains crucial—only implement small-scale adjustments rather than attempting to transform the entire world at once.
In the hexagram's lines, both the first and top positions are Yin lines (representing petty individuals). If such people act rashly—like birds fluttering wildly—they invite misfortune. The noble person understands the importance of assessing circumstances: practicing discretion when required and resolving minor issues appropriately leads to auspicious outcomes.
The "Minor Exceeding" hexagram in the Book of Changes (Yijing) depicts a situation where yin energy prevails while yang declines. Just as a bird flying too high invites danger, when petty individuals gain excessive power, calamity inevitably follows—both outcomes arising from overreaching.
The second line, occupying the central position and adjacent to the third, can restrain excessive tendencies. The fifth line, holding the honored position and neighboring the fourth, governs immoderate phenomena. "Passing the ancestor to meet the ancestress" refers to positional relationships: the "ancestor" denotes the initial first line, while the "ancestress" represents the internal second line—surpassing the first to reach the second's position.
"Not reaching the ruler but encountering the minister" describes avoiding correspondence with the fifth line while remaining content in a subordinate role. Internally, this is called "exceeding"; externally, it is deemed "falling short"—a minor failing of ministers. Like dense clouds withholding rain, yin energy accumulates above yet fails to distribute blessings widely, only obtaining trivial gains from nearby caves while unable to quell widespread chaos—this constitutes a gentleman's minor failing.
The third and fourth lines are both yang, yet the third is excessively rigid while the fourth remains comparatively gentle. If the third cannot restrain yin energy, caution is required; if the fourth cannot transcend yang influence, vigilance becomes necessary. When yang grows overly rigid and yin ascends, disaster becomes unpredictable; when yang remains gentle while yin flourishes, calamity may still be averted.
For gentlemen dealing with petty individuals, prevention is difficult, but coexistence proves even harder. Petty men, when advancing, will suppress rivals; when entrenched, they grow suspicious of dissent. Thus, even while upholding righteousness, gentlemen must assess circumstances flexibly, avoiding inflexibility. These are all expedient measures adopted out of necessity.
During times of minor exceeding, gentlemen face hardship, yet those defying cosmic principles ultimately gain no advantage. Both the initial and top lines warn: soaring too high leaves no perch; what seems clever becomes self-destruction. Hence the first line states "the flying bird brings misfortune," while the top declares "the flying bird meets calamity." The sage's repeated admonitions simultaneously fortify gentlemen's defenses and lament petty men's schemes. Therefore, in such times, gentlemen must refrain from reckless action, practicing instead humility and restraint.
This passage discusses the Ji Ji hexagram (Fire below Water, symbolizing "After Completion") from the Yi Jing (Book of Changes). It reveals that when things reach a state of perfection, we must be especially vigilant against the seeds of decline.
The Ji Ji hexagram represents accomplished affairs, bringing modest success and favoring the maintenance of correct principles. While auspicious at the outset, it ultimately leads to disorder. Like water positioned above fire—seemingly balanced—the noble person must anticipate potential dangers and take preventive measures.
Each of the six lines (yao) carries its warning:
- The first yang line (Initial Nine) advises pulling the chariot wheel and wetting the tail (symbolizing cautious action) to avoid mistakes
- The second yin line (Six Two) suggests a woman needn't anxiously search for lost ornaments, as they will return in seven days (demonstrating how upholding the Middle Way brings natural rewards)
- The third yang line (Nine Three) recounts how Emperor Gaozong took three years to conquer the Guifang tribes, warning against entrusting important matters to petty people
- The fourth yin line (Six Four) recommends maintaining vigilance all day, like preparing tattered clothes against the cold (illustrating preparing for danger in times of safety)
- The fifth yang line (Nine Five) compares sacrifices between eastern and western neighbors, showing how timely simplicity brings greater blessings than extravagance
- The top yin line (Six Above) warns of the peril of soaking one's head (symbolizing excess)
The combination of Kan (Water) and Li (Fire) forms Ji Ji, mirroring how heaven and earth interact harmoniously. Although all six lines show proper correspondence between firm (yang) and yielding (yin) energies in their correct positions, the sages worried that reaching the pinnacle of success inevitably leads to decline. The hexagram statement mentions "ending in disorder," while the line texts contain warnings like "danger," all admonishing people to prevent calamity during peaceful times.
The success (heng) of Ji Ji refers to fleeting prosperity at the turning point before decline, when minor matters may still proceed smoothly. The "benefit in steadfastness" (li zhen) arises because firm and yielding energies each occupy their proper positions—the strong remain vigorous without agitation, the gentle stay compliant without slackness. Only through this balanced interaction of principle and circumstance can completion be achieved. King Wen used "auspicious beginning, chaotic ending" to reveal the pattern of all phenomena, while Confucius expressed concern that people might consequently become negligent.
(Note: Ji Ji is the 63rd hexagram in the Yi Jing, representing the state of accomplished affairs; "Kan-Li" refers to the Water and Fire trigrams among the Eight Trigrams; "firm and yielding" denote yin and yang qualities; "yao" are the constituent lines of a hexagram)
This passage expounds on the philosophical insights from the "Jiji Hexagram" (symbolizing accomplished affairs) in the Book of Changes (Yijing). The core teaching reveals that when things reach a state of perfection, complacency and cessation of effort will inevitably lead to decline from prosperity.
The text employs the metaphor of "fire and water interacting" (with the Li trigram of fire below and the Kan trigram of water above) to illustrate harmonious cooperation, much like using fire to cook rice. However, without vigilance, excessive fire may evaporate the water, while too much water can extinguish the flames—turning good fortune into misfortune. Thus, the noble person (junzi) must remain alert in times of peace, anticipating potential crises even during smooth progress.
A crucial emphasis is placed on true prevention: it is not about solving problems after they arise, but about guarding against stagnation caused by contentment with the status quo. The hexagram imagery shows initial brightness (Li trigram at the front) potentially culminating in darkness (Kan trigram at the rear), akin to the peril of a drunkard soaking his head—a symbol of reckless danger.
The passage analyzes the warnings in each line:
The first line resembles cautiously dragging a cartwheel across a river—slow but prudent;
The second line, though capable, sits between two yang lines and faces distractions, requiring patience for the right moment;
The third line demonstrates excessive haste for quick results;
The fourth line displays gentle caution;
The fifth line, occupying the honored position, subtly conveys the highest form of warning by emphasizing blessings rather than explicit admonitions.
The overarching message clarifies that even in favorable circumstances, every stage demands vigilance. Only through balanced firmness and flexibility can sustained success be achieved.
This passage elucidates principles of governance and personal conduct. The most essential quality is not talent, but the grave mistake of employing petty individuals. If the ruler (the "ninth five" supreme position) can uphold the correct Dao (the Way) and maintain harmonious balance, they become an enlightened sovereign capable of saving the world. Yet while a good beginning is easy, a good ending is difficult—thus one must take warning from the sincerity of sacrificial rituals.
Action should commence in the east, yet harvest comes from the west. When first establishing systems, regulations tend toward complexity—at such times, simplicity should be emphasized, maintaining tranquility so all under heaven may enjoy peaceful blessings. Just as the eastern neighbor's elaborate ox sacrifice proves less auspicious than the western neighbor's simple offering, timing must be precisely right without excessive striving.
The phrase "great fortune arrives" signifies the departure of the old and the arrival of the new. If one cannot maintain fullness, the future will be lost. Order and chaos follow no fixed pattern—their pivot lies in human hearts. Beginning with balanced moderation brings good governance; ending with slackened resolve brings chaos. The chaos stems not from the conclusion itself, but from the mentality of termination. How can the key to order and chaos be attributed to heavenly mandate while indulging in personal negligence?
The Yi Jing's (Book of Changes) principle of mutual complementarity between firm and yielding lines constitutes the essential mechanism governing the alternation of order and chaos.
The Weiji hexagram (Water below, Fire above) symbolizes unfinished affairs. When a small fox's tail gets wet while crossing the river, it indicates unfavorable circumstances. The hexagram image shows fire above water—the noble person should carefully discern phenomena and abide by their proper station.
The initial six line suggests a wet tail brings trouble because one fails to know when to stop. The second nine line describes pulling cart wheels as auspicious, for it maintains centrality in upright action. The third six line warns that advancing prematurely during incompletion brings danger, though it suits crossing great rivers. The fourth nine line states upholding correctness dispels regret, like receiving honors after three years campaigning against northern tribes. The fifth six line describes the noble person's radiance bringing good fortune. The top nine line shows excessive drinking wets the head through lack of restraint.
Though Weiji inverts Yin-Yang positions, it contains the cyclical principle of heaven and earth. The hexagram's structure—Li (Fire) above, Kan (Water) below—with fire's nature ascending and water's descending, their failure to intersect perfectly symbolizes the state of unfinished affairs.
This passage elucidates the profound meaning of the "Weiji Hexagram" (Unfinished) from the Book of Changes. The Weiji Hexagram symbolizes incomplete affairs, with its image depicting fire above water (the Li trigram above, the Kan trigram below). Fire's nature is to rise while water's tendency is to descend—their opposing directions prevent harmonious interaction.
Examining the yao positions, the yin line at the top represents the ruler, while the yang line at the bottom signifies the minister. The misalignment of their firm and yielding positions creates a disconnect in communication between superior and subordinate, hence the name "Unfinished." Yet yin and yang still resonate with each other: yang occupying a yin position avoids excessive rigidity, while yin in a yang position prevents undue weakness. Though seemingly divergent, they ultimately converge; though apparently misaligned, they return to the proper path. Thus, it is said that "Unfinished brings success." This success stems from both heavenly will and human prudence. The Dao of Heaven does not condemn one to perpetual hardship, yet escaping adversity still requires human effort.
The Weiji Hexagram takes Li as its substance and Kan as its function, embodying the principle of yin-yang resonance. Despite its unfinished state, success is possible because the fifth yao, yielding yet balanced, fulfills human duties in harmony with heavenly timing, avoiding reckless advance. The metaphor of "a small fox nearly crossing the river" illustrates the precarious moment when danger persists but has not yet been fully overcome. Just as the Book of Changes uses the "overreaching dragon" in the Qian Hexagram to warn against excessive yang energy, it employs the "small fox" here to caution against yin's tendency toward hesitation. When yin responds to yang, the greatest peril lies in insufficient resolve—hence the warning of the fox wetting its tail while crossing.
The noble person who comprehends this hexagram must carefully discern phenomena and remain steadfast in their proper place. By observing differences to seek common ground, they understand that water and fire, though opposing, can also nourish each other; yin and yang, though contrary, can still resonate. Among the six yao, the third and fourth are most critical: the third emerges from Kan's peril to meet Li's clarity, favorable for crossing treacherous waters; the fourth, positioned in Li's brightness yet facing Kan's danger, is suited for decisive action and achieving merit. Though the third yao's position is irregular, its yang nature and resonance with other yang lines demand responsibility—one must courageously confront difficulties rather than evade them.
This passage from Yi Shuo (Discourse on the Changes) primarily elucidates the principles for navigating adversity. When facing unfavorable circumstances (as symbolized by the Weiji hexagram, "Before Completion"), reckless action invites danger. However, by maintaining steadfast resolve, progressing step by step, and coordinating efforts between superiors and subordinates, one can transform crisis into stability.
The text analyzes each line (yao) of the Weiji hexagram: The fourth line, though improperly positioned, possesses capability. If it adheres quietly to the correct path and acts decisively, it can avoid regret and achieve merit. Both the third and fourth lines occupy positions requiring the overcoming of obstacles, while the first and second lines resemble a fox's tail or cartwheel submerged in water—either lacking sufficient strength or passively evading responsibility, neither can accomplish anything substantial. The fifth line, centered and upright, embodies the luminous virtue (De) of a noble person, capable of handling affairs wisely without ostentation. The topmost ninth line, excessively rigid and aggressive, risks inviting calamity; it would fare better by emulating the composure of one contentedly drinking wine while awaiting the proper moment.
The passage particularly emphasizes that true wisdom—exemplified by historical figures like Zhuge Liang (styled Kongming) and Zhang Liang (styled Zifang)—lies in cultivating virtue (De) during adversity, harmonizing with the timing of heaven (tian shi), neither forcing outcomes nor indulging in passivity. Indulging in pleasure like Liu Ling or Ruan Ji of the Seven Sages of the Bamboo Grove proves not only futile but harmful. The text concludes by highlighting how the Yijing (Book of Changes) ends with the Weiji hexagram, illustrating the endless flux of worldly affairs and the perpetual interplay between celestial patterns (tian dao) and human affairs (ren shi) that achieves equilibrium.
(Note: Weiji, the 64th hexagram of the Yijing, symbolizes a state of incompletion; yao refers to the six component lines of a hexagram, counted from bottom to top. Historical figures mentioned—Zhuge Liang (Kongming) and Zhang Liang (Zifang)—are paragons of discerning situational dynamics.)
All things in the world gather according to their kind, and from this arise fortune and misfortune. The heavens manifest the images of sun, moon and stars; the earth displays the forms of mountains, rivers and vegetation—thus the patterns of transformation between heaven and earth are revealed.
Yin and Yang, hardness and softness, rub against and resonate with each other, while the Eight Trigrams (Qian/Kun/Zhen/Xun/Kan/Li/Gen/Dui) mutually stimulate and propel one another. Thunder energizes the growth of all things, while wind and rain nourish the earth's vitality. The alternating movements of sun and moon create the cycle of cold and heat. The Dao of Qian (symbolizing heaven and Yang) forms the male, while the Dao of Kun (symbolizing earth and Yin) forms the female. Qian initiates all things, while Kun brings them to completion.
The principle of Qian is simple and comprehensible; the function of Kun is straightforward and practical. Simplicity makes things easy to understand, and straightforwardness makes them easy to follow. What is easily understood invites closeness; what is easily followed leads to accomplishment. What invites closeness can endure long, and what leads to accomplishment can expand greatly. Endurance is the virtue of the worthy; expansion is their enterprise. Understanding this principle of simplicity means grasping the patterns of the world; grasping these patterns allows one to find one's proper place between heaven and earth.
The term "rubbing" refers to observing the process of creation before the Eight Trigrams were formed; "stimulating" describes how the Trigrams contain the patterns of transformation after their formation. "Rubbing" is the mutual resonance of Yin and Yang; "stimulating" is the progression of change. It is precisely this friction and resonance between Yin and Yang that makes the operation and transformation of the Eight Trigrams ceaseless—difficult to say which comes first. For instance, Li represents the sun while Kan represents the moon: their movements manifest the interaction of Qian and Kun, which is the resonance and progression of Yin and Yang. Thus the sun and moon's movements create the alternation of cold and heat: when the sun reaches the Ox constellation (water element, distant from humans hence cold), it brings cold; when it reaches the Well constellation (fire element, close to humans hence warm), it brings heat. The Taixuan Jing states: When the sun moves south, all things wither; when it moves north, all things grow. At summer solstice when the sun is at the southern Well constellation, all things tend toward decay; at winter solstice when it's at the northern Ox constellation, all things begin to sprout. Within death lies birth; within growth lurks decay—this is the principle of Yin-Yang resonance and progression.
(Chapter 1 Content)
The sages created the Eight Trigrams to observe celestial and terrestrial phenomena, attaching hexagram statements to explain fortune and misfortune. The mutual progression of Yang hardness and Yin softness produces transformation. Therefore, fortune and misfortune symbolize gain and loss; regret and remorse symbolize worry and trouble; transformation symbolizes advance and retreat; hardness and softness symbolize day and night. The changes in the six lines manifest the patterns of the Three Ultimates (heaven, earth and humanity). Thus what the noble person relies upon for peaceful dwelling and joyful conduct is the order revealed in the Yi Jing; what they delight in contemplating are the profound meanings within the hexagram statements. Therefore in daily life, the noble person...
The Book of Changes (Yijing) teaches us: When observing the hexagrams, one must carefully contemplate the meanings of their judgments; when taking action, observe the transformations and study the divination results. This way, one receives divine protection and achieves smooth progress in all endeavors.
Chapter Two explains: The Tuan (hexagram statements) interpret the symbolic meanings, while the Yao (line statements) explain the transformations. Auspicious and inauspicious signs indicate gain and loss; regret and remorse signify minor faults; "no blame" results from skillful rectification of errors. Thus, noble and humble positions manifest in the line placements, great and small in the hexagram images, and fortune or misfortune in the judgments. Concern over regret and remorse lies in attention to detail, while avoiding misfortune depends on timely repentance. Hexagrams differ in magnitude, judgments vary in difficulty—each phrase points to specific meanings.
Chapter Three states: The Book of Changes aligns with the patterns of Heaven and Earth, thus encompassing the Dao of the cosmos. Looking up to observe celestial patterns and looking down to examine earthly principles, one comprehends the interplay of darkness and light. Tracing origins and investigating endings reveals the discourse on life and death. When essence (Jing) and vital energy (Qi) condense, they form physical matter; wandering souls produce transformations—thus we understand the conditions of spiritual beings. Aligning with Heaven and Earth ensures no violation of natural laws; comprehending all things while applying the Dao to aid the world prevents errors. Acting flexibly without indulgence, rejoicing in Heaven and knowing destiny—thus one remains free from worry. Being content with one's station and cultivating kindness enables universal love. Embracing cosmic transformations without overstepping boundaries, perfecting all things without omission, mastering the Dao of day and night—this constitutes true wisdom. Therefore, the divine has no fixed method, nor does the Book of Changes possess rigid forms.
The Book of Changes speaks not of "Yin-Yang" but of "Yin preceding Yang," manifesting the principle of ceaseless vitality. It speaks not of "life and death" but of "death preceding life," showing death as life's continuation. It speaks not of "divine spirits" but of "spirits and ghosts," revealing the interconnection between subtlety and manifestation. It speaks not of "opening and closing" but of "closing and opening," demonstrating latent movement within stillness. Thus the Book of Changes functions by: completely encompassing the Dao of Heaven-Earth and Yin-Yang without omission, while distinctly differentiating Yin-Yang without confusion. Truly, its cyclical beginning and ending perfectly correspond with cosmic patterns.
When Yin's essence combines with Yang's Qi, life emerges; when Yin's form unites with Yang's spirit (Shen), the physical body takes shape—this is called "essence and vital energy condensing into matter." The hun (ethereal soul) represents the heart's spiritual aspect. Physical objects possess form and substance—their existence is typically judged by aggregation and dispersion; the spiritual dimension...
The Yishuo scripture primarily explores the transformations of life and death, the relationship between form and spirit, and the principles of Yin-Yang. The text reveals that the essence of birth, death, gathering, and dispersion transcends sensory perception—much like the Book of Songs describes King Wen's spirit wandering beside the Heavenly Emperor after death. The ancient saying "suddenly becoming human, then transforming into other things" refers precisely to this metamorphosis.
The root of human life and death lies in the coming and going of thoughts and the arising and ceasing of consciousness. At death, the spirit (Shen) can move and transform freely. This transformation is no longer bound to physical form but manifests through Qi (the fundamental energy constituting all things in Daoist thought), allowing the spirit to come and go, separate and unite at will. In life, form and spirit are united and indistinguishable, but after death, the departing spirit may retain awareness without form (Yang) or retain form without awareness (Yin). The separation of form and spirit manifests as the ethereal Hun-soul (Yang Qi) ascending and the corporeal Po-soul (Yin Qi) descending. Understanding that Yin and Yang transform into each other yet never truly separate reveals that what ascends is the refined Qi (forming spiritual life), while what descends is coarse Qi (forming physical death). Ultimately, all transformations return to the Great Void (the cosmic origin), beyond precise measurement.
All things in the universe interact through Qi's resonance: the clear and light Qi forms Heaven, while the heavy and turbid Qi forms Earth; those who cultivate purity become divine beings, while those clinging to attachments become ghosts. These are natural outcomes of selection, difficult to define absolutely. The Book of Changes speaks of "transformation" as a principle of boundless profundity.
Regarding "contentment in any circumstance and profound benevolence," sages can settle peacefully anywhere, without barriers between themselves and the myriad things, whereas ordinary people must choose suitable environments to find stability, easily generating discriminatory minds. The sage's mental state resembles still water—reflecting all things without attachment.
The final chapter elucidates the Dao of Yin-Yang: their alternation constitutes the Dao; inheriting it is goodness, and fulfilling it is innate nature. Different people comprehend the Dao from different perspectives—the benevolent see benevolence, the wise see wisdom, while common folk use it daily without awareness. Thus, noble persons who grasp it wholly are rare. The Dao manifests through benevolence and virtue (De) while remaining hidden in function, driving all things forward without the anxieties of sages. What is called the "great enterprise" is the Dao's vast containment; its "abundant virtue" is its daily renewal; "change" (Yi) is the unceasing generation of life; and "Qian" represents the celestial phenomena of creation.
This passage elucidates the fundamental principles of Yin-Yang transformation and celestial-earthly operations. Kun (representing the yin energy of earth) embodies the manifestation of heavenly Dao. Calculating ultimate numbers to foresee the future constitutes divination, comprehending transformation patterns represents the method of handling affairs, while the unfathomable state of Yin-Yang fluctuation is termed "Shen" (spirit).
The law of celestial-earthly creation ultimately manifests through Yin-Yang interaction. Yang represents movement, brightness, and formlessness; Yin signifies stillness, obscurity, and form. Yang lacks fixed form yet relies on Yin for support, while Yin requires Yang's activation to manifest function. Their union generates all things; their separation leads to universal dissolution. This transformation operates with utmost subtlety, permeating all mysteries—from the hidden realms of spirits to visible human affairs and the cosmic order of heaven and earth.
The principle of Yin-Yang manifests through cyclical alternations of movement-stillness, coming-going, opening-closing, and ascending-descending. Accumulating from subtlety to prominence before returning again to subtlety, this ceaseless process without discernible cause constitutes the "Dao." Whether in formless origins or formed existences, all result from Yin-Yang interaction. Some Confucian scholars mistakenly regard Dao as merely an ethereal state, when in truth the Dao of Yin-Yang transformation permeates everything, demonstrating that principle (li) and Qi (energy) are fundamentally inseparable.
Some erroneously equate "inheriting goodness" with Yang and "forming nature" with Yin, or interpret "inheriting goodness" as prenatal Qi and "forming nature" as postnatal substance. In reality, the Dao of Yin-Yang flows throughout creation—humans achieve heaven-earth's creative work precisely by inheriting celestial Dao. At birth, human and creature natures contain no inherent good or evil; deviations emerge later through Qi-influence, just as commoners unknowingly employ Yin-Yang principles daily—this constitutes the prenatal natural Dao.
The supreme Dao exists as seamless unity without obstruction, revealing original nature's freedom from evil—corruption stems solely from turbid Qi obscuration. When Qi becomes adulterated, nature becomes lost and Yin-Yang principles violated. Heaven-earth's De (virtue/power) remains boundless: manifesting, it generates all things displaying benevolence; concealed, it harbors the mystery of universal fulfillment. This alternating revelation and concealment creates the ceaseless transformational movement pervading creation.
The Book of Changes (Yijing) reveals the fundamental principles of Yin-Yang transformation. When Yin reaches its extreme, it gives birth to Yang, and when Yang reaches its peak, it reverts to Yin. This perpetual cycle of transformation drives the movement of heaven, earth, and all things. Thus, the principle of ceaseless transformation is the essence of the Book of Changes. The eternal and unchanging Dao manifests itself in the cyclical patterns of growth and renewal in all phenomena.
Sages comprehend the mysteries of Yin-Yang transformation by observing the patterns on tortoise shells (guilong) and listening to the harmonic tones of the phoenix's cry (lülü). There is no need for deliberate display—compassion can be seen in a chick, innate nature recognized in mountain trees, principles observed in plum blossoms, and trigrams (gua) derived from the footprints of a hare. With attentive contemplation, the patterns of growth in all things become clear; but if one clings to forceful seeking, the vital dynamism (shengji) within them becomes obscured.
What are called miraculous phenomena (shen fei tianbao, qi fei difu) are actually contained within the principles of the Book of Changes. The mysteries of the River Chart and Luo Writing (Hetu Luoshu) are hidden within the Book of Changes, while the wisdom of the Book of Changes resides in the hearts of sages. These mysteries may seem profound, yet they simply reveal the perpetual cycle of transformation in all things.
The essence of the Dao encompasses both "being" (you) and "non-being" (wu): Yin represents the tangible forms, while Yang embodies the intangible spirit. Though their manifestations differ, they are fundamentally unified. In the process of generating all things, the primordial vital energy (Qi) from the Great Void (Taixu) maintains a refined and orderly state, ultimately returning to the unified source. The function of the Dao manifests in complementary movements such as stillness and motion, ascent and descent, dryness and dampness: stillness condenses to form the earth, while motion transforms to create heaven; rising Qi generates the fire of Yang, and descending Qi coalesces into the water of Yin. Without stillness, motion loses its foundation; without motion, stillness loses its vitality.
The "Discourse on the Changes" scripture primarily elucidates the profound relationship between yin-yang transformations and the mysteries of Shen (spirit), as well as the all-encompassing nature of the Book of Changes (Yijing).
The first section discusses the relationship between yin-yang and Shen: When the two qi (vital energies) of yin and yang (the fundamental energies constituting all things) cease to depend on each other, transformation occurs. Initially subtle and nearly imperceptible, these energies gradually interact and coalesce to produce Shen (the numinous function transcending form). Qi serves as the seed of form, while form manifests from qi—these mutual transformations between emptiness and substance all represent the workings of qi. Shen emerges as the wondrous function produced by the interaction between form and qi. Shen governs form and qi, while qi constitutes the foundation of creation. By comprehending the principles of manifestation from nothingness and return to nothingness from being, one masters the profound mysteries of yin-yang transformations.
The second section expounds on the vastness and subtlety of the Yijing: The wisdom of the Changes is profound and far-reaching, capable of explaining both distant phenomena and immediate circumstances, completely encompassing all laws between heaven and earth. The Qian hexagram (representing yang strength) remains unified in stillness and becomes firm in motion; the Kun hexagram (representing yin receptivity) closes in stillness and expands in motion—thus all things are generated. The breadth of Change's principles compares to heaven and earth, its transformations parallel the four seasons, its yin-yang meanings resemble the sun and moon, while its simplicity embodies supreme virtue.
Yin and yang follow natural patterns of transformation, while the hexagrams (the symbolic system of Yijing) reveal the essence of these patterns. The Yijing can be considered the source of all written characters and principles—even the profound mysteries of heaven, earth, and spiritual beings are fully contained within its hexagrams. The sages revealed these subtle truths through creating the hexagrams and elucidated their profound meanings through commentary. Without the hexagrams, the principles of yin-yang transformation would remain invisible; without the sages' explanations, the laws of fortune and misfortune would be difficult to comprehend. Only the Yijing truly encompasses the mysteries of heaven, earth, and spiritual beings; only the sages fully understand the way of advance, retreat, survival, and demise.
This scripture primarily discusses the origins, structure, and the profound intentions behind the sages' creation of the Book of Changes (Yijing).
It begins by explaining the core philosophy of the Yijing: humans should emulate the lofty heights of heaven and learn from the humble depths of earth. Heaven and earth each have their proper positions, and within them, the transformations of Yin-Yang unfold. Preserving one's innate nature and nurturing virtuous thoughts are the gateway to the Dao (the Way) and righteousness.
Next, it introduces the "Ten Wings" (ten commentaries traditionally attributed to Confucius that elucidate the Yijing), which include: the Upper and Lower Tuan Commentaries, the Upper and Lower Xiang Commentaries, the Upper and Lower Xici Commentaries, the Wenyan Commentary, the Shuogua Commentary, the Xugua Commentary, and the Zagua Commentary.
The text then recounts the historical development of the Yijing: When Fu Xi first drew the eight trigrams (Bagua), there were no written characters. In that era, people were simple and honest, using knotted ropes to record events, and the world was naturally harmonious. By the late Shang dynasty, King Wen composed the hexagram statements, embodying virtue through a sense of caution and concern. The Duke of Zhou later added the line statements, completing the system of upper and lower hexagrams. During the chaotic Spring and Autumn period, Confucius composed the Ten Wings, repeatedly expounding the profound meanings of the Yijing.
The scripture emphasizes that the sages did not create the Yijing to deliberately exhaust its mysteries, but rather out of necessity in an age of decline. Just as the trigrams were used to manifest omens when the dragon appeared in the Yellow River, and the Ten Wings were employed to clarify principles when the qilin (mythical creature) was wounded in the marsh, the sages adapted their methods to different circumstances.
Finally, it points out that the roots of Confucius's thought lie in the Yijing, while its practical application is found in the Spring and Autumn Annals. The Yijing elucidates principles, while the Spring and Autumn Annals records facts. The Son of Heaven in the Spring and Autumn Annals corresponds to the Qian (Heaven) hexagram in the Yijing, and the four seasons align with the four virtues of "yuan, heng, li, zhen" (origination, prosperity, harmony, and steadfastness). The Yijing uses these four virtues to encompass human affairs, while the Spring and Autumn Annals employs the four seasons to regulate royal laws. Regardless of time or distance, the principles of the Yijing remain universally applicable, demonstrating the depth of the sages' study of this classic.
Chapter Seven further elaborates: When the sages observed the complex phenomena of the myriad things in the world, they used hexagram images to model their forms. Observing the movements and transformations of all things, they discerned their patterns and used line statements to determine auspicious or inauspicious outcomes. Though the affairs of the world are exceedingly intricate, one must not despise them; though changes are manifold, one must not become confused. First, one must model and observe, then articulate; first, one must study and discuss, then act. Through such deliberation and practice, one may accomplish great undertakings.
The Book of Changes states: "When a crane calls in the shade of a tree, its mate responds; I have fine wine, which I will share with you." Confucius explained: When a noble person remains at home, if their words accord with the Dao, people a thousand miles away will respond—how much more so those nearby? If their words contradict the Dao, people a thousand miles away will oppose them—how much more so those nearby. Words issuing from one's mouth affect the common people; actions occurring nearby are seen from afar. Words and deeds constitute the pivotal mechanism of a noble person's conduct—once this mechanism is set in motion, it determines glory or disgrace, gain or loss. A noble's words and deeds can even move heaven and earth—how could one not be cautious?
The Tongren hexagram speaks of first wailing then laughing. Confucius explained: The noble person's way of conducting themselves involves sometimes serving in office and sometimes withdrawing, sometimes remaining silent and sometimes speaking out. When two people are of one mind, their combined strength can cut through metal; words spoken in heartfelt communion carry the fragrance of orchids. The initial six line of the Daguo hexagram states there's no fault in using white reeds as ritual padding. Confucius explained: Placing offerings directly on the ground would suffice—how could using white reeds be wrong? This represents the utmost in caution. Though white reeds are insignificant things, they can serve important purposes. Maintaining this attitude of caution in conduct ensures freedom from fault.
The Qian hexagram says the noble person who labors with humility will have good fortune. Confucius explained: To toil without boasting, to achieve without claiming merit—this is the most profound De (Virtue). When speaking of accomplishments, maintain humility; let your virtue be expansive and your courtesy reverent. Humility means preserving one's position through constant respect. The top nine line of the Qian hexagram warns that the dragon flying too high will have cause for regret. Confucius explained: To be honored yet lack real authority, to occupy high position yet lose the people's hearts, with worthy men relegated to inferior positions without support—such conduct inevitably brings regret.
The initial nine line of the Jie hexagram states there's no calamity in not leaving one's gate. Confucius explained: Disorder often arises through words as its stepping stones. When rulers aren't cautious, they lose ministers; when ministers aren't cautious, they lose their lives; when important affairs aren't handled cautiously, they fail. Therefore the noble person maintains careful secrecy and avoids rash speech. Confucius further remarked: Did the authors of the Book of Changes understand the thief's mentality well? The Xie hexagram says carrying burdens while riding invites robbers. Bearing loads is the labor of petty men; riding in carriages is the privilege of noble men. When petty men enjoy noble privileges, robbers think to take them; when superiors are negligent and subordinates oppressive, robbers think to attack. Careless storage invites theft; excessive adornment invites lust. The Book of Changes states "carrying burdens while riding invites robbers"—this is bringing misfortune upon oneself.
Though the affairs of the world may seem obscure and unpredictable, through divination by hexagrams, nothing fails to manifest the patterns of Yin-Yang transformation, containing principles of comprehensive understanding. What appear as strange openings and closings of phenomena all follow fundamental laws. If one can extend these principles through investigation...
This chapter of the Yi Shuo (Discourse on the Changes) explains the relationship between the numbers of Heaven and Earth, the transformations of Yin-Yang, and the generation of all things. Heaven and Earth each have five fundamental numbers: the heavenly numbers (Yang numbers) are 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9, which sum to 25; the earthly numbers (Yin numbers) are 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10, which sum to 30. The total of Heaven and Earth is 55, and through the permutations and combinations of these numbers, one can deduce matters as unfathomable as the workings of spirits and deities.
In divination, 50 yarrow stalks are used (the Great Expansion Number), though in practice, only 49 are employed. Through the four steps of "dividing into two," "hanging one aside," "counting by fours," and "returning the remainders," the changes of Heaven, Earth, and the four seasons are simulated. After 18 operations, a hexagram is derived. The number of stalks for the Qian (Heaven) hexagram is 216, while for the Kun (Earth) hexagram it is 144—together they total 360, matching the number of days in a year. The combined stalk count for all hexagrams is 11,520, symbolizing the number of all things. By mastering these patterns of transformation, one can comprehend the profound mysteries of Heaven and Earth.
The esoteric principles contained in the Hetu (River Chart) and Luoshu (Luo Writing)—ancient mystical diagrams—were revealed even before the formation of the hexagrams. The numbers 1 through 10 correspond to the Five Phases (Wuxing): 1 and 6 belong to Water, 2 and 7 to Fire, 3 and 8 to Wood, 4 and 9 to Metal, and 5 and 10 to Earth. The growth of all things begins with the fusion of Primordial Yang (the innate Yang Qi) and True Liquid (the innate Yin Jing). The number 1 represents Water (the father), 2 represents Fire (the Qian Yang of the south), 4 represents Metal (the Kun Yin of the west), and 3 represents Wood (the child), while Earth serves as the crucial harmonizing element among the Five Phases. The fiery nature of the south is firm and strong, belonging to the Qian (Heaven) principle as the masculine, while the metallic nature of the west is yielding and compliant, belonging to the Kun (Earth) principle as the feminine. Water, Earth, Wood, Fire, and Metal are all indispensable, with Earth being particularly vital as it enables the fulfillment of the other four phases.
This scripture primarily elucidates the laws governing cosmic generation and operation, focusing on the pivotal roles of the core concepts "One" and "Five" within this framework.
The workings of heaven and earth follow fixed patterns: Six combines with two to form Earth (among the Five Phases), seven combines with three, eight combines with four, and nine combines with five. Both the Luoshu (a mystical diagram) and Hetu (another esoteric diagram) center around "One," while their four corners adhere to mutual conquest relationships. In the southwest, Fire conquers Metal; in the northeast, Water generates Wood. The Qi of Water rotates leftward to produce Wood, while the Qi of Fire moves rightward to subdue Metal—just as sons inherit from fathers and male-female unions occur. This reveals the profound mysteries of cosmic operation.
All things originate from Earth and ultimately return to Earth. The "Five" in the Hetu and Luoshu occupies the central position, representing the harmonizing Qi—the energy of Yin-Yang union. Humans are born through receiving this harmonizing Qi of heaven and earth. When sages created the Bagua (Eight Trigrams), they followed this principle, where the auspicious or inauspicious nature of hexagrams depends on grasping the essential "center."
The "One" positioned below actually refers to the "One" within the central "Five." "Five" serves as the pivot of centrality, while "One" is its root. The "Do not use" in Qian hexagram's initial nine line and the "unused" in the Dayan numbers (divinatory numerals) both point to this "One." The complex transformations of numbers six through nine, and the dynamic interactions among the six offspring trigrams of Qian and Kun, all originate from this "One."
Humans possess both "Five" and "One." The "One" spoken of by sages is not merely one among myriad things, but that which wondrously governs all existence. It permeates heaven and earth, surveys the eight directions, operates within all beings, and weaves through transformations. The generative power of "One" is inexhaustible. Thus when sages emulate heaven and earth, their ultimate aim is to align with the marvelous functions of "One" and "Five"—how could this be merely about numbers?
Regarding interpretations of the Dayan numbers: combining the ten celestial stems, twelve earthly branches, and twenty-eight lunar mansions totals fifty. The "One" remains unused because heaven's generative Qi requires emptiness to achieve fullness, using transformation to perfect all things—hence forty-nine are actually employed. The Yi (Changes) contains Taiji (Supreme Ultimate), just as celestial phenomena have the North Star. Taiji generates the two modes (Yin-Yang), which divide into sun and moon; the sun and moon illuminate the four seasons, which correspond to the Five Phases. The Five Phases in motion differentiate into twelve months, whose accumulated transformations form the twenty-four solar terms. The North Star remains motionless at the center while forty-nine other stars revolve around it ceaselessly. In terms of hexagrams...
This passage primarily discusses the numerical applications in the Book of Changes (Yijing) and the four ways sages employ its principles.
Regarding numerical aspects: The six lines (yao, fundamental components of hexagrams) undergo forty-eight transformations. Combined with the two functions of Qian and Kun (hexagrams representing heaven and earth), they form the standard number fifty. The "Hidden Dragon" line (qianlong) in the initial nine of Qian hexagram refers to the application of forty-nine. While heaven and earth's total number is fifty-five, each of the Five Phases' Qi subtracts one, balancing excess and deficiency—precisely embodying the universal principle of forty-nine. The Great Expansion number fifty originates from the celestial five multiplied by the earthly ten in the center of the Hetu (ancient mystical diagram). During divination, removing six (symbolizing the six lines) leaves forty-nine. These manifestations of natural numerical principles transcend human manipulation. Five multiplied by ten yields fifty—the completion of numbers—while subtracting one initiates transformation. Preserving the largest number while leaving one empty mirrors the operations of heaven and earth.
Concerning the sage's path: The Yijing manifests four aspects of sagely wisdom: speech honors hexagram statements, action honors transformation, crafting objects honors symbolic imagery, and divination honors prognostication. Thus when noble persons (junzi) undertake affairs or journeys, their inquiries receive responses—whether regarding distant or profound matters—revealing future outcomes. Without the world's most refined wisdom, how could this be possible? Through the interplay of three and five transformations, interwoven numbers comprehend change to manifest the patterns of heaven and earth; exhaust numbers to determine all phenomena under heaven. Without the world's most adaptable wisdom, how could this be achieved? The Yijing itself is thoughtless and actionless (wuwei), quiescent and unmoving, yet through resonance comprehends all principles. Without the world's most miraculous wisdom, how could this occur?
The Yijing is how sages probe profundity and investigate subtlety. Its depth connects all minds under heaven; its subtlety accomplishes all affairs; its miraculousness achieves swift results without haste and reaches destinations without motion. As Confucius noted, "The Yijing contains four aspects of the sage's way." Quiescence manifests the realm of sincerity; resonant penetration demonstrates spiritual function—the unmanifest state between movement and stillness constitutes the subtle boundary between being and non-being.
This text reveals the inherent logic of numerical applications in the Yijing, along with four wisdom states attainable through its study: refinement, adaptability, miraculousness, and the capacity to penetrate the liminal space between existence and void.
The human mind is subtle and easily influenced by external phenomena. Once thoughts arise but fail to maintain centered balance, one deviates from the true path. Therefore, one must preserve the innate purity of the state before thoughts emerge—this is the essence of "true principle" (the fundamental truth of the universe), while adaptability and infinite subtle function are its manifestations. In the fleeting moment of transition between stillness and movement, the true principle suddenly reveals itself—this is the harbinger of all transformations, the omen of fortune and misfortune.
Though the signs have appeared, they remain in their nascent stage, not yet fully formed. If one can comprehend the Dao and always maintain the original mind, adapting with subtlety in the ambiguous state between presence and absence while never straying from the root, one attains a realm of tranquil nature and luminous wisdom. At this stage, the mysteries of serene stillness and responsive penetration (referring to the dual states of meditative stillness and dynamic adaptability in cultivation), as well as the principles of sincerity and divine subtlety, are fully embodied within oneself.
Confucius said: What is the purpose of the Book of Changes? The Book of Changes reveals the patterns of all things, accomplishes great endeavors, and encompasses the Dao of the world. The sages used it to connect the aspirations of all people, establish the great undertakings of the world, and resolve its uncertainties. The nature of the yarrow stalks (divination tools) is round and divinely subtle; the nature of the hexagrams is square and illuminating. The transformations of the six lines reveal fortune and misfortune. The sages used this to purify their minds, retreat into silent contemplation, and share the fortunes and misfortunes of the people. With divine wisdom, they foresaw the future; with profound knowledge, they preserved the past.
The ancient ones, who were wise and discerning, possessing divine martial virtue yet never resorting to force, were those who understood the Dao of Heaven and deeply observed human affairs. They created sacred divination tools to guide the people, and through fasting (a Daoist ritual for purifying body and mind), they elevated their virtue to a divine state. Closing the door symbolizes the Kun hexagram (Earth), while opening it symbolizes the Qian hexagram (Heaven). This opening and closing represent transformation, and their ceaseless flow is penetration. What manifests is called "image," what takes form is called "vessel," the rules established for their use are called "methods," and the people's daily reliance on them without awareness is called "divine."
The Book of Changes reveals: In the beginning, there was the Taiji (the Supreme Ultimate), which gave rise to the two modes of Yin and Yang. The two modes produced the four images (lesser Yang, greater Yang, lesser Yin, greater Yin), and the four images produced the eight trigrams. The eight trigrams determine fortune and misfortune, and fortune and misfortune shape great undertakings. Thus, the greatest image is Heaven and Earth, the most evident transformation is the four seasons, the brightest suspended images are the sun and moon, and the most exalted position is wealth and honor. To prepare resources for human use, to create tools for the benefit of all—none surpass the greatness of the sages.
This passage from the Yi Shuo explains the essence of the Book of Changes (Yijing) and the realm of sages. It states that to fathom profound principles, foresee future trends, determine the auspicious and inauspicious for all under heaven, and accomplish great undertakings, no tools are more essential than the divinatory stalks (yarrow stalks used for divination) and tortoise shells (used for oracle bone divination).
The signs and transformations revealed by heaven and earth are emulated by sages; the auspicious and inauspicious omens displayed in the heavens are mirrored by them; and the Dragon Diagram from the Yellow River and the Tortoise Script from the Luo River (legendary celestial auspicious patterns) are followed. The Book of Changes elucidates its principles through the four symbolic images (of yin and yang), clarifies its meanings through the appended statements (hexagram and line texts), and aids decision-making through judgments of fortune and misfortune.
However, the Book of Changes is not merely a tool for divination—it uses divination to illuminate the universal truth. Sages employ it to purify their minds, concealing wisdom deep within. Through the divinatory stalks, hexagrams, and line statements, sages clearly reveal the patterns of transformation in all things, where gains and losses naturally manifest. Though they perceive all phenomena, the innate nature of sages—unthinking and non-acting (Wuwei)—remains profoundly hidden, beyond the comprehension of ordinary people.
The way of heaven and earth operates thus: without first gathering and condensing, it cannot fully manifest; if the virtue (De) of the human mind is not inwardly restrained, it can easily be exhausted. Through divination, the principles of fortune and misfortune are determined by heaven, and human delusions are thereby dissolved. The sage’s mind is like the Supreme Ultimate (Taiji)—the people can follow it but never fully grasp it. Thus, the sage does not need divination to commune with the divine, nor hexagrams to foresee the future. For them, there is no distinction between auspicious and inauspicious, nor any anxiety.
The reason sages can share the people’s joys and sorrows is that they have penetrated the Dao of the Three Powers (heaven, earth, and humanity) and embodied the essence of all things. Therefore, the people’s concerns become their concerns, and fortune and misfortune are shared. The wisdom of sages enables them to foresee the future while also synthesizing the past. This wisdom is complete and self-sufficient, requiring no reliance on divinatory tools.
A true sage transcends the limitations of form, merging with all things—originally, there is no distinction between auspicious and inauspicious. Yet, to stand with the people in facing adversity, judgments of fortune and misfortune are made. Only the ancient sages, who were wise, discerning, divinely martial yet not bloodthirsty, could achieve this. Purifying their own hearts, the people naturally trust them; sharing the people’s hardships, adversity naturally dissipates. With divine wisdom as their strength, what need is there for slaughter?
(Note: "Withdrawing and storing in secrecy" refers to concealing wisdom deep within the heart, not revealing it lightly.)
The Book of Changes states: "When one receives divine protection from Heaven, all good fortune follows without hindrance." Confucius explains that "protection" (you) means assistance. Heaven assists those who accord with the Dao of Heaven, while people assist those who are sincere and trustworthy. When a person maintains sincerity, aligns with the Dao, and honors the worthy, they naturally receive Heaven's blessing, ensuring auspiciousness and success.
Confucius further observes: "Written words cannot fully convey speech, nor can speech fully express thought." But does this mean the sages' thoughts are truly incomprehensible? Not at all. The sages established hexagrams to fully articulate their ideas, created the sixty-four hexagrams to reveal the truth and falsehood of phenomena, appended judgments and line statements to thoroughly explain them, employed transformations and circulations to exhaust the functions of things, and inspired people to manifest their spiritual essence. The Qian (Heaven) and Kun (Earth) hexagrams contain the core principles of the Book of Changes. Once Qian and Kun are positioned, the Dao of the Changes is established within them. If Qian and Kun were to perish, the Dao of the Changes would no longer be visible; if the Dao of the Changes were invisible, the operations of Qian and Kun would nearly cease.
Thus, what transcends form is called the "Dao," while what has tangible shape is called a "vessel" (qi). The mutual transformation and adjustment of Dao and vessel is called "change" (bian), its widespread application is called "penetration" (tong), and its implementation in people's lives is called "enterprise" (shiye). Observing the complexity and subtlety of all things under Heaven, the sages used hexagrams to model their forms and symbolize their attributes—hence the term "image" (xiang). Studying the movements and transformations of all things, they discerned their patterns to establish rituals and norms, appending judgments to determine fortune and misfortune—hence the term "line" (yao).
When the eight trigrams are arranged in sequence, their images are contained within; when the trigrams overlap and combine, the transformations of the lines become evident. The mutual interaction of the firm (yang) and yielding (yin) generates change; when paired with hexagram and line statements, the principles of movement are clarified. Outcomes such as fortune, misfortune, regret, and remorse all arise from these movements. The firm and yielding are the foundation, while adaptability must accord with the times. The Dao of Heaven and Earth is eternally visible; the Dao of the sun and moon is eternally luminous; the movements of all things under Heaven are unified in this constant Dao. The Qian hexagram reveals simplicity through its steadfast strength, while the Kun hexagram demonstrates ease through its gentle compliance. The lines emulate these transformations; the images model these phenomena. As lines and images shift within the hexagrams, fortune and misfortune manifest externally, and achievements are realized therein.
This passage from the Yi Shuo explains how sages respond to the world's constant transformations by adhering to the principle of "zhen" (constancy in righteousness). The scripture reveals that heaven and earth's greatest virtue lies in nurturing life, while the sage's most precious treasure is maintaining their fundamental position. To preserve this position requires benevolence (ren), and to unite people's hearts requires resources, yet the foundation for managing wealth, regulating conduct, and preventing wrongdoing among the people ultimately rests on upholding righteousness (yi).
All worldly affairs alternate between auspiciousness and inauspiciousness in ceaseless transformation—this occurs when one fails to grasp "zhen in action" (the correct path of movement). "Zhen" means uprightness and single-minded focus. Whenever humans act, they inevitably become entangled; seeking good fortune may instead lead to misfortune. Only those who fully comprehend the principles of change without being trapped by auspicious or inauspicious outcomes truly understand "zhen." Laozi said that when lords and kings hold fast to the "One" (Dao), they become the standard for all under heaven. Though transformations are myriad, all can be governed by this singular principle.
Human restlessness stems from insatiably chasing auspicious outcomes. Yet pursuing glory invites disgrace, and coveting gain leads to loss—this is the natural order. If one can act without artificial effort, naturally aligning with the Great Void (cosmic origin), distinctions between auspicious and inauspicious dissolve. Even when encountering fortune or misfortune, maintaining inner transcendence allows proper response. All 384 lines of the 64 hexagrams value "zhen," for the supreme truth is this: a single "correctness" can master ten thousand changes.
Yao and Shun didn't neglect the world's sorrows for pleasure—they used constancy to overcome fortune. Confucius and Yan Hui didn't alter their joy amid hardship—they used constancy to overcome misfortune. Thus, constancy originates from cosmic law: heaven and earth operate through "zhen's manifestation" (zhen guan), sun and moon shine through "zhen's illumination" (zhen ming), and all transformations under heaven return to "zhen's unity" (zhen fu yi). Understanding the patterns of fortune while acting with constancy erases regret. Regrets stem from minor faults, yet "repentance" (hui) reflects the self-examining Dao-mind, where faults gradually diminish; "stinginess" (lin) represents the excuse-making human mind, where faults multiply. By holding to the constancy of the One, these faults naturally wax and wane.
The concluding reference to Confucian thought describes creation's vitality: from Wuji (Non-Ultimate) to Taiji (Supreme Ultimate), Yin-Yang and the Five Phases generate all things—this is the creative dynamism of the cosmos. From Taiji returning to Wuji, all things revert to their source—this is the cyclical process of return.
This passage from Yi Shuo (Explanations on the Changes) primarily discusses the patterns of cosmic creation and the evolution of human civilization. Regarding zaohua (cosmic operation), the text observes that generation and dissolution may appear as opposites, yet both manifest natural law. What is termed "the mechanism of termination" (shaji) in the Yinfu Jing (Scripture of the Hidden Talisman) represents tactical adaptation rather than fundamental Dao. Heaven and Earth's supreme De (Virtue/Power) is "generation"—the transformations of Yin-Yang are but different expressions of this ceaseless generative Qi (vital energy).
The narrative then recounts how ancient sage-kings observed nature to establish civilization: Fuxi (Baoxi Shi) created the Bagua (Eight Trigrams) by contemplating the patterns of Heaven and Earth, crafting fishing nets through knotted cords. Shennong Shi invented agricultural tools to teach cultivation and established marketplaces to facilitate trade. During the reigns of the Yellow Emperor (Huangdi), Yao, and Shun, further advancements emerged—boats and carts improved transportation, dwellings enhanced living conditions, mortars and pestles processed grain, while bows and arrows maintained order. These innovations embody the Yijing (Classic of Changes) principle: "When exhausted, transform; through transformation, penetrate; through penetration, endure." By aligning reforms with natural patterns, they ultimately received Heaven's protection.
References like "derived from Li/Yi/Shihe" indicate how these inventions correspond to specific hexagram principles. For instance, fishing nets follow Li hexagram (symbolizing interlaced netting), farming tools follow Yi hexagram (symbolizing augmentation), and marketplaces follow Shihe hexagram (symbolizing exchange). These records reflect the ancient concept of "creating implements by observing images," demonstrating how human civilization emerged through emulating cosmic patterns.
This passage outlines several key stages in the development of ancient civilization, with particular focus on Fu Xi's creation of the Eight Trigrams (Bagua).
Regarding the evolution of ancient burial customs: Initially, people wrapped the deceased in thick layers of straw and buried them in wilderness areas without constructing burial mounds or markers, and mourning periods had no fixed duration. Later, sages introduced the use of inner and outer coffins (guan-guo) for interment—a practice inspired by insights from the Great Excess hexagram (one of the 64 hexagrams in the Book of Changes).
On the advancement of record-keeping methods: In high antiquity, people used knotted cords for keeping records. Later, sages developed written contracts (shuqi), which officials employed to govern administrative affairs and common people used to clarify matters—an innovation deriving from the Breakthrough hexagram (the decisive hexagram in the Book of Changes).
Concerning discussions about Fu Xi's Eight Trigrams diagrams: Fu Xi originally created only one Bagua arrangement. Later circular, horizontal, and square diagrams were all subsequent creations by later scholars based on Yi principles. The circular diagram symbolizes celestial phenomena, with the Qian trigram (representing Heaven) positioned south and Kun trigram (representing Earth) north. The square diagram represents geographical principles, placing Qian in the northwest and Kun in the southeast. These configurations embody the dynamic interplay and transformational operations of Yin-Yang.
The author emphasizes that the essence of the Book of Changes transcends graphical representation: True Yi principles are formless and imageless—the 64 hexagrams can be flexibly applied without rigid adherence to fixed diagrams. Through the Yi, sages transmitted methods for integrating profound principles into daily speech and conduct, beginning with the Qian hexagram and concluding with the Incomplete hexagram, with a subtlety surpassing any graphical demonstration.
The passage concludes by noting that King Wen of Zhou contributed the concept of overlapping hexagrams (combining two trigrams to form the 64 hexagrams), and the name "Book of Changes" (Yijing) also dates from King Wen's era. According to the Commentary on the Yi, Fu Xi created the Eight Trigrams to commune with the virtue of spiritual beings (Shenming zhi de) and classify the dispositions of all things.
This passage examines the historical context and core concepts of the Yijing (Book of Changes). While rarely mentioning Fuxi's (Baoxishi) creation of the Yijing, it repeatedly emphasizes King Wen of Zhou's contributions. The Qian (Heaven) and Kun (Earth) hexagrams are regarded as the gateway to the Yijing—though hexagram names are numerous, they follow discernible patterns, possibly reflecting the crisis consciousness of a declining era.
The author suggests the Yijing likely emerged during the late Shang dynasty's collapse and the Zhou dynasty's rise, connected to historical events involving King Wen and King Zhou. The sage (primarily King Wen here) elucidated fortune and misfortune by establishing hexagram images, observing phenomena, and composing judgments, thereby revealing cosmic mysteries through appropriate symbolism. The sage could also perceive patterns in movement, grasp universal principles, and establish behavioral norms accordingly.
The text describes how sages purified their minds through the Yijing, retreating into quiet contemplation and communicating with deities through fasting (zhai). During the turbulent transition from Shang to Zhou, King Wen responded to a changing world with unchanging principles, embedding his philosophy within the hexagram and line statements—particularly through Qian's "Using Nine" and Kun's "Using Six" line texts, which express his central ideas.
Regarding hexagram formation, it explains the principle of three-line trigrams combining into six-line hexagrams. The term "line" (yao) originally meant mutual transformation, derived from intersecting trigrams. Confucius noted that trigram arrangements create symbolic representations, with overlapping producing line transformations. Hexagrams inherently embody images without needing explicit names; overlapping naturally generates lines without requiring special explanation—this forms the theory of "overlapping hexagrams" (the 64 hexagrams). When challenged, the author cites examples like Shennong modeling farming tools after the Yi hexagram and trade practices after the Shike hexagram, demonstrating that overlapping hexagrams existed long before.
This passage examines the relationship between the hexagrams of the Book of Changes (Yijing) and the ancient sages' invention of tools and institutions. The author refutes a mechanistic correspondence theory, arguing that one cannot simplistically claim that Fuxi (the legendary sage who created the Eight Trigrams) invented certain implements based solely on specific hexagrams.
The text notes that the Xici Zhuan (Great Commentary) lists twelve innovations including hunting and fishing, plows and hoes, trade, and clothing, demonstrating how the sixty-four hexagrams already encompassed all civil necessities. However, the sages' creation of implements was never a mechanical matching with hexagrams, but rather a response to the needs of their times. When Fuxi established order in the world, he created the Eight Trigrams to reveal heaven and earth's mysteries; when King Wen faced a declining age, he expanded them into sixty-four hexagrams to exhaust all transformations between heaven and earth—both were natural acts in accordance with their historical circumstances.
The author provides examples to challenge rigid interpretations: If the Dui hexagram represents concubines, does this mean the concubine system originated in Fuxi's era? If the Kan hexagram symbolizes thieves, were thieves also products of Fuxi's time? Such claims clearly defy common sense. The sages' emulation of heaven and earth's Dao lies in grasping the principle of simplicity, profoundly investigating the subtleties of creation. Only in times of societal decline do hexagrams like Mingyi (Darkening of the Light), Wuwang (Innocence), Ge (Revolution), and Huan (Dispersion) emerge to foretell impending crises.
The concluding paragraph explains fundamental concepts of the Yijing: The essence of Yi (Change) is symbolism (xiang), which means representing things through imagery; the judgment (tuan) analyzes a hexagram's substance (its overall character); the line statements (yao) emulate the movements and transformations of all phenomena under heaven. It is precisely through these symbols and changes that omens of fortune and misfortune become visible, while warnings about regret and error are made manifest.
Emphasizing the Yijing's wisdom as residing in flexible application, this passage opposes rigid interpretations of hexagram-reality correlations, embodying the Daoist philosophy of "moving in harmony with the times" (yu shi xie xing).
Chapter Three discusses the patterns of yin and yang trigrams. Why is it that yang trigrams (representing active, luminous hexagrams) contain more yin lines, while yin trigrams (representing passive, dark hexagrams) contain more yang lines? This is because yang trigrams are governed by odd numbers, while yin trigrams are characterized by even numbers. In terms of virtue (De), yang trigrams symbolize one ruler leading two subjects—this is the Way (Dao) of the noble person. Yin trigrams represent two rulers competing for one subject—this is the way of petty individuals.
Yang trigrams, rooted in odd numbers, demonstrate the noble status of firm yang virtue. Yin trigrams, marked by even numbers, embody the yielding quality of submission yet achieving shared success. In times of prosperous governance, the yang trigram's model of one ruler with two subjects exemplifies the noble path. During chaotic eras, the yin trigram's pattern of two rulers contending for one subject manifests as the way of inferior men. The proper order of the world lies in unity, while selfishness leads to division. The one-ruler-two-subjects model values singularity, whereas the two-rulers-one-subject dynamic deviates from impartial justice.
In scholarly pursuits, without vigorous spiritual energy (Shen), one falls into the disorderly state of two rulers competing for one subject. Though both may appear reverent, without yang's firmness, reverence becomes merely an external lord while the heart remains servile. With yang's strength, reverence truly nurtures the original mind.
Chapter Four cites the Yijing (Book of Changes): "When thoughts wander restlessly, companions will follow your mental fluctuations." Confucius explains: What in all creation requires special deliberation? All ultimately return to the same destination though paths differ; achieving unity permits a hundred considerations. When the sun sets the moon rises; when the moon withdraws the sun appears—their alternation generates illumination. After bitter cold comes sweltering heat; when extreme heat recedes, severe cold returns—this cycling of temperatures forms the year. Withdrawal contracts, advance expands—their mutual stimulation produces benefit.
The inchworm bends to stretch further; dragons and snakes hibernate to preserve life (Xingming). Refining principle (Li) to spiritual perfection (Shen) enables application; employing knowledge to settle body and mind cultivates virtue (De). What lies beyond cannot be known. Exhausting spiritual mystery and penetrating transformation represents virtue's supreme state.
The Yijing states: "Confined among stones, leaning on thistles, returning home to find no wife—ominous." Confucius interprets: Being trapped where one shouldn't be inevitably damages reputation; depending where one shouldn't necessarily endangers life. With both reputation ruined and life imperiled, death approaches—how could one see one's wife?
The Yijing says: "A duke shoots at a hawk atop the high wall, capturing it—nothing unfavorable." Confucius explains: Hawks are fierce birds, arrows deadly tools, the archer human. Noblemen store sharp implements, awaiting the moment to act—how could they not succeed? Action without obstruction ensures immediate results. This speaks of preparation enabling seized opportunities.
The bow and arrow are merely tools—what truly matters is the person who wields them. A true noble person (junzi, one of high virtue) cultivates their abilities in advance and waits for the proper moment to act. How could affairs not proceed smoothly this way? When action meets no obstruction and every effort yields results, this illustrates the principle of preparing one's tools before acting.
Confucius said: Petty individuals (xiaoren, those of low virtue) feel no shame in acting without benevolence, fear no consequences in pursuing what is unjust, and exert no effort unless there is personal gain. Without deterrence, they never restrain themselves. For such people, receiving minor punishment and learning from it is actually a blessing. The Book of Changes states, "Fetters wound the toes, but no great misfortune follows"—this precisely conveys the idea. Good deeds, if not accumulated, cannot establish one's reputation; wicked deeds, if not accumulated, will not bring about one's ruin. Petty individuals deem small acts of kindness worthless and thus neglect them, and consider minor transgressions harmless and thus fail to correct them. Consequently, their misdeeds accumulate until they can no longer be concealed, and their crimes grow too grave to escape. The Book of Changes warns, "Shackles maim the ears—ominous"—this is the meaning.
Confucius said: Those in peril often remain complacent in their circumstances; states doomed to fall often believe themselves secure; chaos frequently arises from the delusion of good governance. Therefore, the noble person does not forget danger in times of safety, does not forget ruin in times of existence, and does not forget disorder in times of peace. Only then can they ensure personal security and the preservation of the state. The Book of Changes cautions, "It is nearly lost, it is nearly lost! As if tied to a fragile mulberry branch"—this is the warning.
Confucius said: Those of shallow virtue yet exalted rank, meager wisdom yet grand ambitions, feeble strength yet heavy responsibilities—rarely do they avoid calamity. The Book of Changes says, "The tripod's legs break, spilling the ruler's feast—his appearance disgraced, ominous." This describes the inability to bear one's burden.
Confucius said: How wondrous are those who perceive the subtle signs of change! The noble person neither flatters superiors nor slights subordinates—this is the wisdom of discerning the subtle. The term "subtle" (ji) refers to the faint omens of transformation, the early manifestations of fortune or misfortune. The noble person acts upon seeing these signs without delay. The Book of Changes states, "Firm as a boulder—not a full day passes before clarity is achieved. Perseverance brings good fortune." If one is steadfast as stone, why wait a full day to judge? The truth is instantly apparent. The noble person understands both the hidden and the evident, knows both softness and strength—thus they become figures of universal respect.
Confucius praised Yan Hui (the son of the Yan clan), saying: Was he not nearly perfect? He never failed to recognize his faults, and once aware, never repeated them. The Book of Changes declares, "Turning back after straying not far—no great remorse. Supreme good fortune." This is the principle.
When Heaven and Earth's Yin and Yang energies merge, the myriad things are conceived; when male and female essences unite, the myriad beings are born. The Book of Changes observes, "When three journey together, one is lost; when one travels alone, a companion is found"—this speaks of the necessity of single-minded focus.
Confucius said: The noble person first secures their position before acting, first calms their heart before speaking, first establishes bonds before seeking aid. By cultivating these three, they achieve completeness. Acting recklessly in peril, the people will not follow; speaking fearfully, the people will not respond; seeking help without prior connection, the people will not give.
This passage from Yi Shuo (Discourse on Change) primarily explains the principles of Yin-Yang transformation and their application in human conduct. The mutual transformation of Yin and Yang, the interplay between strength and gentleness—these changes and responses follow natural laws. When the transformations of Yin-Yang and rigidity-softness align with their inherent nature, all things flourish spontaneously; when adulterated with artificiality, conflicts of benefit and harm arise.
Human emotions are the natural expression of innate character. Sincerity in relationships reveals the beauty of one's true nature, while pretense and affectation invite misfortune. The Dao of Heaven operates with unwavering authenticity, ceaseless in its motion, whereas the human way is often obscured by selfish desires, oscillating between sincerity and deceit. Thus, complete sincerity aligns with heavenly principle and brings benefit, while falsehood violates it and invites harm.
The key to accomplishing great undertakings lies in: discerning the subtle signs of change to comprehend underlying principles, persisting with unyielding determination to achieve tangible results, and understanding advance and retreat to preserve oneself. This is the path of cultivating both internal and external dimensions—delving deeply into principles until one attains spiritual mastery ("refined meaning enters the spirit"), enabling effortless application in practice. When external actions are proper, internal cultivation deepens, creating mutual reinforcement between inner and outer.
As for reaching the state of comprehending the mysteries of all things, this requires prolonged cultivation and accumulation—a feat even the noble person finds difficult to fully attain. The divine manifests in the formless patterns governing all existence, while transformation appears in the tangible forms of phenomena. Only through thoroughly understanding principles and fully realizing one's nature can this realm be reached—it cannot be achieved through mere thought or forced effort. Practitioners should maintain focused awareness and cultivate stillness within, harmonizing with change while awaiting the proper timing. When selfish desires are utterly purified and one completely aligns with heavenly principle, one may inherit the supreme goodness and embody the wondrous transformative qualities of the Dao.
The Book of Changes (Yijing) states that sages comprehend the signs of transformation in all things, foreseeing the future without deliberate observation. Even someone as discerning as Yan Hui (Confucius' most virtuous disciple) still needed to actively observe emerging trends. This shows that Yan Hui approached sagehood but had not yet fully attained it.
Sages are completely united with the good Dao (Dao), thus perceiving negative tendencies before they take form; Yan Hui maintained a subtle distance from perfect virtue, recognizing improper thoughts only as they arose. The saying "there is nothing improper he does not perceive" means Yan Hui could discern all improper matters in the world. Once aware of impropriety, he prevented such thoughts from taking root in his heart; knowing something was wrong, he never repeated it, thus never manifesting it in action. This explains why Yan Hui approached sagehood—not because he frequently had improper thoughts, nor because he could only correct mistakes after committing them.
The noble person (junzi) responds immediately to subtle omens without waiting for matters to fully manifest. This swift response doesn't rely on cleverness but on rock-solid steadfastness. When selfish desires don't disturb the heart-mind (Xin), clarity naturally prevails; with an undisturbed mind, actions become radiantly upright. Such people advance without rashness and retreat without hesitation—why would they need to constantly await opportunities? Yet the noble person's steadfastness isn't rigid: they observe celestial phenomena in minute detail, examine earthly patterns in broad strokes, emulate the yielding virtue (De) of Yin when appropriate, and manifest Yang's strength when needed. Adapting to the Dao's transformations while maintaining unshakable inner principles, they become models for all.
Confucius said: "The Qian (Heaven) and Kun (Earth) hexagrams are the gateway to understanding the Book of Changes." Qian represents all Yang phenomena, Kun all Yin manifestations. Their interaction creates the complementary dynamics of strength and yielding, thereby manifesting the creative transformations of heaven and earth and penetrating the virtuous power (De) of the spiritual realm. Though the hexagram names appear disorderly, their classification reveals patterns that may reflect the thinking of declining eras. The Book of Changes illuminates the past and foresees the future, making hidden principles visible and obscure meanings clear. It distinguishes things through appropriate naming, determines fortune and misfortune with precise language—its content is remarkably comprehensive. Though the hexagram names are small, their symbolic categories are vast; their meanings profound yet expressed in elegant language; their words subtle yet pointed, their examples simple yet profound. Through the principles of Yin-Yang transformation, it guides people's conduct and clarifies the karmic consequences of gain and loss.
The rise of the Yijing (Book of Changes) likely occurred during the mid-antiquity period. Was its creator perhaps imbued with a sense of profound concern? Thus, nine hexagrams were employed to elucidate the fundamental virtues for navigating life:
The "Lü Hexagram" (symbolizing practice) forms the foundation of virtue (De), the "Qian Hexagram" (symbolizing humility) serves as virtue's handle, the "Fu Hexagram" (symbolizing return) constitutes virtue's root, the "Heng Hexagram" (symbolizing constancy) stabilizes virtue, the "Sun Hexagram" (symbolizing decrease) cultivates virtue, the "Yi Hexagram" (symbolizing increase) broadens virtue, the "Kun Hexagram" (symbolizing adversity) discerns virtue, the "Jing Hexagram" (symbolizing nourishment) anchors virtue, and the "Xun Hexagram" (symbolizing compliance) regulates virtue.
Specifically: The Lü Hexagram achieves perfection through harmony, the Qian Hexagram shines brightly through noble humility, the Fu Hexagram discerns all things through subtle observation, the Heng Hexagram maintains focus amidst complexity, the Sun Hexagram transforms difficulty into ease, the Yi Hexagram grows continuously without deliberate effort, the Kun Hexagram finds clarity at exhaustion's limit, the Jing Hexagram nourishes all while abiding in its proper place, and the Xun Hexagram balances priorities while remaining subtly concealed.
These nine hexagrams each serve distinct functions: Lü guides harmonious action, Qian standardizes ritual propriety, Fu fosters self-awareness, Heng preserves consistent character, Sun avoids calamity, Yi generates benefit, Kun reduces resentment, Jing clarifies moral principles, and Xun facilitates adaptive change.
Though the complete Yijing contains sixty-four hexagrams, why emphasize these nine? Did the creator select them as remedies for adversity due to personal anxiety? Not so. The sage's concern lay with humanity's loss of fundamental nature—why would they worry about personal circumstances? Therefore, these hexagrams serve to alleviate worldly anxieties, with "returning to original nature" as their core purpose, while the deliberate placement of "Lü" and "Qian" at the forefront reflects careful design.
The Dao (principle) and concrete phenomena are inherently inseparable, just as essence (shen) and manifestation cannot be divided. Yet those claiming Daoist attainment often treat phenomena as external objects, while seekers of mystery become trapped by superficial appearances. The Yijing's Dao involves exhausting human nature to comprehend heavenly mandate (tianming), eternally abiding in perpetual transformation. Hence, advocates of emptiness and self-indulgence frequently misinterpret the Yijing—precisely what caused the sages profound concern.
How to resolve this concern? Through ritual propriety's guidance. The Lü Hexagram guards against external distractions, the Qian Hexagram concentrates internal spirit (shen), thereby facilitating the return to original nature. Yet without stabilization after return, one may stray again, necessitating understanding "constancy." Rigid adherence without flexibility leads to stagnation, hence the importance of comprehending "increase and decrease." Mastering the decrease of selfish desires and increase of heavenly principle enables maintaining unwavering original nature amidst adversity, like an inexhaustible well providing universal nourishment. Achieving this state allows responsive adaptation—permeating like wind while leaving no trace.
This passage from Discussions on the Changes elucidates the core philosophy and practical wisdom of the Yijing (Classic of Changes).
Regarding the principle of "adaptive change": Only when the mind remains unobstructed can one respond with flexibility. When one's learning reaches the level of adapting to circumstances, the original purity of the heart-mind is fully restored. However, this must be grounded in ritual propriety and rooted in virtuous conduct (De) — this is the true essence of the sage's teachings. Ritual norms are not mere superficial conventions, nor is the Yijing some abstruse and unfathomable doctrine. While the Yijing speaks of transformation and ritual emphasizes regulation, neither advocates rigid dogmatism nor complete absence of principles. Here, the arguments of those who promote nihilistic indulgence find no footing.
On the "virtue of yielding" (Xun De): Those who defy circumstances without adaptation are stubborn extremists, while those who completely submit to circumstances without principles are weak-minded. True yielding virtue lies in discerning the proper measure — accommodating situations while maintaining discernment, all without leaving traces or flaunting one's abilities.
Regarding self-cultivation: Virtue (De) is often lost through excessive caution, while resolve grows weary amidst繁杂 affairs. If one can maintain clarity in adversity and composure in chaos — perceiving subtleties like distinguishing minute objects, facing complexity without fatigue; discerning right from wrong in subtle words and deeds, remaining unmoved by external temptations — then one returns to original authenticity. By preserving tranquility amid busy social engagements and sustaining commitment without weariness, one maintains virtue perpetually.
On practical wisdom: Actions contrary to human nature prove difficult at first but easier later, while deeds aligned with heavenly principle appear easy initially but grow challenging. In pursuing the Dao through learning, as virtue (De) daily advances, one's mind expands; the higher one's position, the more essential it becomes to avoid arrogance.
Chapter Eight further clarifies: The principles expounded in the Yijing must not be divorced from daily life. It reveals the ceaseless patterns of change — the mutual transformations of yin-yang and hardness-softness follow no fixed template, requiring only adaptation to change. Through hexagram and line transformations, it awakens people to vigilance, as if guided by teachers and nurtured by parents. Beginners must follow the hexagram statements to discern their direction, ultimately mastering their inherent patterns. Yet these principles cannot manifest spontaneously without the right practitioner.
Chapter Nine observes: This classic investigates the fundamental nature of things from beginning to end. The six alternating lines reflect situations within specific temporal contexts. The initial line proves hardest to grasp while the top line appears easiest — this reflects the root-and-branch nature of phenomena. The beginning line's statement requires careful pondering, while the outcome becomes certain only at the end. As for the intricate interrelations of hexagram images and changing line positions, one must discern their auspicious or inauspicious portents.
In Chapter 9 of the Yi Jing (Book of Changes), determining right and wrong, gain and loss depends on observing whether the yao positions in the hexagram are complete. To foresee survival or demise, fortune or misfortune, one need only observe the transformations of the yao lines. Those who truly understand the Yi can grasp most of its principles simply by contemplating the hexagram statements (explanatory texts for each hexagram). The second and fourth yao share similar functions but differ in position—the second yao often receives praise while the fourth tends toward anxiety, as it is closer to the ruler's position. The way of Yin (the receptive) should not venture far; the key lies in avoiding faults by adhering to the Middle Way. Similarly, the third and fifth yao share functions but differ in outcome—the third often brings danger while the fifth yields achievement, determined by their noble or humble status. Excessive weakness invites peril; only strength can ensure victory.
Chapter 10 states that the Yi Jing encompasses all things, covering the Dao of Heaven, the Dao of Humanity, and the Dao of Earth. By dividing the three realms—Heaven, Earth, and Humanity—into Yin and Yang, the six yao lines are formed. These six yao embody the Dao of the Three Powers. The Dao transforms, hence it is called "yao"; the yao have hierarchies, hence they are called "things"; the interweaving of things creates "patterns," and when these patterns are misaligned, fortune or misfortune arises.
Chapter 11 explains that the Yi Jing emerged during the transition between the Shang and Zhou dynasties, encapsulating the stories of King Wen and King Zhou. Thus, the hexagram statements warn of danger, urging the complacent to vigilance and the arrogant to restraint. Its principles are vast, encompassing all things, ever cautionary, with the key lying in avoiding faults—this is the true essence of the Yi.
Chapter 12 elucidates that the Qian hexagram (symbolizing Heaven) is the firmest under Heaven, its virtue constant and simple yet capable of discerning peril; the Kun hexagram (symbolizing Earth) is the most yielding under Heaven, its virtue constant and succinct yet capable of recognizing obstacles. It can bring joy to the heart and penetrate contemplation, thereby determining fortune and misfortune and achieving great deeds. Thus, in transformation, auspicious signs emerge; by observing images, one understands objects; through divination, one foresees the future. Heaven and Earth establish their positions, the sage fulfills their function, humanity and spirits collaborate, and even the common people may partake. The Eight Trigrams communicate through symbolism; the yao statements reveal through disposition. The interplay of firm and yielding manifests fortune and misfortune. Change brings benefit; fortune and misfortune follow circumstance. Thus, love and aversion contend, giving rise to fortune and misfortune; distance and proximity, acceptance and rejection, produce regret and hesitation; sincerity and deceit intertwine, creating advantage and harm. If things draw near but do not harmonize, danger arises, or harm befalls, followed by regret. The words of traitors are marked by shame; the hesitant speak haltingly. The virtuous are sparing in speech, the restless verbose. Slanderers of good people hedge their words; those who abandon integrity speak submissively.
When the ancient sages created the Book of Changes (Yijing), they devised the method of divination with milfoil stalks through silent communion with spiritual forces. They observed the patterns of heaven and earth (the "three celestial and two terrestrial numbers" referring to the yin-yang principle of three as heavenly number and two as earthly number) to establish numerical systems, discerned the transformations of yin and yang to formulate the Eight Trigrams (Bagua), and developed the hexagram lines based on the qualities of strength and yielding. All these accord with the principles of Dao and De (Virtue), capable of elucidating moral principles and ultimately achieving the purpose of exploring the essence of life.
What heaven bestows upon humans is called "destiny" (ming), and what all beings receive is called "nature" (xing). These fundamentals all originate from the Book of Changes, hence its system is profoundly comprehensive. Through observing heaven, earth, and all things, the sages created the Book of Changes, encompassing all principles of existence, exhausting the nature of all beings, and aligning with the natural Dao of heaven—thus grasping the source of life's essence. Scholars investigate phenomena to exhaust their nature and thereby comprehend destiny; this exploration of life's origin never transcends the four fundamental virtues of "origination, prosperity, advantage, and perseverance" (yuan heng li zhen, the four virtues of the Qian hexagram symbolizing the four phases of heaven's movement).
The attainment of heaven's "origination" (yuan) manifests in humans as benevolence; obtaining "prosperity" (heng) becomes propriety; acquiring "advantage" (li) transforms into righteousness; and achieving "perseverance" (zhen) embodies wisdom. Therefore, yuan heng li zhen represent the eternal Dao of heaven, while benevolence, righteousness, propriety, and wisdom form the guiding principles of human nature. Observe this creative pattern: heaven is noble and earth humble; yang is active while yin is still; distinctions between noble and base give rise to fortune and misfortune—all rooted in the pre-celestial state before the Supreme Ultimate (Taiji), fixed and unchanging. This is the truth of life's origin.
(Chapter 2)
The sages created the Book of Changes to comply with the principles of life's essence. Thus they established heaven's law as yin-yang, earth's law as yielding-strength, and humanity's law as benevolence-righteousness. Combining the three powers (san cai) of heaven, earth, and humanity—each divided into yin and yang—the Book of Changes employs six lines to form a hexagram. Through alternating yin-yang and transforming yielding-strength, a complete hexagram system emerges across six line positions.
(Chapter 3)
Heaven and earth establish their upper and lower positions; mountains and marshes exchange their qi; thunder and wind stimulate each other; water and fire do not repel—thus the Eight Trigrams intermingle. To calculate the past requires sequential deduction, while foreseeing the future demands reverse deduction; therefore the Book of Changes primarily employs reverse deduction.
For worldly affairs, reviewing the past follows sequential thinking, whereas predicting the future requires reverse thinking. The Book of Changes was created for foreseeing the future, hence its use of reverse deduction. Hexagram lines are drawn from bottom to top; the Yi diagrams are read from right to left—this reverse deduction method actually embodies thinking that follows heavenly principles. Top-to-bottom is called "sequential"; bottom-to-top is "reverse"; left-to-right is "sequential"; right-to-left is "reverse." Sequential deduction comprehends what has occurred; reverse deduction foreknows what is to come. To know what has not yet happened—this is precisely the subtlety of the Book of Changes' "reverse calculation" method.
This passage explains the differences between Fu Xi's Bagua (Eight Trigrams) and King Wen's Bagua in the Yijing (Book of Changes), along with the principles of trigram transformation. Fu Xi's Bagua illustrates the fundamental patterns of heaven and earth in nature: heaven above and earth below, the sun rising in the east and the moon appearing in the west, mountains in the northwest and marshes in the southeast, wind coming from the southwest and thunder stirring in the northeast. These represent fixed, unchanging natural laws, hence termed "the past" (what is already known).
King Wen's Bagua, on the other hand, demonstrates the principles of cyclical transformation: the Qian trigram (heaven) is positioned in the northwest, Kun (earth) in the southwest, Kan (water) and Li (fire) occupy the center, Zhen (thunder) and Xun (wind) are active on the left, while Gen (mountain) and Dui (marsh) are paired on the right. These trigram positions reflect the patterns of change in all phenomena, thus called "the future" (what is yet to occur).
The text further explains the transformational logic of the trigrams: Taiji (Supreme Ultimate) generates the two polarities of Yin and Yang, which in turn produce the four phases (lesser Yang, greater Yang, lesser Yin, greater Yin), and from these four phases emerge the eight trigrams. The Qian and Li trigrams belong to Yang, representing heaven and fire; the Kun and Kan trigrams belong to Yin, representing earth and water. When the bottom Yang line of Qian transforms into Yin, it becomes Xun (wind) — the transformation of heaven. When the third Yin line of Kun changes to Yang, it becomes Gen (mountain) — the transformation of earth. When the third Yang line of Li shifts to Yin, it forms Zhen (thunder) — the transformation of fire. When the first Yin line of Kan turns to Yang, it produces Dui (marsh) — the transformation of water.
Finally, the passage clarifies that Yijing divination primarily follows the transformational patterns of King Wen's Bagua. Though it may appear to deduce changes through reverse reasoning, it actually aligns with natural laws. This differs from Daoist Neidan (internal alchemy) practice, which employs reverse cultivation methods of restraint to seek vitality.
This scripture primarily discusses the relationship between the Eight Trigrams (Bagua) — Qian (Heaven), Dui (Lake), Kan (Water), Xun (Wind), Zhen (Thunder), Li (Fire), Kun (Earth), and Gen (Mountain) — and the transformations of nature, as well as the role of the "Sovereign" (referring to the cosmic governing force) within this framework.
The interactions among the Eight Trigrams fall into two categories: mutual alignment and mutual distancing. The trigrams Qian, Dui, Kan, and Xun remain distant from one another, each generating distinct transformations. By observing these changes, one can discern the patterns of interdependence among things; by examining their transitions, one comprehends the principles of mutual generation.
Zhen (Thunder) and Xun (Wind) represent the initial stage of interaction: Zhen contains minimal Yang Qi and abundant Yin Qi, while Xun holds minimal Yin Qi and abundant Yang Qi. Thus, the initial manifestations are thunder shaking all things into motion and wind scattering them. Dui (Lake), Li (Fire), Kan (Water), and Gen (Mountain) signify deeper interaction: Dui and Li embody Yang Qi penetrating Yin Qi, while Kan and Gen represent Yin Qi infiltrating Yang Qi. Consequently, the intermediate phase manifests as rain nourishing all things, sunlight warming them, mountains stabilizing them, and marshes fostering their growth.
The Yang Qi of Zhen, Dui, and Li all originate from Qian (Heaven), making Qian the ruler of all things. The Yin Qi of Xun, Kan, and Gen all return to Kun (Earth), making Kun the gatherer of all things. Yet although Qian governs Yang Qi, it inherently oversees both Yin and Yang, hence its designation as "Lord" and "Sovereign." The Sovereign above appears to govern through non-action (Wuwei), while ministers below must act diligently to serve the world. Though the Sovereign manifests through the trigrams, it never truly departs, for the generation and transformation of all things stem from the generative power of the Sovereign's Virtue (De). Thus, we understand that ceaseless regeneration is the very essence of the Supreme Ultimate (Taiji).
Chapter Four details how the "Sovereign" manifests through the Eight Trigrams: emerging in Zhen, bringing order in Xun, revealing itself in Li, nurturing in Kun, rejoicing in Dui, engaging in cosmic struggle in Qian, laboring in Kan, and completing the cycle in Gen. All beings begin their growth with Zhen in the east, then align orderly through Xun in the southeast. Li symbolizes illumination in the south, where all things become visible — hence sages face south when governing. Kun represents the earth, nourishing all beings. Dui corresponds to autumn, when the harvest brings joy. Qian in the northwest embodies the struggle between Yin and Yang. Kan signifies water in the north, the trigram of toil where all things return to storage. Gen in the northeast marks both the completion of one cycle and the beginning of another.
The "Sovereign" is the pivot of Qian and Kun's revolutions — its comings and goings cannot be directly observed but only perceived through the movement and transformation of all things. Xun represents the transition between spring and summer, when vibrant life emerges in perfect order, as if regulated by an unseen force.
This passage primarily explains the correspondences between the Eight Trigrams (Bagua) — Qian (Heaven), Kun (Earth), Zhen (Thunder), Xun (Wind), Kan (Water), Li (Fire), Gen (Mountain), and Dui (Lake) — and natural phenomena, directional seasons, as well as human relationships.
First, the Xun trigram (representing wind) corresponds to summer, when yin and yang meet, much like the Gou hexagram (signifying encounter). The Li and Kun trigrams reside in the southwest, the direction that nurtures all things. Heaven governs the inception of all beings, while Earth brings their growth to completion. The Dui trigram aligns with mid-autumn, when all things reach maturity but have not yet withered—thus, all beings rejoice in the harvest, oblivious to impending decay. The northwest belongs to yin, yet the Qian trigram (symbolizing Heaven and yang) resides there, representing the struggle between yin and yang—like waning yang resisting the ascendant yin.
The Kan trigram is the northern trigram, where all things return to rest and recuperation, as if comforted. The Gen trigram signifies cessation—without the pause of qi (vital energy), nothing can be accomplished; without the stillness of time, nothing can grow. Cessation marks both the endpoint of achievement and the beginning of renewal. Thus, the Gen trigram is the key to the completion and renewal of all things in Heaven and Earth, as well as the foundation of the sage’s learning—beginning and ending with purpose.
Next, the passage describes the trigrams’ effects on all things:
- Thunder (Zhen) most powerfully stirs all beings.
- Wind (Xun) most thoroughly scours all things.
- Fire (Li) most effectively dries them.
- Lake (Dui) most delights them.
- Water (Kan) most nourishes them.
- Mountain (Gen) most decisively ends and renews them.
Fire and water complement each other; thunder and wind do not conflict; mountain and lake share their qi—only through such interactions can transformation and generation occur.
The trigrams’ inherent qualities are then explained:
- Qian: firm and strong
- Kun: gentle and yielding
- Zhen: stirring and dynamic
- Xun: penetrating and entering
- Kan: perilous and sinking
- Li: clinging and luminous
- Gen: halting and still
- Dui: joyful and harmonious
They also correspond to animals:
- Qian: horse
- Kun: ox
- Zhen: dragon
- Xun: fowl
- Kan: pig
- Li: pheasant
- Gen: dog
- Dui: sheep
In the human body, they align with specific parts:
- Qian: head
- Kun: abdomen
- Zhen: feet
- Xun: thighs
- Kan: ears
- Li: eyes
- Gen: hands
- Dui: mouth
Finally, the trigrams represent familial relationships:
- Qian, as Heaven, is called the father.
- Kun, as Earth, is called the mother.
The Zhen trigram, obtained from the first yang line, is the eldest son.
The Xun trigram, obtained from the first yin line, is the eldest daughter.
The Kan trigram, obtained from the second yang line, is the middle son.
The Li trigram, obtained from the second yin line, is the middle daughter.
The Gen trigram, obtained from the third yang line, is the youngest son.
The Dui trigram, obtained from the third yin line, is the youngest daughter.
This passage primarily explains the natural phenomena, human affairs, and characteristics symbolized by the Eight Trigrams (Bagua) — Qian (Heaven), Kun (Earth), Zhen (Thunder), Xun (Wind/Wood), Kan (Water), Li (Fire), Gen (Mountain), and Dui (Marsh). Each trigram corresponds to multiple symbolic meanings, encompassing both concrete objects and abstract concepts.
The Qian trigram represents Heaven, symbolizing circular shapes, rulers, fathers, jade, metal, coldness, ice, bright red colors, as well as fine horses, aged horses, lean horses, dappled horses, and tree fruits.
The Kun trigram represents Earth, symbolizing mothers, cloth, cooking pots, stinginess, equilibrium, cows, large carts, cultural refinement, the masses, and handles. In terms of color, it represents black.
The Zhen trigram represents Thunder, symbolizing dragons, bluish-yellow hues, flowers, broad roads, eldest sons, impatience, green bamboo, and reeds. For horses, it denotes those good at neighing, with white hind hooves, swift runners, or white foreheads. For crops, it represents inverted growth (roots facing upward). Ultimately, it symbolizes vigor and lush freshness.
The Xun trigram represents Wood and Wind, symbolizing eldest daughters, straightness, craftsmen, mortars, length, height, indecisiveness, hesitation, and odors. In humans, it indicates thinning hair, broad foreheads, and prominent eye whites. For benefits, it suggests tripled market profits. Its final manifestation is an impatient disposition.
The Kan trigram represents Water, symbolizing ditches, concealment, curvature, bows, and wheels. In humans, it signifies excessive worry, heart ailments, or ear pain. Its color is red. For horses, it denotes beautiful spines, anxious temperaments, lowered heads, thin hooves, or sluggishness. For carts, it indicates frequent misfortunes. It also symbolizes the moon, thieves, and—for trees—hardness with dense cores.
The Li trigram represents Fire, symbolizing the sun, lightning, middle daughters, armor, and weapons. In humans, it denotes large bellies. It also represents dryness, as well as turtles, crabs, snails, clams, and tortoises. For trees, it indicates withered upper sections.
The Gen trigram represents Mountains, symbolizing narrow paths, small stones, gate towers, melons, gatekeepers, fingers, dogs, rats, and black-mouthed animals. For trees, it signifies hardness with numerous knots.
The Dui trigram represents Marshes, symbolizing youngest daughters, shamans, speech, destruction, and decisive judgments. For land, it indicates hard saline soil. It also represents concubines and sheep.
The passage concludes by observing that the Xun trigram, though gentle by nature, ultimately becomes impatient; the Kan trigram, though perilous by nature, ultimately achieves smoothness—just as wind at its peak turns violent, and overflowing water begins to flow. Thus, those superior to ordinary people compete in the world, while those inferior to them excel at adapting to circumstances. The refined Qi (energy) of Yin-Yang is released through water, while its breath disperses as wind. This is why the Kan trigram symbolizes thieves—secretly appropriating the Qi of Yin-Yang.
The Xun hexagram in the Book of Changes represents the quality of deep penetration, capable of initiating the interaction between Yin and Yang energies. The essence (Jing) of humans and all things can dissipate through mental activity—thus excessive intellectual exertion actually steals away one's vital essence. The sages understood the principle of "withdrawing and storing in secrecy" (gathering the spirit and returning to stillness) precisely to preserve their essential vitality from being depleted and to stabilize their Qi from external disturbances.
(The phrase "Xun's compliance and Kan's peril" refers to how the Xun hexagram symbolizes compliance while the Kan hexagram represents danger, hinting at the risks of overusing intellect.)
Chapter Eleven explains the sequential evolution of the hexagrams:
First came Heaven and Earth, after which the myriad things could grow. What fills the space between Heaven and Earth is nothing but the myriad things, hence the Zhun hexagram follows, representing a state of abundance. In their initial growth, all things are inevitably in a state of ignorance, hence the Meng hexagram follows, symbolizing tender immaturity. Young life requires nourishment, giving rise to the Xu hexagram, which speaks of the principles of nourishment through food and drink.
With the distribution of sustenance comes contention, hence the Song hexagram appears. Disputes lead to collective conflict, so the Shi hexagram follows, representing the gathering of multitudes. When people gather, relationships of closeness and distance emerge, giving rise to the Bi hexagram, symbolizing intimate attachment. Such bonds require accumulation and maintenance, hence the Xiao Xu hexagram appears. When material accumulation reaches a certain level, ritual norms become necessary, leading to the Lü hexagram (symbolizing adherence to propriety). Only by following ritual can there be peace, hence the Tai hexagram follows, representing smooth progress.
But nothing remains forever smooth, so the Pi hexagram follows (symbolizing obstruction). Obstruction cannot last indefinitely either, hence the Tong Ren hexagram follows (symbolizing human harmony). When people live in harmony, resources naturally gather, giving rise to the Da You hexagram. In times of abundance, one must not become complacent, hence the Qian hexagram follows. Wealth accompanied by humility inevitably brings joy, so the Yu hexagram appears (symbolizing delight). Joy attracts followers, hence the Sui hexagram. Following others out of pleasure inevitably creates complications, so the Gu hexagram follows (symbolizing the resolution of troubles).
Only after resolving complications can expansion occur, hence the Lin hexagram appears (symbolizing growth). When things grow, they attract attention, giving rise to the Guan hexagram. Being observed leads to aggregation, so the Shi Ke hexagram follows (symbolizing biting union). Things cannot unite arbitrarily, hence the Bi hexagram appears (symbolizing ornamentation). Excessive adornment leads to decline, so the Bo hexagram follows (symbolizing peeling away). Yet decline cannot continue endlessly—when exhausted, things return, hence the Fu hexagram appears (symbolizing return).
Returning to the proper path eliminates delusion, so the Wu Wang hexagram follows. Without delusion, accumulation becomes possible, giving rise to the Da Xu hexagram. Sufficient accumulation enables nourishment, hence the Yi hexagram appears (symbolizing nurturing). Without proper nurturing, action becomes impossible, so the Da Guo hexagram follows (symbolizing excess). But nothing remains in perpetual excess... (The subsequent evolution of hexagrams follows the same principle, embodying the cyclical law of things reversing upon reaching their extremes.)
In the Book of Changes (Yijing), the "Kan hexagram" represents peril and entrapment. When trapped in difficulty, one must seek support, hence it is followed by the "Li hexagram," where Li symbolizes attachment and illumination.
The cosmic evolutionary sequence unfolds as follows: First comes heaven and earth, then the myriad things emerge. With the myriad things comes the distinction between male and female; the union of male and female forms the husband-wife relationship. From husband and wife come children, establishing the father-son relationship. The father-son relationship extends to the distinction between ruler and subject; with ruler and subject comes hierarchy and social order. Once social hierarchy is established, rituals and norms arise. The way of husband and wife requires enduring stability, hence it is followed by the "Heng hexagram," where Heng represents constancy. But nothing can remain unchanged forever, so next comes the "Dun hexagram," where Dun signifies retreat. Yet retreat cannot last indefinitely either, hence the "Dazhuang hexagram" appears, symbolizing renewed vigor.
When things reach their peak, they must advance, hence the "Jin hexagram," where Jin denotes progress. In progress, injury is inevitable, so next comes the "Mingyi hexagram," where Yi means wounded. After being wounded abroad, one must return home to recuperate, hence the "Jiaren hexagram" appears. When family relations deteriorate, conflict arises—this is the "Kui hexagram," where Kui signifies estrangement. Escalating conflict leads to hardship, hence the "Jian hexagram," where Jian represents adversity. But hardship does not last forever, so next comes the "Xie hexagram," where Xie means relief. Excessive relief brings loss, hence the "Sun hexagram." When diminishment reaches its limit, it turns to increase—this is the "Yi hexagram." Excessive increase leads to rupture, hence the "Guai hexagram," where Guai denotes decisive action. After decisive action comes new opportunity—this is the "Gou hexagram," where Gou signifies encounter. When all things encounter one another, they gather, hence the "Cui hexagram," where Cui means gathering. Gathering that ascends is the "Sheng hexagram." Unceasing ascent leads to predicament, hence the "Kun hexagram." When those above are trapped, they must return to the foundation—this is the "Jing hexagram." A well requires constant cleansing and renewal, so next comes the "Ge hexagram," symbolizing revolution. The vessel that best represents revolution is the cauldron, hence the "Ding hexagram." The one who presides over sacrificial vessels should be the eldest son, so next comes the "Zhen hexagram," where Zhen signifies shaking. Things cannot shake forever—they must stop, hence the "Gen hexagram," where Gen means stillness. But stillness too cannot last indefinitely, so next comes the "Jian hexagram," where Jian denotes gradual progress. Gradual progress must have a destination, hence the "Guimei hexagram." Finding the right destination brings prosperity—this is the "Feng hexagram," where Feng represents abundance. At the height of prosperity comes decline, and one loses one's dwelling—hence the "Lü hexagram." When traveling with no place to rest, humility and adaptation are needed—this is the "Xun hexagram," where Xun signifies entering. Adapting to the environment brings joy, hence the "Dui hexagram," where Dui denotes delight.
The "Huan Hexagram" (Dispersion) in the Book of Changes symbolizes separation, but nothing remains divided forever, hence it is followed by the "Jie Hexagram" (Restraint) to impose limits. With restraint comes the establishment of sincerity, giving rise to the "Zhongfu Hexagram" (Inner Truth); those with sincerity will inevitably take action, thus producing the "Xiaoguo Hexagram" (Small Excess); only through recognizing faults can one correct them, leading to the "Jiji Hexagram" (After Completion); yet the progression of things knows no end, concluding ultimately with the "Weiji Hexagram" (Before Completion).
The "Treatise on the Miscellaneous Hexagrams" elucidates through contrasting characteristics:
The Qian Hexagram (Heaven) is robust and vigorous, while Kun (Earth) is gentle and yielding; Bi (Union) brings joy, Shi (Army) brings worry. Lin (Approach) and Guan (Contemplation) represent giving and receiving respectively. Zhun (Birth Throes) manifests without losing its position, Meng (Youthful Folly) appears mixed yet distinct. Zhen (Thunder) signifies initiation, Gen (Mountain) signifies cessation; Sun (Decrease) and Yi (Increase) mark the beginnings of waxing and waning. Daxu (Great Accumulation) seizes opportunities, Wuwang (Innocence) guards against calamity.
Cui (Gathering) assembles, Sheng (Ascending) does not return; Qian (Modesty) appears frivolous, Yu (Enthusiasm) tends toward laxity. Shike (Biting Through) concerns nourishment, while Bi (Grace) disregards outward appearances. Dui (Lake) reveals, Xun (Wind) conceals; Sui (Following) flows naturally, Gu (Decay) requires rectification. Bo (Splitting Apart) decays, Fu (Return) brings renewal; Jin (Advance) is like daylight, Mingyi (Darkening) resembles night. Jing (Well) flows freely, Kun (Oppression) encounters obstacles; Xian (Influence) acts swiftly, Heng (Duration) endures.
Huan (Dispersion) scatters, Jie (Limitation) restrains; Xie (Release) eases, Jian (Obstruction) brings hardship. Kui (Opposition) separates externally, Jiaren (Family) unites internally; Pi (Standstill) and Tai (Peace) are polar opposites. Dazhuang (Great Strength) knows moderation, Dun (Retreat) understands withdrawal. Dayou (Great Possession) gains multitudes, Tongren (Fellowship) gains intimacy; Ge (Revolution) discards the old, Ding (Cauldron) establishes the new. Xiaoguo (Small Excess) contains faults, Zhongfu (Inner Truth) values sincerity; Feng (Abundance) brings frequent changes, Lü (Traveler) lacks close ties.
Li (Fire) flames upward, Kan (Water) flows downward; Xiaoxu (Small Accumulation) gathers little, Lü (Treading) does not linger. Xu (Waiting) avoids rashness, Song (Conflict) maintains distance; Daguo (Great Excess) overturns, Gou (Encounter) brings meeting (the yielding meets the firm). Jian (Gradual Progress) resembles a maiden awaiting marriage, Yi (Nourishment) cultivates upright Qi; Jiji (After Completion) brings stability, Guimei (Marrying Maiden) marks feminine fulfillment. Weiji (Before Completion) represents masculine adversity, while Guai (Breakthrough) decides (the firm resolves the yielding), symbolizing the growth of the noble path and decline of petty ways.
The "Postscript to Explanations of the Changes" observes: The Book of Changes is the work of sages, comprehensible only to sages themselves. Later scholars who cannot grasp its meaning yet force interpretations inevitably distort the text, each bending the sage's intent to personal views, thereby obscuring the original wisdom further. Among all classics, the Six Classics stand supreme: the Book of Documents preserves historical records, the Book of Songs collects folk poetry, while the Book of Rites was compiled by Han Confucian scholars.
(Note: Technical terms like "hexagram" are retained, with comparative explanations enhancing comprehension of each hexagram's nature. For parallel structures like the "Treatise on the Miscellaneous Hexagrams," grouped interpretations maintain readability while keeping commentary within 1.5 times the original text's length.)
The Yijing (Book of Changes) stands as a unique classic. While historical texts from the Spring and Autumn period were edited by Confucius, most retained their original wording. Only the Yijing was collectively completed by sages like Fuxi, King Wen, the Duke of Zhou, and Confucius. These sages had already reached the pinnacle of wisdom, and a classic crafted by such minds is naturally flawless—utterly beyond the reach of later generations.
Later scholars, far from attaining the sage's level, presumptuously attempt to interpret their works—a clear case of overestimating themselves. Does this mean no one after Fuxi, King Wen, the Duke of Zhou, or Confucius could truly understand the Yijing? In truth, as long as one employs the wisdom of the sages to interpret their writings, the Yijing can indeed be comprehended. It does not require Fuxi or the others to explain it personally.
Now, reading Yishuo (Discourse on the Changes) by the revered Daoist master Lü Dongbin (known as Lü the Great Immortal in Daoist tradition), one finds insights both original and unprecedented, presented with such clarity that they shine like the sun and moon—illuminating for all to see. This confirms that Master Lü was a true sage, one genuinely capable of interpreting the sages' classics. Even if Fuxi, King Wen, the Duke of Zhou, and Confucius were to explain one another's works, they could not surpass Master Lü's interpretations. It can be said that Yishuo is the Yijing explained through the wisdom of a sage.
I have heard that the original manuscript of Yishuo was kept for many years in the Jade Pine Temple (Yusong Guan) on Mount Yu (in present-day Changshu, Jiangsu), and it was only this winter that Daoist Master Xujing of Guangling (modern Yangzhou) and others printed and circulated it. This shows that the transmission of texts depends on the right timing, conditions, and people. The Yijing was refined over millennia by multiple sages, while Yishuo, completed by Master Lü alone, remained hidden on Mount Yu until now—a marvel in itself. This work will surely endure eternally, just like the Yijing.
The Yijing elucidates the principles of heaven and earth, the cycles of the sun and moon, and the transformations of Yin-Yang. Following its logic, one can derive infinite variations from a single fundamental truth; reversing its application, one can return from complexity to the root. Delving deeply into it reveals the origins of human nature (Xing) and life (Ming) as well as the Dao of Heaven; practicing it leads to the highest attainments of Confucianism, Buddhism, and Daoism.
This passage is Jiang Yuelun's postscript to the Discourse on the Yi (Yi Shuo), which recounts the origins and significance of this classic text.
It begins by extolling the greatness of the Book of Changes (Yijing), recognizing it as the transmission of the ancient sages' core teaching of "refining unity to hold fast to the Mean"—the very truth Confucius realized when he studied the Yi at fifty. Over the centuries, hundreds of scholars have commented on the Yijing, each offering their own interpretations, yet most remained confined to particular aspects: some clung to theories of principle (li) and vital energy (qi), while others rigidly adhered to the techniques of images and numbers (xiangshu). These could only be considered partial views, failing to reveal the profound mystery of how Confucianism, Buddhism, and Daoism share a common origin.
In the spring of the Renzhi year, Jiang Yuelun's son obtained the Discourse on the Yi, a work authored by Lü Dongbin (the Pure Yang Patriarch). After studying it repeatedly dozens of times, he discovered that this text truly elucidates the unspoken depths of the three sages—Fuxi, King Wen, and Confucius—and synthesizes the wondrous principles revered by all sages. As the elder Xu Jun'an had already expounded in detail in his own postscript, Jiang saw no need for further praise.
Later, when preparing a new edition, they found that half a page on the Jian hexagram was missing, and for years it remained incomplete. It was not until the Jiuwei year that, by a stroke of fate, the missing portion was finally recovered, allowing the text to be restored in full. Jiang regarded this as perfectly timed for the revised edition, a rare and auspicious coincidence.
Finally, he reflects on how the ancient sages revealed subtle truths through the drawing of hexagrams, yet later scholars fragmented images and numbers from their underlying principles. Many historical works on the Yi—such as those by Ge Hong, Tao Hongjing, and Yuan Tiangang—have been lost, perhaps preserved as secret treasures in the celestial realms. But Lü Dongbin (the Blessed Sovereign of Fuyou)'s Discourse on the Yi not only clarifies the patterns of heavenly Dao but also aligns with human ethics and daily life, unveiling the true essence of the Mean and the fundamental principles of divine transformation.
(Note: "Pure Yang Patriarch" and "Blessed Sovereign of Fuyou" are honorific titles for Lü Dongbin; the "three sages" refer to Fuxi, King Wen, and Confucius; "golden rules and jade scriptures" denote precious Daoist texts.)
The Yishuo scripture reveals the principles of initiating things and accomplishing undertakings, as well as the wisdom of divining the future by calculating the past. It requires no deliberate study to comprehend the supreme realm, for a single fundamental principle runs through its entirety. Compared to works like Yanyuan, Dongji, Yuanbao, and Bianxu, the Yishuo truly stands in a class of its own.
(Junyuan humbly states:) As someone as ignorant and oblivious to the great Dao (the Way) as myself, I can hardly glimpse its profound mysteries. I can only recite it repeatedly and study it diligently, yet I always feel its wisdom is inexhaustible. As the saying goes: A person may live their whole life beneath the heavens yet never know how high the heavens are; they may tread upon the earth their entire life yet never fathom how deep the earth is. If one goes to the rivers and seas with only a small gourd or ladle to scoop water, drinks their fill, and departs, how could they ever understand the depths of those waters? Facing this Yishuo scripture now, I feel exactly the same. All I can do is bow reverently and write this postscript.
Source text: Kanripo 漢籍リポジトリ(KR5i0052); Licence: CC BY-SA 4.0 · Report an error / feedback